≡ Menu

In this series, I will be looking at the history of coaches, quarterbacks, rushers, and receivers for all 32 franchises. For coaches and quarterbacks, I will be looking at how much their franchise’s career records (regular season only) would change if we removed the games with that person. For rushers and receivers, I will note how many times that player was the team’s leading rusher/receiver over the course of their time with that franchise (regular plus postseason).

Previous Teams:

AFC East: Dolphins, Bills, Jets, and Patriots
NFC East: Cowboys, Eagles, Giants, and Redskins
AFC North: Steelers, Browns, Ravens, and Bengals
NFC North: Packers, Vikings, Bears

The Detroit Lions began as the Portsmouth Spartans before the Great Depression led to a sale and a five hour move north out of Ohio. Depressing is also a good way to describe much of the Lions history, too. The best coach in Detroit football history is… ??? Well, that’s probably a question most modern fans can’t answer. Potsy Clark won a title with the team in Portsmouth, while Buddy Parker helped guide the team to two titles in the ’50s, with George Wilson being the head coach for a third championship in ’57. And asking who the worst coach in Lions history isn’t an easy one, either: four men finished their tenures at 20 games below .500. The table below shows the full list, and you can see how each man changed the team’s all-time record:

Ovr RkCoachGWLTHC Win %FrGFrWFLFrTFr W%Win% w/o HCDiff
43Potsy Clark85532570.6651249559658320.460.4451.5%
52Buddy Parker72472320.6671249559658320.460.4481.3%
79George Wilson104534560.5381249559658320.460.4530.7%
82Joe Schmidt84433470.5541249559658320.460.4540.7%
91Jim Caldwell64362800.5631249559658320.460.4550.6%
103Wayne Fontes133666700.4961249559658320.460.4560.4%
118Dutch Clark2214800.6361249559658320.460.4570.3%
161Gus Henderson116500.5451249559658320.460.460.1%
167Bobby Ross57273000.4741249559658320.460.460.1%
168Gary Moeller74300.5711249559658320.460.460.1%
180Rick Forzano32151700.4691249559658320.460.460%
188Don McCafferty146710.4641249559658320.460.460%
189Hal Griffen145630.4641249559658320.460.460%
194Tommy Hudspeth24111300.4581249559658320.460.460%
238Dick Jauron51400.21249559658320.460.461-0.1%
240Matt Patricia1661000.3751249559658320.460.461-0.1%
263Harry Gilmer28101620.3931249559658320.460.462-0.2%
265Bill Edwards144910.3211249559658320.460.462-0.2%
317Gus Dorais53203120.3961249559658320.460.463-0.3%
320Bull Karcis808001249559658320.460.463-0.3%
353Bo McMillin36122400.3331249559658320.460.464-0.4%
357Steve Mariucci43152800.3491249559658320.460.464-0.4%
363Monte Clark105436110.4141249559658320.460.465-0.4%
420Jim Schwartz80295100.3631249559658320.460.467-0.7%
430Darryl Rogers58184000.311249559658320.460.468-0.7%
445Marty Mornhinweg3252700.1561249559658320.460.468-0.8%
475Rod Marinelli48103800.2081249559658320.460.47-1%

At quarterback, Bobby Layne stands out from the pack in the exact way you would expect. The Hall of Fame quarterback from the ’50s posted a 0.643 winning percentage with the Lions; all other quarterbacks for Detroit since 1950 have combined for a 0.435 winning percentage. Remarkably, there have been 8 quarterbacks to start at least 50 games for the Lions since 1950, and 7 of the 8 have a losing record. Joey Harrington gets the blame for hurting the team’s overall winning percentage the most: it would be 0.460 since 1950 without him, instead of the 0.452 that it actually is.

Ovr RkQBGWLTQB Win %FrGFrWFLFrTFr W%Win% w/o QBDiff
36Bobby Layne84532920.6431018451548190.4520.4351.7%
120Bill Munson48242130.5311018451548190.4520.4480.4%
130Earl Morrall26151010.5961018451548190.4520.4490.4%
131Greg Landry84404130.4941018451548190.4520.4490.4%
145Erik Kramer1510500.6671018451548190.4520.4490.3%
169Matthew Stafford141667500.4681018451548190.4520.4500.3%
177Eric Hipple57282900.4911018451548190.4520.4500.2%
203Dave Krieg75200.7141018451548190.4520.4510.2%
212Tom Dublinski54100.8001018451548190.4520.4510.2%
219Milt Plum52232540.4811018451548190.4520.4510.2%
235Jim Ninowski189810.5281018451548190.4520.4510.1%
239Scott Mitchell57273000.4741018451548190.4520.4510.1%
258Bob Gagliano116500.5451018451548190.4520.4510.1%
300George Izo32100.6671018451548190.4520.4520.1%
314Joe Reed126600.5001018451548190.4520.4520.1%
325Stoney Case11001.0001018451548190.4520.4520.1%
392Andre Ware63300.5001018451548190.4520.4520%
399Drew Stanton42200.5001018451548190.4520.4520%
413Don Majkowski21100.5001018451548190.4520.4520%
434Gary Danielson52232810.4521018451548190.4520.4520%
474Karl Sweetan166820.4381018451548190.4520.4530%
476Joe Ferguson52300.4001018451548190.4520.4530%
481Rodney Peete47212600.4471018451548190.4520.4530%
495Todd Hons31200.3331018451548190.4520.4530%
507Tobin Rote2391220.4351018451548190.4520.4530%
521John Witkowski10100.0001018451548190.4520.4530%
519Jim Hardy10100.0001018451548190.4520.4530%
520Jerry Golsteyn10100.0001018451548190.4520.4530%
675Gus Frerotte62400.3331018451548190.4520.453-0.1%
683Ty Detmer41300.2501018451548190.4520.453-0.1%
705Frank Reich20200.0001018451548190.4520.453-0.1%
704Harry Gilmer20200.0001018451548190.4520.453-0.1%
757Rusty Hilger93600.3331018451548190.4520.453-0.1%
798Jeff Garcia51400.2001018451548190.4520.454-0.1%
847Shaun Hill103700.3001018451548190.4520.454-0.2%
914Charlie Batch46192700.4131018451548190.4520.454-0.2%
950Mike McMahon71600.1431018451548190.4520.455-0.2%
1045Dan Orlovsky70700.0001018451548190.4520.455-0.3%
1107Daunte Culpepper1001000.0001018451548190.4520.457-0.4%
1129Jeff Komlo1621400.1251018451548190.4520.458-0.5%
1137Chuck Long2141700.1901018451548190.4520.458-0.6%
1153Jon Kitna36102600.2781018451548190.4520.459-0.6%
1170Joey Harrington55183700.3271018451548190.4520.460-0.7%

Oklahoma State’s Barry Sanders is obviously the best running back in Lions history, and he led Detroit in rushing yards in 152 games (regular plus postseason, combined). That’s third to only Emmitt Smith and Walter Payton in terms of production with one team. But consider that Sanders played in fewer games than those two: Only Curtis Martin (92%, 130 games) with the Jets and Edgerrin James (96%, 101 games) with the Colts played at least 100 games with one team and led that team in rushing yards in at least 90% of their games. Billy Sims, from rival Oklahoma, is the second best rusher the team has had since at least 1950 (Detroit had some good ones before then, including Dutch Clark. And if not for a brutal knee injury, Sims might have become a Hall of Famer, too.

RusherFirst YrLast YrLeading RusherTotal Games%
Barry Sanders1989199815215996%
Billy Sims19801984536285%
James Jones19831988428649%
Kevin Jones20042007405375%
Nick Pietrosante19591965408845%
James Stewart20002002374190%
Dexter Bussey197419843615224%
Kevin Smith20082012355564%
Mel Farr19671973337047%
Altie Taylor19691975339236%
Joique Bell20122016266540%
Bob Hoernschemeyer19501955256340%
Ameer Abdullah20152018233566%
Steve Owens19701974225441%
Dan Lewis19581964208424%
Garry James19861988184045%
Jahvid Best20102012152268%
Horace King197519831512512%
Reggie Bush20132014132650%
Bobby Layne195019581310113%
Theo Riddick20132018138515%
Maurice Morris20092011124527%
Lew Carpenter19531955123732%
Rick Kane197719851211510%
Greg Landry196819781210312%
John Henry Johnson19571959113333%
Shawn Bryson20032006115420%
Doak Walker19501955117115%
Tom Watkins19621967106416%
Mikel Leshoure20122013101759%

Detroit has had two great, Hall of Fame caliber players at wide receiver: Calvin Johnson is as physically gifted as any athlete to ever play the position, while Herman Moore is a player whose production exceeded his reputation. Still, he wasn’t Megatron, and that’s not a criticism of anyone.

ReceiverFirst YrLast YrLeading ReceiverTotal Games%
Calvin Johnson200720158413761%
Herman Moore199120015815238%
Brett Perriman19911996369936%
Johnnie Morton199420013412926%
Gail Cogdill196019683310332%
Freddie Scott19781983318835%
Charlie Sanders196819773012923%
Roy Williams20042008276045%
Jeff Chadwick19831989277436%
Terry Barr195719652710426%
Leonard Thompson197519862517714%
Golden Tate20142018217329%
David Hill197619822110121%
Jim Gibbons195819682014014%
Germane Crowell19982002195535%
Dave Middleton19551960196529%
Jim Doran19511959199520%
Marvin Jones20162018184144%
Pat Studstill19611967187723%
Larry Walton19691976189619%
Dorne Dibble19511957177224%
Earl McCullouch19681973177323%
Robert Clark19891991164734%
Ray Jarvis19741978165728%
Cloyce Box19491954156125%
Az-Zahir Hakim20022006144233%
Willie Green19911993135026%
Richard Johnson19891990123238%
Ron Jessie19711974125422%
Doak Walker19501955127117%
Pete Mandley19841988127416%
Mark Nichols19811987127716%
Billy Sims19801984116218%
Leon Hart19501957109810%

That’s it for the Detroit version of this series. Please leave your thoughts in the comments.

{ 0 comments }