≡ Menu

Positive Air Yards per Attempt: 2017 Update

Adam Steele is back for another guest post. You can view all of Adam’s posts here. As always, we thank him for contributing.


Positive Yards Per Attempt: 2017 Update

If I could only share one thing from my time doing football analytics, it would be the following principle: Positive plays carry more weight than negative plays in determining the winner of a football game. I’ve already written a couple of articles on this subject and hope to further the cause with this update.

Overview

For those of you who don’t feel like reading the previous two posts, I’ll give you the basic gist. Since passing has a far greater impact on winning than running, I’ve focused my research on quarterbacks, but the principle applies to the entire offense (defense, not so sure). Despite everyone constantly harping on turnover avoidance, a potent passing offense is usually able to overcome giveaways. Conversely, avoiding turnovers is normally not enough to overcome a weak passing game. Furthermore, turnovers are highly random and situation dependent, so it follows that turnovers are a very poor method of gauging quarterback performance. Even though sacks are largely the quarterback’s fault, they are also very context dependent and only contribute a small amount in determining game outcomes. More importantly, the majority of signal callers trade sacks for interceptions or vice versa, so it’s no really fair to include one but not the other.

Here is my new formula for Positive Yards Per Attempt (PY/A):

(Air Yards + YAC / 2 + Passing First Downs x 10 + Passing Touchdowns x 10) / Pass Attempts

This metric captures the frequency and magnitude of a quarterback’s positive plays while ignoring the negative ones (sacks and interceptions). I only give half credit for YAC because I think it’s more a function of the receivers and system than the QB, and I bump the traditional first down bonus up to 10 yards (it’s usually nine yards) because I consider first downs very important and I prefer the nice, even number. Also, touchdowns are still worth 20 yards, as usual: but all touchdowns are first downs, so the bonus here needs to be lowered to only 10 yards.

Results

I have the necessary data to calculate PY/A back to 1992. Using the standard cutoff of 224 attempts to qualify, this sample yields exactly 800 quarterback seasons. The table is default sorted by Value, which equals (PY/A – League PY/A) x attempts. If you’d prefer to ignore volume, Relative is the quarterback’s PY/A compared to league average. Win % represents the team’s win percentage in games started by the QB.

RkQuarterbackYearTeamValuePY/ALgPY/ARelativeAttWin %
1Peyton Manning2004IND181713.099.433.664970.750
2Kurt Warner2001STL160311.888.942.945460.875
3Matt Ryan2016ATL146812.29.452.755340.688
4Peyton Manning2013DEN146811.59.272.236590.813
5Tom Brady2007NWE138911.599.182.405781.000
6Aaron Rodgers2011GNB137712.139.392.745020.933
7Carson Palmer2015ARI1358129.472.535370.813
8Peyton Manning2006IND132911.429.042.395570.750
9Drew Brees2011NOR129111.369.391.966570.813
10Kurt Warner2000STL128012.618.923.693470.727
11Daunte Culpepper2000MIN128011.628.922.704740.688
12Kurt Warner1999STL123111.348.872.474990.813
13Chris Chandler1998ATL122112.839.103.733270.929
14Philip Rivers2010SDG120111.419.192.225410.563
15Peyton Manning2005IND118311.659.042.614530.875
16Steve Young1993SFO118111.488.932.564620.625
17Philip Rivers2009SDG116211.59.112.394860.813
18Tom Brady2011NWE114511.279.391.876110.813
19Drew Brees2009NOR112611.39.112.195140.867
20Randall Cunningham1998MIN110511.79.102.604250.929
21Tony Romo2007DAL108711.279.182.095200.813
22Steve Young1994SFO107011.298.972.324610.813
23Steve McNair2003TEN106811.478.802.674000.714
24Ben Roethlisberger2009PIT102211.139.112.025060.600
25Tony Romo2014DAL100211.729.422.304350.800
26Philip Rivers2008SDG99211.179.092.074780.500
27Daunte Culpepper2004MIN99111.249.431.815480.500
28Peyton Manning2000IND98910.658.921.735710.625
29Aaron Rodgers2014GNB95911.269.421.845200.750
30Peyton Manning2009IND95210.789.111.675710.875
31Tony Romo2006DAL95111.869.042.823370.600
32Steve Young1998SFO94110.929.101.825170.733
33Mark Brunell1996JAX93910.598.901.695570.563
34Matt Schaub2009HOU93910.729.111.615830.563
35Steve Young1992SFO92311.449.152.304020.875
36Philip Rivers2013SDG91910.969.271.695440.563
37Peyton Manning2007IND90010.939.181.755150.813
38Trent Green2004KAN90011.059.431.625560.438
39Peyton Manning2012DEN89210.869.331.535830.813
40Drew Brees2012NOR88110.659.331.326700.438
41Ben Roethlisberger2007PIT86711.339.182.154040.667
42Matt Hasselbeck2005SEA85910.959.041.914490.813
43Brett Favre1995GNB85510.529.021.505700.688
44Carson Palmer2006CIN84010.659.041.615200.500
45Ben Roethlisberger2004PIT82912.249.432.812951.000
46Steve Beuerlein1999CAR82710.328.871.455710.500
47Carson Palmer2005CIN82110.659.041.615090.688
48Jeff George1999MIN81311.348.872.473290.800
49Scott Mitchell1995DET79610.389.021.375830.625
50Brett Favre2009MIN79010.69.111.495310.750
51Brett Favre1997GNB78310.438.911.535130.813
52Steve McNair2001TEN77310.738.941.794310.467
53Nick Foles2013PHI77211.79.272.433170.800
54Peyton Manning1999IND76610.318.871.445330.813
55Eli Manning2011NYG76410.699.391.305890.563
56Ben Roethlisberger2014PIT76010.679.421.256080.688
57Drew Brees2008NOR75510.289.091.196350.500
58Peyton Manning2003IND75110.128.801.335660.750
59Russell Wilson2015SEA75111.029.471.554830.625
60Ben Roethlisberger2005PIT75011.849.042.802680.750
61Peyton Manning2014DEN73710.659.421.235970.750
62Aaron Rodgers2010GNB72810.729.191.534750.667
63Vinny Testaverde1996BAL72310.228.901.325490.250
64Tom Brady2004NWE71710.949.431.514740.875
65Elvis Grbac2000KAN71710.238.921.315470.467
66Cam Newton2015CAR71510.929.471.454950.938
67Chad Pennington2002NYJ71410.78.911.793990.667
68John Elway1998DEN71211.19.102.003560.833
69Ben Roethlisberger2015PIT71210.999.471.524690.636
70Kirk Cousins2016WAS71010.629.451.176060.531
71Steve Young1997SFO70810.898.911.993560.800
72Jim Kelly1992BUF69410.659.151.504620.688
73Aaron Rodgers2009GNB69310.399.111.285410.688
74Trent Green2000STL69011.88.922.882400.400
75Philip Rivers2011SDG68810.579.391.185820.500
76Drew Brees2013NOR67910.319.271.046500.688
77Matt Ryan2012ATL67710.439.331.106150.813
78Brian Griese2000DEN66910.918.921.993360.700
79Troy Aikman1993DAL66110.618.931.693920.786
80Dan Marino1995MIA65310.379.021.354820.643
81Vinny Testaverde1998NYJ65110.649.101.554210.923
82Drew Brees2016NOR65110.429.450.976730.438
83Trent Green2003KAN64010.028.801.225230.813
84Troy Aikman1995DAL63910.59.021.484320.750
85Drew Brees2006NOR63610.199.041.155540.625
86Donovan McNabb2004PHI63410.789.431.354690.867
87Marc Bulger2004STL63210.749.431.304850.571
88Ben Roethlisberger2011PIT63010.629.391.235130.733
89Erik Kramer1995CHI62710.229.021.205220.563
90Tom Brady2010NWE62510.469.191.274920.875
91Jeff Garcia2000SFO62510.048.921.115610.375
92Brett Favre2001GNB61710.158.941.215100.750
93Andrew Luck2016IND61710.589.451.135450.533
94Trent Green2002KAN61510.228.911.314700.500
95Tony Romo2011DAL61410.579.391.185220.500
96Peyton Manning2001IND61210.068.941.125470.375
97Daunte Culpepper2003MIN61210.148.801.354540.500
98Dak Prescott2016DAL61210.789.451.334590.813
99Tom Brady2012NWE60710.289.330.956370.750
100Russell Wilson2013SEA59810.749.271.474070.813
101Tom Brady2009NWE59410.169.111.055650.625
102Tony Romo2009DAL59210.199.111.085500.688
103Eli Manning2009NYG59110.279.111.165090.500
104Brett Favre1998GNB58910.179.101.075510.688
105Chris Chandler1997ATL58410.618.911.713420.500
106Andy Dalton2015CIN58110.989.471.503860.769
107Marc Bulger2003STL5819.898.801.095320.800
108Aaron Rodgers2012GNB57710.389.331.055520.688
109Ben Roethlisberger2010PIT57110.669.191.473890.750
110Andrew Luck2014IND56710.349.420.926160.688
111Jeff Hostetler1993RAI56610.288.931.354190.667
112Kurt Warner2007ARI56110.439.181.244510.455
113Jake Delhomme2008CAR55810.449.091.354140.750
114Kurt Warner2008ARI55810.039.090.935980.563
115Tom Brady2005NWE55710.099.041.055300.625
116Matt Hasselbeck2003SEA5579.888.801.095130.625
117Steve Beuerlein1993PHO55510.258.931.334180.429
118Drew Brees2014NOR54710.259.420.836590.438
119Russell Wilson2012SEA54310.719.331.383930.688
120Chad Pennington2008MIA54110.239.091.144760.688
121Brett Favre2004GNB53910.439.431.005400.625
122Tommy Maddox2002PIT53610.338.911.423770.682
123Marc Bulger2005STL53210.899.041.852870.250
124Brett Favre1996GNB5319.888.900.985430.813
125Trent Green2005KAN52410.079.041.035070.625
126Rich Gannon2002OAK5249.758.910.856180.688
127Matt Ryan2008ATL52110.299.091.204340.688
128Rich Gannon1999OAK5169.878.871.005150.500
129Peyton Manning2008IND51110.029.090.925550.750
130Chris Chandler1999ATL50810.538.871.653070.333
131Brad Johnson1999WAS5089.858.870.985190.625
132Tom Brady2016NWE50510.629.451.174320.917
133Doug Flutie1998BUF50210.529.101.423540.700
134Mark Brunell1997JAX50210.068.911.154350.643
135Dan Marino1992MIA49410.049.150.895540.688
136Peyton Manning2002IND4949.748.910.845910.625
137Drew Bledsoe1998NWE49010.129.101.024810.571
138Jim Harbaugh1995IND48810.579.021.553140.583
139Matt Schaub2010HOU48710.049.190.855740.375
140David Garrard2007JAX48110.669.181.483250.750
141Rich Gannon2000OAK4789.938.921.014730.750
142Dan Marino1994MIA4749.748.970.776150.625
143Robert Griffin2012WAS47010.539.331.203930.600
144Ben Roethlisberger2006PIT46510.039.040.994690.467
145Jeff George1997OAK4639.798.910.895210.250
146Matt Schaub2008HOU46210.319.091.223800.545
147Jameis Winston2016TAM45810.269.450.815670.563
148Eli Manning2010NYG45610.049.190.855390.625
149Jay Cutler2008DEN4539.839.090.746160.500
150Matthew Stafford2011DET45210.079.390.686630.625
151Phil Simms1993NYG44910.058.931.124000.688
152Jameis Winston2015TAM44810.319.470.845350.375
153Kerry Collins2002NYG4459.728.910.825450.625
154Carson Palmer2011OAK44110.749.391.353280.444
155Aaron Rodgers2008GNB4379.919.090.825360.375
156Aaron Rodgers2013GNB43710.779.271.512900.667
157Bobby Hebert1992NOR43510.189.151.034220.750
158Matt Schaub2011HOU43410.889.391.492920.700
159Tony Romo2012DAL4309.999.330.666480.500
160Tyrod Taylor2015BUF42810.69.471.133800.538
161Brett Favre2007GNB4279.989.180.805350.813
162Damon Huard2006KAN42610.789.041.752440.625
163Kurt Warner2009ARI4249.949.110.835130.667
164Drew Bledsoe2002BUF4249.68.910.706100.500
165Jake Plummer2004DEN42110.249.430.815210.625
166Drew Bledsoe2005DAL4199.889.040.844990.563
167Jake Delhomme2004CAR41510.219.430.785330.438
168Carson Palmer2007CIN4149.99.180.725750.438
169Jake Delhomme2005CAR4139.999.040.954350.688
170Steve Young1996SFO41110.28.901.303160.750
171Philip Rivers2006SDG4039.919.040.884600.875
172Donovan McNabb2006PHI40310.319.041.273160.500
173Brett Favre2003GNB4019.658.800.854710.625
174Mark Brunell2000JAX4019.718.920.785120.438
175Gus Frerotte1996WAS3999.758.900.854700.563
176Kirk Cousins2015WAS39910.219.470.745430.563
177Steve McNair2002TEN3979.718.910.814920.688
178Michael Vick2010PHI39110.249.191.053720.727
179John Elway1997DEN3899.688.910.775020.750
180Drew Brees2004SDG38710.49.430.974000.733
181Matt Hasselbeck2002SEA3859.838.910.924190.500
182Jim Kelly1993BUF3859.748.930.824700.750
183Vinny Testaverde1995CLE3829.999.020.973920.333
184Chris Chandler2001ATL3809.988.941.043650.429
185Troy Aikman1992DAL3769.949.150.794730.813
186Jon Kitna2003CIN3749.518.800.725200.500
187Vinny Testaverde1993CLE37110.548.931.612300.500
188John Elway1996DEN3709.698.900.794660.867
189Marc Bulger2006STL3649.669.040.625880.500
190Troy Aikman1994DAL3649.988.971.013610.714
191Derek Anderson2007CLE3629.879.180.695270.667
192Jay Cutler2010CHI36110.039.190.844320.667
193John Elway1995DEN3619.689.020.675420.500
194Mark Brunell2001JAX3589.78.940.764730.400
195Jake Plummer2003DEN3539.968.801.173020.818
196Jay Cutler2007DEN3529.949.180.754670.438
197Jeff George1995ATL3519.659.020.635570.563
198Mark Brunell1998JAX34510.079.100.973540.769
199Donovan McNabb2009PHI3449.899.110.784430.714
200Josh McCown2013CHI34310.89.271.532240.600
201Jake Plummer1997ARI34210.068.911.162960.333
202Drew Brees2005SDG3429.729.040.685000.563
203Ryan Fitzpatrick2014HOU34110.519.421.093120.500
204Philip Rivers2016SDG33910.049.450.595780.313
205Michael Vick2011PHI33910.199.390.804230.538
206Steve Beuerlein1998CAR33810.089.100.993430.333
207Marcus Mariota2016TEN33810.29.450.754510.533
208Jeff George1994ATL3389.618.970.645240.438
209Eli Manning2012NYG3369.969.330.635360.563
210Chad Pennington2003NYJ3369.938.801.132970.444
211Drew Bledsoe1999NWE3359.498.870.625390.500
212John Elway1993DEN3349.538.930.615510.563
213Marcus Mariota2015TEN33210.379.470.903700.250
214Drew Brees2015NOR329109.470.526270.467
215Tony Romo2008DAL3269.829.090.734500.615
216Jeff Garcia2001SFO3269.598.940.655040.750
217Carson Palmer2013ARI3259.849.270.575720.625
218Colin Kaepernick2013SFO32210.049.270.774160.750
219Philip Rivers2014SDG3219.989.420.565700.563
220Bobby Hebert1993ATL3219.678.930.754300.333
221Stan Humphries1995SDG3209.699.020.674780.600
222Peyton Manning2010IND3189.669.190.476790.625
223Matt Ryan2015ATL3139.989.470.516140.500
224Warren Moon1995MIN3139.539.020.526060.500
225Jim Everett1995NOR3129.579.020.555670.438
226Russell Wilson2016SEA31110.029.450.575460.656
227Tom Brady2015NWE3119.979.470.506240.750
228Matt Ryan2011ATL3099.949.390.555660.625
229Dan Marino1996MIA3089.738.900.833730.538
230Brian Griese2002DEN3069.618.910.704360.615
231Brian Griese2004TAM30610.349.430.913360.400
232Warren Moon1992HOU30610.039.150.883460.600
233Jeff Hostetler1994RAI3039.638.970.674550.563
234Blake Bortles2015JAX3009.979.470.496060.313
235Mark Brunell1999JAX3009.558.870.684410.867
236Jon Kitna1999SEA2999.488.870.604950.533
237Jim Everett1994NOR2979.528.970.555400.438
238Cam Newton2012CAR2909.939.330.604850.438
239David Garrard2010JAX2899.989.190.793660.571
240Joe Flacco2010BAL2899.789.190.594890.750
241Steve Beuerlein2000CAR2889.468.920.545330.438
242Rich Gannon2001OAK2839.468.940.515490.625
243Matt Ryan2014ATL2829.879.420.456280.375
244Ben Roethlisberger2016PIT2769.999.450.545090.714
245Ty Detmer1996PHI2759.588.900.694010.636
246Jon Kitna2007DET2719.669.180.485610.438
247Sage Rosenfels2007HOU27010.319.181.122400.800
248Scott Mitchell1993MIA26910.088.931.162330.429
249Stan Humphries1994SDG2689.568.970.594530.733
250Scott Mitchell1996DET2659.58.900.614370.286
251Joe Montana1993KAN2649.818.930.882980.727
252Aaron Rodgers2016GNB2639.889.450.436100.625
253Jim Kelly1996BUF2609.598.900.693790.615
254Jake Plummer2005DEN2609.619.040.574560.813
255Jay Cutler2013CHI259109.270.733550.455
256Jay Fiedler2001MIA2589.518.940.574500.688
257Joe Flacco2009BAL2529.619.110.504990.563
258Matt Hasselbeck2007SEA2479.629.180.445620.625
259Drew Bledsoe1997NWE2459.378.910.475220.625
260Matt Schaub2007HOU24410.039.180.852890.364
261Craig Erickson1994TAM2409.578.970.603990.429
262Jim Kelly1994BUF2399.58.970.534480.500
263Brian Hoyer2014CLE2379.969.420.544380.538
264Warren Moon1997SEA2339.358.910.445280.500
265Matt Schaub2012HOU2339.769.330.435440.750
266Warren Moon1993HOU2329.378.930.455200.714
267Steve McNair2000TEN2279.58.920.573960.800
268Gus Frerotte2000DEN2259.898.920.972320.667
269Ben Roethlisberger2012PIT2249.839.330.504490.538
270Troy Aikman1998DAL2219.89.100.703150.636
271Aaron Brooks2003NOR2219.228.800.435180.500
272Trent Green2001KAN2219.368.940.425230.375
273Kyle Orton2010DEN2189.639.190.444980.231
274Jim Everett1992RAM2189.619.150.464750.375
275Drew Brees2010NOR2149.529.190.336580.688
276Matt Hasselbeck2004SEA2139.889.430.454740.500
277Mark Sanchez2014PHI21210.19.420.683090.500
278Daunte Culpepper2002MIN2079.298.910.385490.375
279Carson Palmer2016ARI2079.89.450.355970.433
280Brad Johnson1996MIN2029.558.900.653110.625
281Kurt Warner2005ARI2019.589.040.543750.200
282Kerry Collins2000NYG2009.38.920.385290.750
283Tony Romo2013DAL1999.649.270.375350.533
284Jon Kitna2006DET1969.379.040.335960.188
285David Carr2004HOU1969.859.430.424660.438
286Drew Bledsoe1994NWE1969.258.970.286910.625
287Vinny Testaverde1992TAM1949.699.150.543580.357
288Jay Fiedler2002MIA1939.578.910.662920.700
289Neil O'Donnell1992PIT1939.769.150.623130.750
290Jeff Hostetler1995OAK1919.699.020.672860.636
291Eli Manning2014NYG1889.739.420.316010.375
292Josh Freeman2010TAM1879.599.190.404740.625
293Tom Brady2014NWE1839.739.420.315820.750
294Dan Marino1997MIA1809.238.910.335480.563
295Cody Carlson1992HOU1809.949.150.792270.667
296Dave Krieg1992KAN1789.589.150.434130.625
297Dave Brown1994NYG1769.478.970.503500.600
298Steve DeBerg19932TM1759.78.930.772270.400
299Eli Manning2008NYG1729.459.090.364790.750
300Michael Vick2002ATL1689.318.910.404210.567
301Matt Moore2011MIA1689.879.390.483470.400
302Daunte Culpepper2001MIN1639.398.940.453660.364
303Andy Dalton2016CIN1639.749.450.295630.406
304Boomer Esiason1993NYJ1629.278.930.344730.500
305Byron Leftwich2005JAX1619.579.040.533020.727
306Jake Delhomme2003CAR1609.158.800.364490.667
307Kordell Stewart1997PIT1599.278.910.364400.688
308Tom Brady2003NWE1559.098.800.295270.875
309Cam Newton2011CAR1549.699.390.305170.375
310Andy Dalton2013CIN1519.539.270.265860.688
311Jake Plummer2001ARI1519.238.940.295250.438
312Steve Young1995SFO1509.359.020.344470.727
313Brian Hoyer2015HOU1479.879.470.403690.556
314Warren Moon1994MIN1459.218.970.246010.600
315Jeff Garcia2003SFO1449.168.800.373920.385
316Neil O'Donnell1995PIT1439.369.020.344160.750
317Ben Roethlisberger2008PIT1429.49.090.304690.750
318Doug Flutie2000BUF1329.58.920.572310.800
319Kordell Stewart2001PIT1319.248.940.304420.813
320Mike Tomczak1996PIT1269.218.900.324010.667
321Scott Mitchell1997DET1219.148.910.245090.563
322Chad Pennington2004NYJ1209.769.430.323700.615
323Bobby Hoying1997PHI1209.448.910.532250.417
324Frank Reich1996NYJ1189.268.900.363310.143
325Billy Joe Tolliver1999NOR1169.38.870.432680.143
326Vince Young2009TEN1139.559.110.442590.800
327Charlie Batch1999DET1139.298.870.422700.600
328Matt Hasselbeck2006SEA1139.349.040.303710.583
329Stan Humphries1992SDG1109.399.150.244540.733
330Gus Frerotte1999DET1109.258.870.382880.333
331Jeff Blake2002BAL1049.268.910.352950.400
332Jon Kitna2002CIN1049.138.910.224730.167
333Jay Cutler2015CHI1019.689.470.214830.400
334Brett Favre2002GNB1009.098.910.185510.750
335Chris Chandler1995HOU999.39.020.283560.385
336Shaun Hill2008SFO999.449.090.342880.625
337Jay Fiedler2003MIA959.18.800.303140.636
338Trent Edwards2008BUF959.359.090.253740.500
339Brad Johnson2003TAM938.968.800.165700.438
340Rob Johnson2000BUF929.228.920.303060.364
341Elvis Grbac1999KAN909.058.870.184990.563
342Tommy Maddox2003PIT908.978.800.175190.375
343Charlie Batch1998DET899.399.100.293030.417
344Josh Freeman2012TAM899.499.330.165580.438
345Gus Frerotte1995WAS849.239.020.213960.273
346Jeff Garcia2007TAM849.449.180.263270.615
347Trent Dilfer1997TAM839.128.910.223860.625
348Ryan Tannehill2016MIA829.669.450.213890.615
349Kerry Collins1999NYG819.128.870.243310.286
350Matt Cassel2010KAN809.379.190.184500.667
351Jeff Garcia1999SFO799.088.870.213750.200
352Aaron Brooks2001NOR799.088.940.145580.438
353Matthew Stafford2013DET789.399.270.126340.438
354Ben Roethlisberger2013PIT779.49.270.135840.500
355Jon Kitna2010DAL779.439.190.243180.444
356Troy Aikman1996DAL769.068.900.164650.667
357Jay Cutler2012CHI759.59.330.174340.667
358Joe Flacco2014BAL719.559.420.135540.625
359Kevin Kolb2011ARI689.669.390.272530.333
360Brad Johnson1997MIN689.068.910.154520.615
361Chris Miller1992ATL669.419.150.262530.375
362Randall Cunningham1992PHI619.39.150.163840.667
363Trent Green1998WAS599.219.100.125090.429
364Erik Kramer1998CHI589.339.100.232500.375
365Brett Favre1999GNB588.978.870.105950.500
366Cam Newton2013CAR579.399.270.124730.750
367Jim Harbaugh1992CHI569.39.150.163580.385
368Gus Frerotte1997WAS539.048.910.134020.500
369David Garrard2006JAX519.259.040.212410.500
370Doug Flutie1999BUF488.978.870.104780.667
371Byron Leftwich2003JAX458.98.800.114180.385
372Boomer Esiason1996ARI459.038.900.133390.375
373Carson Palmer2010CIN459.279.190.085860.250
374Carson Palmer2014ARI439.619.420.192241.000
375Chris Chandler1996HOU419.038.900.133200.500
376Billy Volek2004TEN399.549.430.113570.250
377Jeff Garcia2008TAM389.29.090.103760.545
378Gus Frerotte2008MIN389.229.090.133010.727
379Rodney Peete2002CAR3698.910.103810.500
380Tony Banks1996STL3698.900.103680.385
381Jay Cutler2011CHI359.59.390.113140.700
382Austin Davis2014STL339.539.420.112840.375
383Vinny Testaverde2004DAL309.499.430.064950.333
384Russell Wilson2014SEA289.489.420.064520.750
385Aaron Brooks2002NOR288.968.910.055280.563
386Dan Marino1999MIA248.948.870.073690.455
387Tom Brady2001NWE2398.940.064130.786
388John Elway1994DEN229.018.970.044940.500
389Charlie Batch2001DET229.018.940.063410.000
390Kerry Collins1996CAR208.958.900.063640.750
391Matt Ryan2010ATL199.229.190.035710.813
392Chad Pennington2007NYJ179.259.180.072600.125
393Ryan Fitzpatrick2010BUF179.239.190.044410.308
394Ryan Tannehill2014MIA169.449.420.035900.500
395Kyle Orton20112TM149.459.390.062520.375
396J.P. Losman2006BUF119.069.040.034290.438
397Donovan McNabb2008PHI109.119.090.025710.594
398Jim Harbaugh1997IND108.948.910.033090.182
399Matthew Stafford2016DET99.479.450.015940.563
400Chad Pennington2006NYJ69.059.040.014850.625
401Brett Favre1994GNB58.988.970.015820.563
402Kerry Collins2010TEN59.219.190.022780.286
403Matthew Stafford2015DET49.489.470.015920.438
404Jeff Blake1994CIN38.988.970.013060.333
405Trent Dilfer2000BAL38.938.920.012260.875
406Tom Brady2006NWE29.049.040.005160.750
407Scott Mitchell1994DET28.978.970.012460.444
408Philip Rivers2007SDG19.189.180.004600.688
409Aaron Brooks2005NOR-29.049.040.004310.231
410Rodney Peete1993DET-58.98.93-0.022520.600
411Chris Chandler1992PHO-69.139.15-0.014130.308
412Matt Leinart2006ARI-79.029.04-0.023770.364
413David Garrard2009JAX-99.099.11-0.025160.438
414Shaun King2000TAM-108.98.92-0.024280.625
415David Garrard2008JAX-139.079.09-0.025350.313
416Donovan McNabb2005PHI-1399.04-0.043570.444
417Mark Brunell2002JAX-168.878.91-0.044160.400
418Carson Palmer2009CIN-169.089.11-0.034660.625
419Kerry Collins2005OAK-189.019.04-0.035650.267
420Jeff Blake1999CIN-198.828.87-0.053890.250
421Drew Brees2007NOR-199.159.18-0.036520.438
422Jeff Blake1996CIN-208.868.90-0.045490.500
423Drew Bledsoe1996NWE-218.878.90-0.036230.688
424Jason Campbell2009WAS-219.079.11-0.045070.250
425Matt Ryan2009ATL-239.069.11-0.054510.643
426Aaron Brooks2004NOR-269.389.43-0.055420.500
427Rich Gannon1992MIN-279.059.15-0.102790.667
428Matt Cassel2008NWE-289.049.09-0.055160.667
429Trent Dilfer1999TAM-288.768.87-0.112440.700
430Shaun Hill2014STL-299.299.42-0.132290.375
431Mark Sanchez2009NYJ-319.029.11-0.093640.533
432Andrew Luck2012IND-319.289.33-0.056270.688
433Cam Newton2014CAR-319.359.42-0.074480.393
434Tyrod Taylor2016BUF-349.379.45-0.084360.467
435Colin Kaepernick2014SFO-359.349.42-0.074780.500
436Mark Brunell2005WAS-358.969.04-0.084540.600
437Christian Ponder2013MIN-379.129.27-0.152390.278
438Jeff Blake2000NOR-378.88.92-0.123020.636
439Vince Young2007TEN-389.089.18-0.103820.600
440Ryan Fitzpatrick2015NYJ-399.49.47-0.075620.625
441Michael Vick2004ATL-419.39.43-0.133210.733
442Drew Stanton2014ARI-459.239.42-0.192400.625
443Patrick Ramsey2002WAS-488.78.91-0.212270.400
444Mike Tomczak1999PIT-488.698.87-0.182580.200
445Donald Hollas1998OAK-508.919.10-0.192600.667
446Joe Flacco2012BAL-529.239.33-0.105310.625
447Brad Johnson2000WAS-538.788.92-0.143650.636
448Tom Brady2013NWE-539.189.27-0.096280.750
449Brad Johnson2002TAM-548.798.91-0.124510.769
450Michael Vick2006ATL-548.99.04-0.143880.438
451Kurt Warner2004NYG-549.239.43-0.202770.556
452Jay Fiedler2000MIA-558.778.92-0.153570.667
453Matthew Stafford2012DET-569.259.33-0.087270.250
454Kordell Stewart2000PIT-588.728.92-0.202890.636
455Matt Cassel2013MIN-599.049.27-0.232540.500
456Chris Chandler2000ATL-608.748.92-0.183310.308
457Chris Simms2005TAM-638.849.04-0.203130.600
458Mark Rypien1992WAS-649.019.15-0.134790.563
459Jake Plummer1998ARI-658.989.10-0.125470.563
460Jeff Hostetler1996OAK-678.738.90-0.174020.538
461Joe Flacco2008BAL-688.949.09-0.164280.688
462Chad Henne2010MIA-699.059.19-0.144900.429
463Kellen Clemens2013STL-728.979.27-0.302420.444
464Rex Grossman2006CHI-738.899.04-0.154800.813
465Robert Griffin2013WAS-749.119.27-0.164560.231
466Eli Manning2005NYG-748.919.04-0.135570.688
467Tony Banks1999BAL-758.648.87-0.233200.600
468Damon Huard2007KAN-768.959.18-0.233320.400
469Cam Newton2016CAR-769.39.45-0.155100.429
470Ryan Fitzpatrick2013TEN-779.059.27-0.223500.333
471Warren Moon1996MIN-788.598.90-0.312470.500
472Vinny Testaverde1994CLE-788.768.97-0.213760.692
473Eli Manning2015NYG-799.349.47-0.136180.375
474Josh McCown2005ARI-808.749.04-0.302700.500
475Joe Montana1994KAN-818.88.97-0.174930.643
476Doug Flutie2001SDG-848.788.94-0.165210.313
477Bobby Hebert1996ATL-848.738.90-0.174880.231
478John Elway1992DEN-858.889.15-0.273160.667
479Josh McCown2015CLE-859.189.47-0.292920.125
480Brock Osweiler2015DEN-879.159.47-0.322750.714
481Kerry Collins2001NYG-888.798.94-0.165680.438
482Donovan McNabb2007PHI-898.999.18-0.194730.571
483Case Keenum2013HOU-898.929.27-0.352530.000
484Donovan McNabb2003PHI-908.618.80-0.194780.750
485Carson Palmer2004CIN-919.229.43-0.214320.462
486Stan Humphries1997SDG-918.58.91-0.412250.375
487Steve McNair2005TEN-918.859.04-0.194760.286
488Alex Van Pelt2001BUF-938.648.94-0.303070.250
489Steve McNair2006BAL-938.849.04-0.204680.813
490Brian Griese1999DEN-988.668.87-0.224520.308
491Kyle Orton2009DEN-998.939.11-0.185410.533
492Rick Mirer1995SEA-1028.769.02-0.263910.538
493Teddy Bridgewater2014MIN-1049.169.42-0.264020.500
494Brett Favre2008NYJ-1058.899.09-0.205220.563
495Jason Campbell2010OAK-1068.879.19-0.323290.583
496Warren Moon1998SEA-1068.689.10-0.412580.400
497Ryan Tannehill2013MIA-1099.089.27-0.195880.500
498Steve McNair1997TEN-1108.648.91-0.264150.500
499Brett Favre2000GNB-1108.738.92-0.195800.563
500Rex Grossman2011WAS-1129.159.39-0.244580.385
501Brett Favre1992GNB-1128.919.15-0.244710.615
502Mark Brunell1995JAX-1138.699.02-0.333460.300
503Ty Detmer1997PHI-1168.438.91-0.482440.286
504Kyle Boller2007BAL-1168.769.18-0.422750.250
505Doug Johnson2003ATL-1178.318.80-0.482430.125
506Michael Vick2005ATL-1188.749.04-0.303870.533
507Neil O'Donnell1993PIT-1188.688.93-0.244860.600
508Alex Smith2016KAN-1209.219.45-0.254890.733
509Trent Dilfer1998TAM-1228.819.10-0.284290.500
510Chris Miller1995STL-1228.729.02-0.304050.538
511Stan Humphries1996SDG-1228.618.90-0.294160.538
512Marc Bulger2007STL-1238.869.18-0.323780.167
513Derek Carr2016OAK-1239.239.45-0.225600.800
514Chris Miller1994RAM-1248.588.97-0.393170.200
515Craig Erickson1993TAM-1248.658.93-0.274570.333
516Jeff Blake1995CIN-1268.89.02-0.225670.438
517Jason Campbell2007WAS-1268.889.18-0.304170.462
518Alex Smith2011SFO-1279.19.39-0.294450.813
519Jim Miller2002CHI-1318.498.91-0.423140.250
520Jim Kelly1995BUF-1328.739.02-0.294580.667
521Stan Humphries1993SDG-1348.518.93-0.413240.600
522Trent Dilfer2005CLE-1358.649.04-0.403330.364
523Kent Graham1996ARI-1388.398.90-0.502740.500
524Trent Dilfer1995TAM-1408.689.02-0.344150.438
525Kelly Holcomb2005BUF-1418.439.04-0.612300.500
526Eli Manning2013NYG-1439.019.27-0.265510.438
527Tony Banks1997STL-1438.618.91-0.294870.313
528Alex Smith2014KAN-1469.19.42-0.314640.533
529Jeff George1993IND-1468.578.93-0.364070.182
530Troy Aikman2000DAL-1468.368.92-0.562620.364
531Brian Griese2001DEN-1468.628.94-0.324510.533
532Matt Ryan2013ATL-1479.049.27-0.236510.250
533Ryan Tannehill2015MIA-1479.229.47-0.255860.375
534David Carr2003HOU-1498.298.80-0.502950.273
535Nick Foles2014PHI-1508.949.42-0.483110.750
536Dave Krieg1995ARI-1508.739.02-0.295210.250
537Tim Couch2001CLE-1518.618.94-0.334540.438
538Dan Marino1998MIA-1528.819.10-0.285370.625
539Josh Freeman2009TAM-1538.589.11-0.532900.333
540Brian Griese2007CHI-1548.69.18-0.592620.500
541Troy Aikman1997DAL-1588.68.91-0.305180.375
542Donovan McNabb2010WAS-1598.859.19-0.344720.385
543Elvis Grbac1997KAN-1598.48.91-0.513140.800
544Donovan McNabb2002PHI-1598.478.91-0.443610.700
545Steve McNair1998TEN-1598.779.10-0.324920.500
546Geno Smith2013NYJ-1608.919.27-0.364430.500
547Steve McNair1999TEN-1638.388.87-0.493310.818
548Ray Lucas1999NYJ-1638.278.87-0.602720.667
549Bubby Brister1993PHI-1648.48.93-0.533090.500
550Tim Rattay2004SFO-1648.939.43-0.503250.111
551Erik Kramer1997CHI-1648.568.91-0.344770.308
552Kent Graham1999NYG-1668.268.87-0.612710.556
553Neil O'Donnell1994PIT-1678.518.97-0.453700.714
554Josh McCown2014TAM-1708.99.42-0.523270.091
555Jake Locker2012TEN-1718.799.33-0.543140.364
556John Skelton2011ARI-1728.779.39-0.622750.714
557Elvis Grbac2001BAL-1758.578.94-0.374670.571
558Jeff George1992IND-1758.589.15-0.573060.600
559Byron Leftwich2004JAX-1759.039.43-0.404410.571
560Steve Beuerlein1994ARI-1778.278.97-0.692550.429
561Kerry Collins2003NYG-1778.448.80-0.355000.308
562Wade Wilson1993NOR-1788.478.93-0.463880.500
563Andy Dalton2012CIN-1798.999.33-0.345280.625
564Jeff Blake1997CIN-1808.348.91-0.573170.273
565Philip Rivers2012SDG-1818.999.33-0.345270.438
566Jim Harbaugh1996IND-1838.458.90-0.454050.500
567Dave Brown1996NYG-1838.448.90-0.463980.375
568Tarvaris Jackson2007MIN-1838.569.18-0.622940.667
569Peyton Manning2015DEN-1838.929.47-0.553310.778
570Quincy Carter2003DAL-1848.438.80-0.365050.625
571Jon Kitna2000SEA-1878.478.92-0.454180.500
572Trevor Siemian2016DEN-1889.069.45-0.394860.571
573Sam Bradford2016MIN-1889.119.45-0.345520.467
574Brad Johnson2005MIN-1898.49.04-0.642940.778
575Brandon Weeden2013CLE-1898.569.27-0.712670.000
576Patrick Ramsey2003WAS-1918.238.80-0.573370.364
577Matt Hasselbeck2015IND-1948.719.47-0.762560.625
578Matt Cassel2012KAN-1958.639.33-0.702770.125
579Chad Henne2009MIA-1958.689.11-0.434510.538
580Michael Vick2012PHI-1978.779.33-0.563510.300
581Troy Aikman1999DAL-1978.438.87-0.454420.500
582Jake Plummer2006DEN-1998.419.04-0.633170.636
583Dave Krieg1996CHI-2018.378.90-0.533770.500
584Neil O'Donnell1998CIN-2038.519.10-0.593430.182
585Brett Favre2010MIN-2048.629.19-0.573580.385
586Andrew Luck2015IND-2048.779.47-0.702930.286
587Mark Brunell2006WAS-2068.249.04-0.792600.333
588Sam Bradford2012STL-2098.959.33-0.385510.469
589Alex Smith2015KAN-2119.029.47-0.454700.688
590Heath Shuler1994WAS-2128.178.97-0.802650.125
591Derek Carr2015OAK-2159.19.47-0.375730.438
592Seneca Wallace2008SEA-2168.29.09-0.892420.375
593Cade McNown1999CHI-2177.958.87-0.922350.333
594Jim Harbaugh1998BAL-2178.359.10-0.742930.417
595Peyton Manning1998IND-2198.729.10-0.385750.188
596Jeff Garcia2004CLE-2198.569.43-0.872520.300
597Dan Orlovsky2008DET-2198.249.09-0.862550.000
598Sam Bradford2013STL-2208.439.27-0.842620.429
599Jay Schroeder1994ARI-2208.048.97-0.922380.625
600Tim Couch2002CLE-2228.418.91-0.504430.571
601Jim McMahon1993MIN-2238.258.93-0.673310.667
602Jeff Garcia2002SFO-2268.488.91-0.435280.625
603Case Keenum2016LAR-2298.749.45-0.713220.444
604Kelly Holcomb2003CLE-2368.018.80-0.783020.250
605Randall Cunningham1994PHI-2378.488.97-0.484900.500
606Carson Palmer2012OAK-2388.919.33-0.425650.267
607Matt Schaub2013HOU-2408.69.27-0.673580.250
608Teddy Bridgewater2015MIN-2408.939.47-0.544470.688
609Patrick Ramsey2004WAS-2418.559.43-0.892720.429
610Matthew Stafford2014DET-2429.019.42-0.406020.688
611John Friesz1993SDG-2447.98.93-1.032380.333
612Jay Cutler2009CHI-2528.669.11-0.455550.438
613Drew Bledsoe2004BUF-2538.879.43-0.564500.563
614Geno Smith2014NYJ-2538.739.42-0.693670.231
615Kerry Collins19982TM-2548.389.10-0.723530.182
616JaMarcus Russell2008OAK-2558.49.09-0.693680.333
617Andrew Walter2006OAK-2568.119.04-0.932760.250
618Philip Rivers2015SDG-2589.089.47-0.396610.250
619Steve Walsh1994CHI-2598.218.97-0.763430.727
620Mike Glennon2013TAM-2608.649.27-0.634160.308
621Kellen Clemens2007NYJ-2608.149.18-1.042500.375
622Jim Harbaugh1993CHI-2618.128.93-0.803250.467
623Ryan Fitzpatrick2009BUF-2627.969.11-1.152270.500
624Alex Smith2010SFO-2628.439.19-0.763420.300
625Matt Cassel2011KAN-2628.429.39-0.972690.444
626Blaine Gabbert2015SFO-2648.549.47-0.942820.375
627Rex Grossman2007CHI-26589.18-1.182250.286
628Vinny Testaverde2001NYJ-2678.348.94-0.604410.625
629Mark Sanchez2012NYJ-2678.749.33-0.594530.400
630Tim Tebow2011DEN-2688.49.39-0.992710.636
631Ryan Tannehill2012MIA-2698.789.33-0.554840.438
632Andy Dalton2014CIN-2718.859.42-0.564810.656
633Matt Hasselbeck2010SEA-2728.589.19-0.614440.429
634Brett Favre2005GNB-2748.599.04-0.456070.250
635Jake Delhomme2009CAR-2748.269.11-0.853210.364
636Ryan Fitzpatrick2012BUF-2758.799.33-0.545050.375
637Terrelle Pryor2013OAK-2768.259.27-1.022720.333
638Ryan Fitzpatrick2016NYJ-2778.769.45-0.694030.273
639Derek Anderson2010ARI-2788.349.19-0.853270.222
640Mark Sanchez2010NYJ-2788.649.19-0.555070.688
641Chad Henne2012JAX-2818.429.33-0.913080.167
642Chad Hutchinson2002DAL-2817.788.91-1.122500.222
643Colin Kaepernick2016SFO-2838.69.45-0.853310.091
644Vinny Testaverde1997BAL-2848.38.91-0.604700.346
645Christian Ponder2011MIN-2848.429.39-0.982910.200
646Kordell Stewart2003CHI-2847.678.80-1.132510.286
647Jim Everett1993RAM-2857.898.93-1.042740.333
648Jim Harbaugh1999SDG-2878.218.87-0.664340.500
649Jay Schroeder1992RAI-2927.999.15-1.152530.444
650Kyle Boller2005BAL-2948.049.04-1.002930.444
651Kerry Collins2008TEN-2948.399.09-0.714150.800
652Eli Manning2006NYG-2948.479.04-0.565220.500
653Joey Harrington2005DET-2958.159.04-0.893300.364
654Kyle Boller2003BAL-3037.448.80-1.352240.556
655Shane Matthews1999CHI-3067.768.87-1.112750.429
656Marc Bulger2009STL-3077.879.11-1.242470.125
657Rich Gannon1998KAN-3078.239.10-0.873540.500
658Drew Bledsoe1993NWE-3118.28.93-0.724290.417
659Tyler Thigpen2008KAN-3128.359.09-0.744200.091
660Matt Hasselbeck2001SEA-3157.968.94-0.983210.417
661Vince Young2006TEN-3188.159.04-0.893570.615
662Kerry Collins2004OAK-3208.819.43-0.625130.231
663Jake Delhomme2006CAR-3208.299.04-0.744310.538
664Anthony Wright2005BAL-3227.839.04-1.212660.286
665Tarvaris Jackson2011SEA-3248.679.39-0.724500.500
666Brooks Bollinger2005NYJ-3267.819.04-1.232660.222
667Eli Manning2007NYG-3298.569.18-0.625290.625
668Craig Whelihan1997SDG-3317.518.91-1.392370.000
669Vinny Testaverde2000NYJ-3318.368.92-0.565900.563
670Tony Banks2000BAL-3327.718.92-1.212740.625
671Kyle Orton2014BUF-3398.669.42-0.764470.583
672Boomer Esiason1994NYJ-3468.188.97-0.794400.357
673Dave Brown1995NYG-3488.269.02-0.764560.313
674Drew Bledsoe2003BUF-3518.058.80-0.754710.375
675Tony Banks2001WAS-3567.988.94-0.963700.571
676Colin Kaepernick2015SFO-35889.47-1.472440.250
677Jeff Blake2003ARI-3647.818.80-0.993670.231
678Joe Flacco2011BAL-3648.729.39-0.675420.750
679Alex Smith2006SFO-3678.219.04-0.834420.438
680Neil O'Donnell1997NYJ-3678.118.91-0.804600.571
681Rick Mirer1996SEA-3717.58.90-1.402650.222
682EJ Manuel2013BUF-3718.069.27-1.213060.400
683Curtis Painter2011IND-3737.859.39-1.542430.000
684Donovan McNabb2001PHI-3758.188.94-0.764930.688
685Kerry Collins1997CAR-3817.918.91-1.003810.462
686Kerry Collins1995CAR-3838.139.02-0.884330.538
687Brett Favre1993GNB-3848.198.93-0.735220.563
688Doug Pederson1999PHI-3857.188.87-1.692270.222
689Andrew Luck2013IND-3888.599.27-0.685700.688
690Trent Edwards2007BUF-3887.749.18-1.442690.556
691J.P. Losman2005BUF-3897.339.04-1.712280.125
692Rich Gannon2003OAK-3897.078.80-1.732250.286
693Ryan Mallett20152TM-3927.869.47-1.612440.333
694Kyle Orton2008CHI-3928.259.09-0.844650.600
695Rodney Peete1995PHI-3937.979.02-1.053750.750
696Kent Graham1997ARI-3947.338.91-1.582500.167
697David Carr2005HOU-3988.19.04-0.944230.125
698Shane Matthews2002WAS-4017.228.91-1.692370.429
699Andy Dalton2011CIN-4028.619.39-0.785160.563
700Drew Brees2002SDG-4048.148.91-0.775260.500
701Brad Johnson2001TAM-4068.218.94-0.735590.563
702Matt Hasselbeck2011TEN-4108.69.39-0.795180.563
703Nick Foles2012PHI-4107.789.33-1.552650.167
704Derek Anderson2008CLE-4117.649.09-1.452830.333
705Shaun Hill2010DET-4148.199.19-1.004160.300
706Charlie Frye2006CLE-4197.979.04-1.073920.308
707Danny Kanell1997NYG-4207.488.91-1.432940.750
708Todd Collins1997BUF-4237.828.91-1.083910.385
709Tim Couch1999CLE-4237.818.87-1.063990.143
710Steve Bono1995KAN-4238.29.02-0.815200.813
711Browning Nagle1992NYJ-4258.059.15-1.103870.231
712Trent Dilfer1996TAM-4288.018.90-0.894820.375
713Ryan Leaf2000SDG-4287.598.92-1.333220.111
714Kordell Stewart1999PIT-4307.318.87-1.562750.455
715David Klingler1994CIN-4337.098.97-1.872310.000
716Alex Smith2013KAN-4338.429.27-0.855080.733
717Boomer Esiason1995NYJ-4407.899.02-1.133890.167
718Jason Campbell2008WAS-4508.219.09-0.895060.500
719Billy Joe Tolliver1994HOU-4527.088.97-1.892400.000
720Cade McNown2000CHI-4567.298.92-1.632800.111
721Tom Brady2002NWE-4608.148.91-0.776010.563
722Alex Smith2009SFO-4617.879.11-1.243720.500
723Charlie Batch2000DET-4637.88.92-1.124120.533
724Brodie Croyle2007KAN-4677.19.18-2.092240.000
725Jay Cutler2014CHI-4688.589.42-0.835610.333
726Mark Sanchez2011NYJ-4698.539.39-0.865430.500
727Tony Banks1998STL-4807.929.10-1.184080.286
728Eli Manning2016NYG-4808.659.45-0.805980.688
729Jake Plummer2000ARI-4857.98.92-1.024750.214
730Josh McCown2004ARI-4868.249.43-1.194080.462
731Jason Campbell2013CLE-4887.739.27-1.543170.125
732Blaine Gabbert2012JAX-4887.589.33-1.762780.100
733Ryan Fitzpatrick2011BUF-4898.539.39-0.865690.375
734Joey Harrington2007ATL-4907.779.18-1.413480.300
735Ken Dorsey2004SFO-4917.269.43-2.172260.143
736David Carr2006HOU-4927.929.04-1.114420.375
737Joe Flacco2015BAL-4948.279.47-1.204130.300
738Drew Bledsoe2000NWE-4957.998.92-0.935310.313
739Steve Bono1996KAN-5057.758.90-1.154380.615
740Sam Bradford2015PHI-5088.529.47-0.955320.500
741Brady Quinn2009CLE-5137.119.11-2.002560.222
742Joey Harrington2006MIA-5137.719.04-1.323880.455
743Brad Johnson2006MIN-5177.869.04-1.184390.429
744Rick Mirer1994SEA-5197.68.97-1.363810.385
745Jim Everett1996NOR-5247.778.90-1.134640.200
746Mark Brunell2004WAS-5257.229.43-2.212370.333
747Jake Plummer1999ARI-5287.498.87-1.383810.273
748Donovan McNabb2000PHI-5317.998.92-0.935690.688
749Gus Frerotte2005MIA-5357.969.04-1.084940.600
750Sam Bradford2011STL-5417.889.39-1.513570.100
751Matthew Stafford2009DET-5467.669.11-1.453770.200
752Drew Brees2003SDG-5547.248.80-1.563560.182
753Brandon Weeden2012CLE-5548.269.33-1.075170.333
754Aaron Rodgers2015GNB-5698.489.47-0.995720.625
755Cleo Lemon2007MIA-5737.339.18-1.853090.143
756Rick Mirer1993SEA-5747.748.93-1.184860.375
757Ryan Leaf1998SDG-5876.79.10-2.402450.333
758Jim Miller2001CHI-5997.438.94-1.523950.846
759Stan Gelbaugh1992SEA-6046.789.15-2.372550.000
760Christian Ponder2012MIN-6188.059.33-1.284830.625
761Craig Whelihan1998SDG-6257.149.10-1.953200.286
762Danny Kanell1998NYG-62679.10-2.102990.300
763Marc Bulger2008STL-6307.669.09-1.434400.133
764Josh Freeman2011TAM-6358.249.39-1.155510.267
765Joe Flacco2013BAL-6378.239.27-1.046140.500
766Matt Hasselbeck2009SEA-6497.789.11-1.334880.357
767Colt McCoy2011CLE-6557.989.39-1.414630.308
768JaMarcus Russell2009OAK-6596.439.11-2.682460.222
769Blake Bortles2016JAX-6618.399.45-1.066250.188
770David Carr2002HOU-6617.428.91-1.494440.250
771Jon Kitna2001CIN-6847.778.94-1.185810.400
772Boomer Esiason1992CIN-6966.649.15-2.502780.364
773A.J. Feeley2004MIA-7037.469.43-1.973560.375
774David Klingler1993CIN-7116.858.93-2.073430.231
775Chad Henne2013JAX-7137.859.27-1.425030.308
776Brett Favre2006GNB-7157.879.04-1.176130.500
777Jake Plummer2002ARI-7287.538.91-1.375300.313
778Kordell Stewart1998PIT-7377.499.10-1.614580.438
779Matt Cassel2009KAN-7437.69.11-1.514930.267
780Brock Osweiler2016HOU-7687.959.45-1.515100.571
781Joey Harrington2004DET-7807.849.43-1.594890.375
782Akili Smith2000CIN-7875.988.92-2.952670.182
783Carson Wentz2016PHI-8018.139.45-1.326070.438
784Kyle Orton2005CHI-8136.839.04-2.213680.667
785Bobby Hoying1998PHI-8215.439.10-3.672240.143
786Ryan Fitzpatrick2008CIN-8226.889.09-2.213720.375
787Nick Foles2015STL-8476.969.47-2.513370.364
788Jimmy Clausen2010CAR-8526.349.19-2.852990.100
789Joe Flacco2016BAL-8568.189.45-1.276720.500
790Kyle Boller2004BAL-8677.569.43-1.874640.563
791Bruce Gradkowski2006TAM-8796.369.04-2.683280.273
792Joey Harrington2002DET-8896.838.91-2.074290.250
793Sam Bradford2010STL-9117.659.19-1.545900.438
794Drew Bledsoe1995NWE-9157.589.02-1.446360.400
795Mark Rypien1993WAS-9395.988.93-2.943190.300
796Blake Bortles2014JAX-9667.389.42-2.034750.231
797Blaine Gabbert2011JAX-10456.869.39-2.534130.286
798Joey Harrington2003DET-10596.888.80-1.915540.313
799Chris Weinke2001CAR-10766.958.94-1.995400.067
800Derek Carr2014OAK-13117.239.42-2.195990.188

I won’t bother telling you what you can see with your own eyes, but there are a few things worth noting. For one, this list dovetails closely with traditional rankings of QB seasons that do include INT’s and sacks; the best seasons were generally great regardless of how many negative plays the QB had. The other main takeaway from PY/A is how strongly it correlates with winning. The correlation between Relative PY/A and Win % is a robust .56. This is pretty remarkable considering PY/A not only excludes interceptions and sacks, but also ignores fumbles, the running game, defense, and special teams. I feel confident in stating that the most vital factor in winning games is consistently producing big plays in the passing game.

The relationship between PY/A and winning holds true from the best passers to the worst and everyone in between. In the table below, I split Relative PY/A into ten bins from highest to lowest. As you’ll see, team Win % drops in lockstep with a drop in PY/A. Teams featuring an elite PY/A offense can expect to win more than three quarters of their games, while PY/A failures barely win one quarter of their matchups.

Range (L)Range (H)Win %N
2over0.77417
1.51.990.67138
11.490.63280
0.50.990.574122
00.490.521136
-0.5-0.010.486162
-1-0.510.464117
-1.5-1.010.36562
-2-1.510.29329
-2.01under0.26121

In data analysis, sometimes a picture really can tell a thousand words. Below are three visualizations of PY/A in relation to Win %. The first two charts show each of the 800 seasons in the sample (with different filters), and the third depicts career numbers for QB’s with 1500+ attempts since 1992.

{ 119 comments }