≡ Menu

Antone Smith and Long Touchdowns

Allow me to present to you Atlanta running back Antone Smith’s 2014 play-by-play log in its entirety:

Week 1 vs. NO
QtrTimeScoreDown/DistYardlineDescription
211:400 - 132nd-and-10own 20rushed for 2 yards
209:160 - 131st-and-10opp 31rushed for 5 yards
300:3317 - 202nd-and-9own 46caught pass for 54 yards TOUCHDOWN
Week 2 vs. CIN
QtrTimeScoreDown/DistYardlineDescription
214:49417011st-and-10own 28caught pass for 4 yards
201:14417083rd-and-4own 38target of incomplete pass
410:23417221st-and-10opp 35caught pass for 15 yards (first down)
400:54419361st-and-10own 41target of incomplete pass
Week 3 vs. TB
QtrTimeScoreDown/DistYardlineDescription
104:21367081st-and-9opp 9rushed for 4 yards
209:0028 - 01st-and-10opp 11rushed for 10 yards (first down)
302:3649 - 01st-and-10opp 36rushed for -2 yards
301:5949 - 02nd-and-12opp 38rushed for 38 yards TOUCHDOWN
Week 4 vs. MIN
QtrTimeScoreDown/DistYardlineDescription
105:230 - 73rd-and-2opp 29rushed for 2 yards (first down)
104:470 - 71st-and-10opp 27rushed for 3 yards
214:55418342nd-and-10own 31rushed for 9 yards
301:4021 - 271st-and-10opp 48rushed for 48 yards TOUCHDOWN
Week 5 vs. NYG
QtrTimeScoreDown/DistYardlineDescription
103:420 - 71st-and-10opp 23rushed for 2 yards
214:59418273rd-and-4opp 4caught pass for 1 yards
212:33419191st-and-10own 25caught pass for 8 yards
305:5113 - 103rd-and-4own 26caught pass for 74 yards TOUCHDOWN

That’s four long touchdowns on 17 offensive touches.  On his four scoring plays, Smith has gained an incredible 214 yards.  That’s the most in the NFL so far, with Steve Smith (162 yards) and Jordy Nelson (160) rounding out the top three.  Perhaps even more incredible is that Smith has gained 214 yards on scoring plays despite gaining only 63 yards on non-scoring plays.  Here’s a chart I tweeted a couple of days ago, showing yards gained on TDs on the X-axis and yards gained on all other plays on the Y-axis:

As you can see, Smith — on the bottom right there — is a pretty big outlier. After all, how is it even possible for a player gain over 150 more yards on plays that end in the end zone than on all other plays?

Smith breaks for for another long score

Smith breaks for for another long score.

Good question!  I looked at all players with at least 2 offensive touchdowns in a season since 1950.  As it turns out, only one player has ever pulled off that feat: Bob Boyd in 1950. You remember Boyd, don’t you? No? As a Rams rookie in 1950, Boyd caught 9 passes for a whopping 220 yards.  How did Boyd gain so many yards on so few catches? Well, four of those receptions were for touchdowns of 33, 42, 63, and 72 yards. On the season, he gained 210 yards on his four catches for touchdowns, and 10 yards on his other five receptions.

He was a rookie, though, and that level of production was a sign of things to come. He would lead the NFL in yards per reception in 1953, and the league in receiving yards in 1954. While gaining more yards on scoring plays than non-scoring plays is pretty rare, it does happen from time to time. The table below shows the just-enough-to-get-Smith’s-2013-season-on-the-list players with more yards gained on scoring plays than non-scoring plays, minimum two touchdowns. As it stands, Smith’s 2014 season would be 2nd all time:

PlayerYearTeamPos9/1 AgeTDYds on TDsYards Not on TDsDiff
Bob Boyd1950RAME-DB22.542108202
Antone Smith2014ATLRB29421463151
John Mackey1966BALTE24.99484339145
Elroy Hirsch1951RAME-HB-DE28.217817681136
Bucky Pope1964RAMFL-WR23.410466331135
Mel Gray1973STLWR24.97323190133
Tommy Brooker1962DTXE-K22.831317124
Dick Compton1965HOUSE-B25.4212517108
Bob Hayes1965DALSE-WR22.713551444107
Robert Woods1978HOUWR23.22101-1102
Clifton McNeil1966CLEWR-FL-SE26.3294094
Tom Crabtree2012GNBTE26.831475691
Bert Rechichar1953BALDB-LB-HB-E23.121213091
Wendell Tucker1968RAMWR-FL2541042084
Larry Burton1978SDGWR26.731052283
Billy Stone1950BALHB-DB24.9526017783
Charley Ferguson1962MINWR-TE22.8622314182
Frank Clarke1960DALE26.6318310182
Jim Seymour1970CHIWR23.841133281
Duane Allen1961RAMTE23.9280080
Daryl Turner1986SEAWR24.7720413074
Harold Jackson1973RAMWR-FL27.71347039674
Dobie Craig1963OAKFL-WR-HB25.521326468
Duane Allen1962RAMTE24.92791168
Keith Wright1980CLEWR24.6362062
Bob Hayes1970DALSE-WR27.71149243161
Babe Dimancheff1952CHIHB3021185761
Steve Bono1995KANQB33.35862759
Ken Toler1982NWEWR23.4263459
Cloyce Box1952DETE-HB291549143358
Howie Livingston19502TMFB-WB-HB28.321074958
Warren Wells1967OAKSE-WR24.8618312657
Pete Metzelaars1991BUFTE31.3255-156
Leon Clarke1960CLEE-FL27.641206456
Clint Didier1983WASTE24.441044955
Dave Parks1964SFOSE-TE-WR22.7837932455
John Adams1962CHIE-FB24.83832855
Eric Streater1987TAMWR23.42873552
Morris Bradshaw1975OAKWR22.941136251
Marshall Johnson1975BALWR-DB22.82833251
Mark Malone1981PITQB-WR22.831035548
Melvin Baker1974MIAWR24.12833845
Jerry Tarr1962DENWR2321288345
Steve Tasker1990BUFWR28.4244044
Lyneal Alston1987PITWR23.12642044
Gloster Richardson1970KANWR-FL28.121096643
Lance Alworth1962SDGFL-WR22.1314310043
Bob Trumpy1969CINTE-WR24.5943839741
Mark Bradley2006CHIWR24.6316112140
Lamont Warren2002DETRB29.72521240
Preston Ridlehuber1966ATLRB22.82723537
Gordie Smith1963MINTE24.421077037
Angelo Coia1961CHISE-WR23.4314210735
Gloster Richardson1971DALWR-FL29.131026834
Charley Frazier1969BOSWR30.1716913633
Sonny Jurgensen1965WASQB31228-533
Lamar Lundy1957RAMDE-E22.43734132
Jason Dunn1997PHITE23.82623131
Ed West1984GNBTE23.15431330
Ricky Feacher1980CLEWR26.6413710730
Milt Plum1960CLEQB25.622-2628
Stacy Robinson1988NYGWR26.53855827
Rocky Ryan1957PHIDB-E25.22593227
Montell Owens2008JAXRB24.32431726
Quinn Gray2006JAXQB27.3226026
Alex Higdon1988ATLTE222431726
Tom Mitchell1968BALTE-WR244714625
Darrel Young2013WASFB26.44684424
Spencer Havner2009GNBTE26.64684424
Moran Norris2006SFOFB28.22341024
John Thompson1982GNBTE25.6224024
Don Hasselbeck1980NWETE25.44775324
Rich McGeorge1970GNBTE22229623
Claude King1961HOUHB22.73785523
Marc Boerigter2002KANWR24.3822119922
Dietrich Jells1999PHIWR27.421017922
Michael Haynes1988ATLWR22.7412710522
Jerry Tagge1973GNBQB23.42422022
Antone Smith2013ATLRB282886721
Joel Dreessen2007HOUTE25.12381721
Ben Utecht2005INDTE24.22401921

Some notes:

  • In 1966, John Mackey had touchdowns of 89, 83, 79, 64, 57, 51, 26, 18, and 17 yards. The former Colt not only was a first-team All-Pro, but he also gained more yards on his scoring plays than non-scoring plays. That’s pretty incredible, especially for a tight end.
  • In 1951, Elroy Hirsch gained 817 yards… on his touchdowns! That insane level of production by Crazy Legs will never be matched again. He caught 17 touchdowns that year, including from 91, 71, 79, 76, and 72 yards out.
  • I was glad to see Marc Boerigter make the list, as Antone Smith did conjure up memories of his 2002 season, at least for your author. That year, the Chief wideout came out of nowhere to catch a 99-yard touchdown and seven more scores despite hauling in just 20 passes.

The only running backs in recent times to make the list are fullback types — Washington’s Darrel Young, Jacksonville’s Montell Owens, and San Francisco’s Moran Norris. The last true halfback to make the list was Lamont Warren in his final days in Detroit, when he totaled just 64 yards from scrimmage. And you have to go back a much longer time — well before the merger — to find any running back coming close to doing what Smith is doing (Baltimore’s Billy Stone, perhaps?).

If there’s a takeaway from this post, it’s an obvious one: let’s just hope Smith gets more touches soon.

{ 5 comments }