≡ Menu

In this series, I will be looking at the history of coaches, quarterbacks, rushers, and receivers for all 32 franchises. For coaches and quarterbacks, I will be looking at how much their franchise’s career records (regular season only) would change if we removed the games with that person. For rushers and receivers, I will note how many times that player was the team’s leading rusher/receiver over the course of their time with that franchise (regular plus postseason).

Previous Teams:

Dolphins
Cowboys

The Buffalo Bills have had a lot of disappointing coaches in their history — I’m looking at you, Harvey Johnson — and only a few good ones. Just four have winning records, although that’s not the worst by AFC East standards. In many divisions, Marv Levy would be considered a strong candidate for the best coach in division history. In the AFC East, he’s relegated to third. But when it comes to Bills coaches, nobody can match his record:

Ovr RkCoachGWLTHC Win %FrGFrWFLFrTFr W%Win% w/o HCDiff
9Marv Levy1821127000.61590041547780.4660.4283.8%
36Lou Saban117684540.59890041547780.4660.4462%
78Wade Phillips48291900.60490041547780.4660.4580.8%
113Chuck Knox73373600.50790041547780.4660.4620.4%
164Rex Ryan31151600.48490041547780.4660.4650.1%
182Sean McDermott32151700.46990041547780.4660.4650%
183Doug Marrone32151700.46990041547780.4660.4650%
201Perry Fewell73400.42990041547780.4660.4660%
209Anthony Lynn1010090041547780.4660.466-0.1%
210Joe Collier30131610.4590041547780.4660.466-0.1%
237Mike Mularkey32141800.43890041547780.4660.467-0.1%
272Buster Ramsey28111610.41190041547780.4660.467-0.2%
323Dick Jauron57243300.42190041547780.4660.469-0.3%
406Gregg Williams48173100.35490041547780.4660.472-0.6%
408John Rauch2872010.26890041547780.4660.472-0.6%
416Hank Bullough2141700.1990041547780.4660.472-0.7%
434Chan Gailey48163200.33390041547780.4660.473-0.7%
442Kay Stephenson36102600.27890041547780.4660.473-0.8%
456Jim Ringo2332000.1390041547780.4660.474-0.9%
481Harvey Johnson2622310.09690041547780.4660.477-1.1%

You won’t be surprised to see the results at quarterback, either. Jim Kelly stands out as the most successful quarterback in franchise history by this methodology, although I’ll note that Doug Flutie actually has him beat on winning percentage. Meanwhile, Dennis Shaw is the man whose done the most harm to the franchise’s career winning percentage. As always, I also recommend sorting the table by games started.

Ovr RkQBGWLTQB Win %FrGFrWFLFrTFr W%Win% w/o QBDiff
8Jim Kelly1601015900.63190041547780.4660.4303.6%
58Jack Kemp77433130.57890041547780.4660.4551.1%
77Doug Flutie3021900.70090041547780.4660.4570.8%
153Tyrod Taylor42222000.52490041547780.4660.4630.3%
174Daryle Lamonica44001.00090041547780.4660.4630.2%
184Warren Rabb106310.65090041547780.4660.4630.2%
217Kyle Orton127500.58390041547780.4660.4640.2%
224Joe Ferguson163778600.47290041547780.4660.4640.2%
288Drew Bledsoe48232500.47990041547780.4660.4650.1%
296M.C. Reynolds32100.66790041547780.4660.4650.1%
307Bob Brodhead11001.00090041547780.4660.4650.1%
308Brian McClure11001.00090041547780.4660.4650.1%
309Matt Cassel11001.00090041547780.4660.4650.1%
310Matt Barkley11001.00090041547780.4660.4650.1%
381Frank Reich84400.50090041547780.4660.4650%
382Kelly Holcomb84400.50090041547780.4660.4650%
464Johnny Green115600.45590041547780.4660.4660%
465Josh Allen115600.45590041547780.4660.4660%
498Thaddeus Lewis52300.40090041547780.4660.4660%
506Tom Flores41210.37590041547780.4660.4660%
518Richie Lucas31200.33390041547780.4660.4660%
577Leo Hart10100.00090041547780.4660.466-0.1%
578Dan Manucci10100.00090041547780.4660.466-0.1%
579Willie Totten10100.00090041547780.4660.466-0.1%
580Jeff Tuel10100.00090041547780.4660.466-0.1%
581LeSean McCoy10100.00090041547780.4660.466-0.1%
582Derek Anderson10100.00090041547780.4660.466-0.1%
717Nathan Peterman41300.25090041547780.4660.467-0.1%
743Trent Edwards32141800.43890041547780.4660.467-0.1%
745Todd Collins1771000.41290041547780.4660.467-0.1%
746Brian Brohm20200.00090041547780.4660.467-0.1%
833Joe Dufek51400.20090041547780.4660.467-0.1%
864Ed Rutkowski30300.00090041547780.4660.467-0.2%
865Kay Stephenson30300.00090041547780.4660.467-0.2%
866James Harris30300.00090041547780.4660.467-0.2%
927Tommy O'Connell71510.21490041547780.4660.468-0.2%
943Al Dorow40400.00090041547780.4660.468-0.2%
953EJ Manuel1761100.35390041547780.4660.468-0.2%
974Alex Van Pelt113800.27390041547780.4660.468-0.2%
995Bruce Mathison71600.14390041547780.4660.468-0.3%
1066Rob Johnson2691700.34690041547780.4660.469-0.4%
1073Vince Ferragamo91800.11190041547780.4660.469-0.4%
1075Gary Marangi70700.00090041547780.4660.469-0.4%
1115Dan Darragh1111000.09190041547780.4660.470-0.5%
1138Ryan Fitzpatrick53203300.37790041547780.4660.471-0.6%
1150J.P. Losman33102300.30390041547780.4660.472-0.6%
1194Dennis Shaw3782720.24390041547780.4660.475-1%

The Bills have two Hall of Fame running backs, and both easily chart the tops here. It’s a testament to the great undrafted free agent running back Fred Jackson that he ranks third, and led the Bills in rushing yards in over half of his games (despite being a starter in under half of them).

RusherFirst YrLast YrLeading RusherTotal Games%
Thurman Thomas1988199913419469%
O.J. Simpson196919779311382%
Fred Jackson200720145810655%
Joe Cribbs19801985526778%
Travis Henry20012004435480%
LeSean McCoy20152018385866%
Willis McGahee20042006384683%
Wray Carlton19601967369040%
Cookie Gilchrist19621964324473%
Marshawn Lynch20072010324571%
Greg Bell19841987314078%
Antowain Smith19972000285947%
C.J. Spiller20102014277238%
Terry Miller19781980154732%
Kenneth Davis198919941511014%
Curtis Brown19771982157919%
Roland Hooks197619821110111%
Shawn Bryson20002002103727%
Darick Holmes19951998105120%
Robb Riddick19811988108212%

Buffalo had a great run at the wide receiver position that scanned over two decades. Andre Reed was a star for 15 years, was replaced by the always underrated Eric Moulds, and even Lee Evans stood out as a strong wide receiver despite playing on awful passing offenses.

ReceiverFirst YrLast YrLeading ReceiverTotal Games%
Andre Reed198519999624240%
Eric Moulds199620056715743%
Lee Evans200420104610942%
Bob Chandler197119794011734%
Elbert Dubenion196019683910637%
Frank Lewis19781983378345%
Steve Johnson20082013287637%
Jerry Butler19791986289131%
J.D. Hill19711975266242%
Peerless Price19992007188521%
Marlin Briscoe19691971174141%
Josh Reed200220091711515%
Sammy Watkins20142016163743%
Haven Moses19681972165927%
James Lofton19891992167023%
Glenn Bass19611966157221%
Bill Brooks19931995135225%
Chris Burkett19851989135723%
Charles Clay20152018125522%
Thurman Thomas19881999121946%
Robert Woods20132016115719%
Don Beebe19891994118713%
Paul Costa196519721110211%
Fred Jackson200720141110610%
Byron Franklin19811984104522%
O.J. Simpson19691977101139%

That’s it for the Buffalo version of this series. Please leave your thoughts in the comments.

{ 0 comments }