A very unhappy marriage
In retrospect, the decision that may wind up ruining Idzik’s career was the one to agree to take the vacant Jets job. Recall that Jaguars GM Dave Caldwell chose Jacksonville over New York, in a move that foreshadowed some of the problems Idzik would encounter. Chief among them: rebuilding in New York — and in particular, with the Jets — is just not like rebuilding in other places. The Jets were 6-10 and coming off back-to-back seasons without the playoffs when Idzik was hired. New York was in a clear rebuilding situation: the Jets cap situation was in terrible shape, and the talent had been depleted. This was going to take some time.
Idzik came from Seattle, where John Schneider took the Seahawks from 5-11 to 7-9 and 7-9 in his first two seasons. Now recognized as one of the best GMs in football, Schneider may well have been fired after two years had he compiled that resume in New York and had the same strained relationship with the media that Idzik had. At a high level, Idzik planned to do in New York what Schneider did in Seattle, or Ted Thompson has done in Green Bay: build through the draft, spend money wisely, and patiently construct a roster. With the Jets — and in particular, due to the media that covers the team — that plan leaves very little margin for error. [continue reading…]