Boxscore vs. PFF: Era in Review

by Bryan Frye on July 26, 2022

Adam Steele is back with more analysis of traditional box score stats versus Pro Football Focus’s big time throw and turnover-worthy play metrics. And we thank him for it.

A couple of weeks ago, I compared TD/INT and BTT/TWP numbers for the 2021 season. Today we’ll be looking at the entire Pro Football Focus era going back to 2006.

Before compiling the data, I hypothesized that TD/INT and BTT/TWP would track in relative lockstep, though perhaps the upward slope of the PFF metrics would be less severe. That turns out to be true for 2006-07 and 2014-21, but oh boy was there some wackiness taking place in between. In the graph below, you’ll see league TD-INT difference in blue and league BTT-TWP difference in red:

From 2008 to 2012, quarterbacks looked just as good, if not better, by PFF numbers as they did by traditional stats. This was a sharp departure from the surrounding years in which quarterbacks scored vastly better in TD-INT than they did in BTT-TWP. This five year stretch was so anomalous that I wondered if PFF changed their charting procedures in a manner that would skew the numbers.
Fortunately, I received confirmation from PFF’s Kevin Cole that their procedures have remained uniform since 2006.

Year	Dpbk	TD	INT	BTT	TWP	Box	PFF	Luck	TD%	INT%	BTT%	TWP%
2021	19898	836	439	822	746	397	76	321	4.2%	2.2%	4.1%	3.7%
2020	19094	863	381	910	695	482	215	267	4.5%	2.0%	4.8%	3.6%
2019	19069	791	405	780	752	386	28	358	4.1%	2.1%	4.1%	3.9%
2018	18909	832	419	839	758	413	81	332	4.4%	2.2%	4.4%	4.0%
2017	18655	738	425	792	729	313	63	250	4.0%	2.3%	4.2%	3.9%
2016	19374	779	414	761	753	365	8	357	4.0%	2.1%	3.9%	3.9%
2015	19466	840	436	786	792	404	-6	410	4.3%	2.2%	4.0%	4.1%
2014	19055	803	449	779	785	354	-6	360	4.2%	2.4%	4.1%	4.1%
2013	19398	799	502	889	804	297	85	212	4.1%	2.6%	4.6%	4.1%
2012	18923	753	466	1067	743	287	324	-37	4.0%	2.5%	5.6%	3.9%
2011	18569	741	504	1112	802	237	310	-73	4.0%	2.7%	6.0%	4.3%
2010	18364	746	510	961	653	236	308	-72	4.1%	2.8%	5.2%	3.6%
2009	18091	703	517	718	544	186	174	12	3.9%	2.9%	4.0%	3.0%
2008	17517	638	463	725	597	175	128	47	3.6%	2.6%	4.1%	3.4%
2007	18120	715	534	759	864	181	-105	286	3.9%	2.9%	4.2%	4.8%
2006	17513	643	516	675	875	127	-200	327	3.7%	2.9%	3.9%	5.0%

If we probe the data in table form, it turns out that 2008-09 and 2010-12 were separate mini-eras within that five year period. In 2008 and 2009, quarterbacks made fewer mistakes (TWP) than at any other point in the PFF era. That’s certainly not what I expected to see. Even more puzzling is that those relatively rare mistakes were punished at a much higher rate (INT%) than in subsequent years. The only
semi-logical explanation is that the introduction of defenseless receiver penalties in 2010 has something to do with it.

Perhaps linked to the new rules against hitting receivers, BTT% spiked from 2010-2012 and hasn’t come close to those levels since. However, the prevalence of highlight reel throws didn’t do much to elevate TD%, as subsequent seasons with fewer BTT have seen slightly higher TD rates than did 2010-2012. The kneecapped defenses from the 2011 lockout may have aided in reaching the peak of BTT rates, but that doesn’t explain 2010 or 2012 nor does it provide any reason for BTT% declining sharply in 2013 and never recovering. If any of you have theories for what happened from 2008-12 I’d love to hear them in the comments.

Enough about trends, it’s time to see the leaderboard. In the chart below, Box represents TD-INT difference, PFF signifies BTT-TWP difference, Adj PFF is BTT-TWP difference after correcting for league average in a given season, and Adj Luck equals Box difference minus Adjusted PFF difference (on-field luck plus era inflation/deflation). I included every QB season with at least one dropback since 2006 so you can access all of the data and tabulate career numbers if desired.

Quarterback	Year	Team	Dpbk	TD	INT	BTT	TWP	Box	PFF	AdjPFF	AdjLuck
Aaron Rodgers	2011	GNB	538	45	6	50	6	39	44	35.0	4
Peyton Manning	2006	IND	571	31	9	41	14	22	27	33.5	-12
Tom Brady	2007	NWE	599	50	8	38	9	42	29	32.5	10
Russell Wilson	2019	SEA	564	31	5	41	11	26	30	29.2	-3
Tom Brady	2016	NWE	447	28	2	33	4	26	29	28.8	-3
Peyton Manning	2013	DEN	677	55	10	45	14	45	31	28.0	17
Peyton Manning	2007	IND	536	31	14	43	19	17	24	27.1	-10
Kyler Murray	2021	ARI	512	24	10	41	12	14	29	27.0	-13
Tom Brady	2020	TAM	631	40	12	45	12	28	33	25.9	2
Tom Brady	2015	NWE	662	36	7	35	10	29	25	25.2	4
Tom Brady	2006	NWE	542	24	12	31	12	12	19	25.2	-13
Aaron Rodgers	2020	GNB	546	48	5	43	12	43	31	24.9	18
Tom Brady	2021	TAM	741	43	12	42	15	31	27	24.2	7
Patrick Mahomes	2018	KAN	606	50	12	48	22	38	26	23.4	15
Tom Brady	2017	NWE	616	32	8	40	15	24	25	22.9	1
Drew Brees	2011	NOR	681	46	14	53	19	32	34	22.6	9
Ben Roethlisberger	2015	PIT	489	21	16	42	20	5	22	22.2	-17
Aaron Rodgers	2021	GNB	561	37	4	36	12	33	24	21.9	11
Aaron Rodgers	2012	GNB	603	39	8	44	12	31	32	21.7	9
Deshaun Watson	2020	HOU	593	33	7	42	14	26	28	21.3	5
Aaron Rodgers	2018	GNB	646	25	2	35	11	23	24	21.2	2
Aaron Rodgers	2014	GNB	548	38	5	36	15	33	21	21.2	12
Russell Wilson	2018	SEA	478	35	7	39	16	28	23	21.0	7
Tom Brady	2011	NWE	643	39	12	42	11	27	31	20.3	7
Baker Mayfield	2018	CLE	511	27	14	40	18	13	22	19.8	-7
Peyton Manning	2012	DEN	604	37	11	49	19	26	30	19.7	6
Drew Brees	2006	NOR	572	26	11	31	18	15	13	19.5	-5
Russell Wilson	2020	SEA	605	40	13	43	17	27	26	19.2	8
Aaron Rodgers	2019	GNB	605	26	4	36	16	22	20	19.1	3
Eli Manning	2011	NYG	617	29	16	53	24	13	29	18.7	-6
Alex Smith	2017	KAN	540	26	5	31	11	21	20	18.2	3
Carson Palmer	2015	ARI	562	35	11	42	24	24	18	18.2	6
Joe Burrow	2021	CIN	571	34	14	35	15	20	20	17.8	2
Sam Bradford	2016	MIN	589	20	5	31	13	15	18	17.8	-3
Ben Roethlisberger	2014	PIT	641	32	9	33	16	23	17	17.2	6
Patrick Mahomes	2020	KAN	610	38	6	46	22	32	24	17.1	15
Philip Rivers	2009	SDG	511	28	9	31	9	19	22	17.1	2
Aaron Rodgers	2016	GNB	645	40	7	34	17	33	17	16.7	16
Russell Wilson	2012	SEA	426	26	10	33	9	16	24	16.7	-1
Matt Ryan	2008	ATL	451	16	11	36	16	5	20	16.7	-12
Cam Newton	2015	CAR	528	35	10	34	18	25	16	16.2	9
Matt Ryan	2011	ATL	592	29	12	40	14	17	26	16.1	1
Peyton Manning	2008	IND	569	27	12	30	10	15	20	15.8	-1
Russell Wilson	2016	SEA	587	21	11	35	19	10	16	15.8	-6
Joe Flacco	2012	BAL	566	22	10	44	19	12	25	15.3	-3
Philip Rivers	2010	SDG	579	30	13	35	10	17	25	15.3	2
Patrick Mahomes	2019	KAN	501	26	5	31	15	21	16	15.3	6
Ben Roethlisberger	2010	PIT	421	17	5	31	9	12	22	14.9	-3
Philip Rivers	2011	SDG	612	27	20	45	20	7	25	14.8	-8
Derek Carr	2016	OAK	576	28	6	32	17	22	15	14.8	7
Andrew Luck	2016	IND	586	31	13	30	15	18	15	14.8	3
Tom Brady	2012	NWE	664	34	8	38	12	26	26	14.6	11
Philip Rivers	2006	SDG	487	22	9	25	16	13	9	14.6	-2
Aaron Rodgers	2010	GNB	506	28	11	42	19	17	23	14.5	2
Eli Manning	2012	NYG	555	26	15	46	22	11	24	14.5	-3
Drew Brees	2012	NOR	696	43	19	53	27	24	26	14.1	10
Matt Ryan	2010	ATL	594	28	9	35	11	19	24	14.0	5
Alex Smith	2011	SFO	489	17	5	34	12	12	22	13.8	-2
Drew Brees	2018	NOR	506	32	5	28	12	27	16	13.8	13
Kirk Cousins	2016	WAS	629	25	12	33	19	13	14	13.7	-1
Ryan Tannehill	2019	TEN	317	22	6	21	7	16	14	13.5	2
Peyton Manning	2009	IND	581	33	16	33	14	17	19	13.4	4
Marc Bulger	2006	STL	637	24	8	26	20	16	6	13.3	3
Troy Smith	2010	SFO	163	5	4	21	5	1	16	13.3	-12
Aaron Rodgers	2015	GNB	618	31	8	31	18	23	13	13.2	10
Matt Ryan	2017	ATL	553	20	12	21	6	8	15	13.1	-5
Andy Dalton	2015	CIN	406	25	7	27	14	18	13	13.1	5
Drew Brees	2017	NOR	556	23	8	31	16	15	15	13.1	2
Ben Roethlisberger	2017	PIT	582	28	14	33	18	14	15	13.0	1
Ben Roethlisberger	2018	PIT	699	34	16	43	27	18	16	13.0	5
Derek Carr	2020	LVR	543	27	9	37	18	18	19	12.9	5
Matt Ryan	2016	ATL	571	38	7	29	16	31	13	12.8	18
Matthew Stafford	2019	DET	309	19	5	25	12	14	13	12.5	1
Tom Brady	2009	NWE	581	28	13	29	11	15	18	12.4	3
Marcus Mariota	2017	TEN	480	13	15	29	15	-2	14	12.4	-14
Russell Wilson	2021	SEA	433	25	6	26	12	19	14	12.3	7
Philip Rivers	2014	SDG	606	31	18	29	17	13	12	12.2	1
Derek Carr	2015	OAK	604	32	13	37	25	19	12	12.2	7
Russell Wilson	2013	SEA	451	26	9	31	17	17	14	12.0	5
Philip Rivers	2007	SDG	482	21	15	27	18	6	9	11.8	-6
Ben Roethlisberger	2009	PIT	556	26	12	30	13	14	17	11.7	2
Matthew Stafford	2020	DET	566	26	10	32	14	16	18	11.6	4
Josh Freeman	2010	TAM	502	25	6	34	14	19	20	11.6	7
Nick Foles	2013	PHI	345	27	2	20	7	25	13	11.5	14
Derek Carr	2021	LVR	666	23	14	39	25	9	14	11.5	-2
Justin Herbert	2021	LAC	703	38	15	27	13	23	14	11.3	12
Peyton Manning	2014	DEN	614	39	15	39	28	24	11	11.2	13
Tom Brady	2013	NWE	668	25	11	32	18	14	14	11.1	3
Colin Kaepernick	2012	SFO	234	10	3	24	9	7	15	11.0	-4
Drew Brees	2009	NOR	534	34	11	28	12	23	16	10.9	12
Matt Moore	2011	MIA	383	16	9	39	22	7	17	10.6	-4
Drew Brees	2010	NOR	683	33	22	42	20	11	22	10.5	0
Philip Rivers	2013	SDG	574	32	11	28	15	21	13	10.5	11
Tom Brady	2018	NWE	591	29	11	29	16	18	13	10.5	8
Josh Allen	2021	BUF	672	36	15	39	26	21	13	10.4	11
Carson Wentz	2017	PHI	468	33	7	29	17	26	12	10.4	16
Jay Cutler	2008	DEN	627	25	18	45	30	7	15	10.4	-3
Lamar Jackson	2019	BAL	424	36	6	20	9	30	11	10.4	20
Ben Roethlisberger	2013	PIT	626	28	14	40	27	14	13	10.3	4
Matthew Stafford	2014	DET	647	22	12	27	17	10	10	10.2	0
Andrew Luck	2018	IND	657	39	15	35	22	24	13	10.2	14
Sam Bradford	2015	PHI	560	19	14	25	15	5	10	10.2	-5
Matthew Stafford	2013	DET	657	29	19	33	20	10	13	10.1	0
Damon Huard	2006	KAN	260	11	1	19	12	10	7	10.0	0
Kirk Cousins	2021	MIN	589	33	7	30	18	26	12	9.8	16
Philip Rivers	2018	LAC	540	32	12	32	20	20	12	9.7	10
Tony Romo	2013	DAL	570	31	10	27	15	21	12	9.5	11
Drew Brees	2015	NOR	658	32	11	32	23	21	9	9.2	12
Tom Brady	2014	NWE	603	33	9	23	14	24	9	9.2	15
Russell Wilson	2015	SEA	528	34	8	27	18	26	9	9.2	17
Drew Brees	2007	NOR	668	28	18	25	20	10	5	8.9	1
Jake Delhomme	2008	CAR	434	15	12	24	12	3	12	8.8	-6
Ryan Tannehill	2016	MIA	418	19	12	25	16	7	9	8.8	-2
Ben Roethlisberger	2012	PIT	479	26	8	34	17	18	17	8.8	9
Aaron Rodgers	2013	GNB	311	17	6	16	6	11	10	8.6	2
Dak Prescott	2021	DAL	626	37	10	32	21	27	11	8.6	18
Matthew Stafford	2021	LAR	631	41	17	36	25	24	11	8.6	15
Brett Favre	2009	MIN	565	33	7	25	11	26	14	8.6	17
Donovan McNabb	2009	PHI	478	22	10	26	13	12	13	8.4	4
Jay Cutler	2013	CHI	374	19	12	26	16	7	10	8.4	-1
Matthew Stafford	2011	DET	699	41	16	46	26	25	20	8.3	17
Aaron Rodgers	2009	GNB	591	30	7	25	11	23	14	8.3	15
Kirk Cousins	2019	MIN	472	26	6	21	12	20	9	8.3	12
Baker Mayfield	2020	CLE	512	26	8	31	17	18	14	8.2	10
Trent Edwards	2008	BUF	397	11	10	20	9	1	11	8.1	-7
Jeff Garcia	2008	TAM	399	12	6	21	10	6	11	8.1	-2
Cam Newton	2012	CAR	521	19	12	36	19	7	17	8.1	-1
Jeff Garcia	2007	TAM	346	13	4	11	5	9	6	8.0	1
Drew Brees	2013	NOR	687	39	12	36	25	27	11	8.0	19
Russell Wilson	2017	SEA	596	34	11	36	26	23	10	8.0	15
Justin Herbert	2020	LAC	627	31	10	31	16	21	15	7.9	13
Eli Manning	2009	NYG	539	27	14	30	17	13	13	7.8	5
Cam Newton	2011	CAR	552	21	17	45	28	4	17	7.8	-4
Tony Romo	2011	DAL	558	31	10	32	15	21	17	7.7	13
Donovan McNabb	2008	PHI	594	23	11	32	20	12	12	7.7	4
Tim Tebow	2010	DEN	88	5	3	13	4	2	9	7.5	-6
Carson Palmer	2007	CIN	592	26	20	32	28	6	4	7.4	-1
Tony Romo	2009	DAL	584	26	9	23	10	17	13	7.4	10
Carson Palmer	2006	CIN	556	28	13	30	29	15	1	7.3	8
Case Keenum	2017	MIN	503	22	7	21	12	15	9	7.3	8
Drew Brees	2008	NOR	648	34	17	28	16	17	12	7.3	10
Matt Ryan	2014	ATL	659	28	14	33	26	14	7	7.2	7
Blake Bortles	2017	JAX	547	21	13	29	20	8	9	7.2	1
Tyrod Taylor	2015	BUF	416	20	6	24	17	14	7	7.1	7
Carson Wentz	2019	PHI	644	27	7	33	25	20	8	7.1	13
Mac Jones	2021	NWE	549	22	13	24	15	9	9	6.9	2
Aaron Rodgers	2008	GNB	570	28	13	29	18	15	11	6.8	8
Alex Smith	2013	KAN	547	23	7	21	12	16	9	6.6	9
Matthew Stafford	2018	DET	595	21	11	30	21	10	9	6.5	4
Matt Hasselbeck	2007	SEA	595	28	12	30	27	16	3	6.4	10
Tyrod Taylor	2017	BUF	466	14	4	16	8	10	8	6.4	4
Tom Brady	2010	NWE	517	36	4	22	7	32	15	6.3	26
Josh Allen	2020	BUF	598	37	10	36	23	27	13	6.3	21
Kirk Cousins	2018	MIN	646	30	10	26	17	20	9	6.2	14
Cam Newton	2014	CAR	486	18	12	25	19	6	6	6.2	0
Tony Romo	2007	DAL	544	36	19	36	33	17	3	6.2	11
Matt Schaub	2009	HOU	608	29	15	24	12	14	12	6.2	8
Kerry Collins	2010	TEN	291	14	8	20	9	6	11	6.1	0
Dak Prescott	2019	DAL	619	30	11	29	22	19	7	6.1	13
Charlie Whitehurst	2014	TEN	203	7	2	12	6	5	6	6.1	-1
Donovan McNabb	2006	PHI	337	18	6	15	13	12	2	5.8	6
Matt Schaub	2007	HOU	305	9	9	12	8	0	4	5.8	-6
Ben Roethlisberger	2007	PIT	451	32	11	29	26	21	3	5.6	15
Michael Vick	2011	PHI	446	18	14	37	24	4	13	5.6	-2
Jay Cutler	2011	CHI	337	13	7	25	14	6	11	5.4	1
Andy Dalton	2018	CIN	386	21	11	23	16	10	7	5.3	5
Jameis Winston	2021	NOR	172	14	3	12	6	11	6	5.3	6
Jon Kitna	2010	DAL	339	16	12	16	5	4	11	5.3	-1
Tony Romo	2010	DAL	220	11	7	13	4	4	9	5.3	-1
Jared Goff	2017	LAR	502	28	7	24	17	21	7	5.3	16
Thaddeus Lewis	2013	BUF	175	4	3	12	6	1	6	5.2	-4
Deshaun Watson	2019	HOU	539	26	12	29	23	14	6	5.2	9
Andy Dalton	2017	CIN	535	25	12	28	21	13	7	5.2	8
Michael Vick	2010	PHI	406	21	6	23	11	15	12	5.2	10
Andy Dalton	2012	CIN	574	27	16	34	19	11	15	5.2	6
Ryan Tannehill	2012	MIA	519	12	13	27	13	-1	14	5.1	-6
Carson Palmer	2014	ARI	233	11	3	15	10	8	5	5.1	3
Tom Brady	2019	NWE	640	24	8	23	17	16	6	5.1	11
David Garrard	2007	JAX	346	18	3	11	8	15	3	5.0	10
Tyler Thigpen	2010	MIA	70	2	2	6	0	0	6	4.8	-5
Tyrod Taylor	2016	BUF	478	17	6	14	9	11	5	4.8	6
Ben Roethlisberger	2016	PIT	526	29	13	32	27	16	5	4.8	11
Drew Brees	2016	NOR	700	37	15	31	26	22	5	4.7	17
Todd Collins	2007	WAS	112	5	0	6	2	5	4	4.6	0
Matt Hasselbeck	2006	SEA	405	18	15	20	20	3	0	4.6	-2
Andrew Luck	2013	IND	602	23	9	30	23	14	7	4.4	10
Philip Rivers	2008	SDG	503	34	11	25	17	23	8	4.3	19
Trevor Siemian	2021	NOR	197	11	3	11	6	8	5	4.2	4
Deshaun Watson	2017	HOU	223	19	8	17	12	11	5	4.2	7
Derek Carr	2019	OAK	542	21	8	17	12	13	5	4.2	9
Andrew Luck	2014	IND	643	40	16	35	31	24	4	4.2	20
Jake Delhomme	2006	CAR	453	17	11	15	16	6	-1	4.2	2
Ryan Tannehill	2013	MIA	646	24	17	27	20	7	7	4.2	3
Baker Mayfield	2019	CLE	574	22	21	29	24	1	5	4.2	-3
Kyler Murray	2019	ARI	590	20	12	23	18	8	5	4.1	4
Donovan McNabb	2011	MIN	172	4	2	8	1	2	7	4.1	-2
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2014	HOU	333	17	8	15	11	9	4	4.1	5
Tony Romo	2006	DAL	358	19	13	19	19	6	0	4.1	2
Josh Freeman	2012	TAM	584	27	17	46	32	10	14	4.0	6
Matt Ryan	2012	ATL	643	32	14	36	21	18	15	4.0	14
Josh McCown	2013	CHI	235	13	1	11	6	12	5	4.0	8
Chad Henne	2011	MIA	123	4	4	10	4	0	6	3.9	-4
Matthew Stafford	2017	DET	612	29	10	31	25	19	6	3.9	15
Brian Hoyer	2016	CHI	204	6	0	7	3	6	4	3.9	2
Eli Manning	2010	NYG	555	31	25	36	23	6	13	3.7	2
Charlie Batch	2006	PIT	56	5	0	4	1	5	3	3.6	1
Brian Griese	2007	CHI	277	10	12	15	13	-2	2	3.6	-6
Geno Smith	2021	SEA	108	5	1	7	3	4	4	3.6	0
Matt Moore	2009	CAR	147	8	2	8	3	6	5	3.6	2
Kerry Collins	2007	TEN	87	0	0	5	2	0	3	3.5	-4
Jared Goff	2018	LAR	594	32	12	32	26	20	6	3.5	17
Bruce Gradkowski	2009	OAK	161	6	3	8	3	3	5	3.5	0
Kyler Murray	2020	ARI	585	26	12	27	17	14	10	3.4	11
Chad Henne	2009	MIA	477	12	14	17	9	-2	8	3.4	-5
Peyton Manning	2010	IND	695	33	17	34	19	16	15	3.3	13
Jalen Hurts	2021	PHI	458	16	9	23	18	7	5	3.3	4
Tim Rattay	2006	TAM	105	4	2	3	1	2	2	3.2	-1
Colin Kaepernick	2014	SFO	530	19	10	26	23	9	3	3.2	6
Alex Smith	2014	KAN	509	18	6	13	10	12	3	3.2	9
Russell Wilson	2014	SEA	494	20	7	23	20	13	3	3.2	10
Kyle Orton	2014	BUF	480	18	10	20	17	8	3	3.2	5
Teddy Bridgewater	2014	MIN	441	14	12	14	11	2	3	3.1	-1
Seneca Wallace	2008	SEA	256	11	3	10	5	8	5	3.1	5
Joe Flacco	2013	BAL	662	19	22	37	31	-3	6	3.1	-6
Blaine Gabbert	2015	SFO	307	10	7	11	8	3	3	3.1	0
Mike Glennon	2014	TAM	219	10	6	12	9	4	3	3.1	1
Matthew Stafford	2012	DET	756	20	17	48	32	3	16	3.1	0
Jared Goff	2019	LAR	648	22	16	31	27	6	4	3.0	3
A.J. McCarron	2015	CIN	131	6	2	5	2	4	3	3.0	1
T.J. Yates	2015	HOU	62	3	1	4	1	2	3	3.0	-1
Jimmy Garoppolo	2016	NWE	66	4	0	4	1	4	3	3.0	1
Tim Tebow	2011	DEN	304	12	6	21	13	6	8	2.9	3
David Carr	2008	NYG	13	2	0	3	0	2	3	2.9	-1
Brian Hoyer	2019	IND	70	4	4	5	2	0	3	2.9	-3
Matt Schaub	2011	HOU	308	15	6	16	8	9	8	2.9	6
Justin Fields	2021	CHI	306	7	10	18	14	-3	4	2.8	-6
Marcus Mariota	2016	TEN	474	26	9	25	22	17	3	2.8	14
Andy Dalton	2016	CIN	604	18	8	22	19	10	3	2.8	7
Matt Ryan	2021	ATL	600	20	12	26	21	8	5	2.7	5
Dwayne Haskins	2019	WAS	232	7	7	8	5	0	3	2.7	-3
John Wolford	2020	LAR	40	0	1	4	1	-1	3	2.5	-4
Jake Delhomme	2007	CAR	91	8	1	5	3	7	2	2.5	4
Matt Ryan	2020	ATL	667	26	11	31	21	15	10	2.5	13
Sage Rosenfels	2006	HOU	40	3	1	2	0	2	2	2.5	0
Joe Flacco	2011	BAL	573	20	12	40	28	8	12	2.4	6
Drew Brees	2019	NOR	390	27	4	11	8	23	3	2.4	21
Damon Huard	2008	KAN	90	2	4	6	3	-2	3	2.3	-4
Nick Foles	2020	CHI	330	10	8	17	11	2	6	2.3	0
Brett Favre	2006	GNB	634	18	18	22	27	0	-5	2.2	-2
Eli Manning	2007	NYG	556	23	20	24	25	3	-1	2.2	1
Drew Brees	2014	NOR	688	33	17	30	28	16	2	2.2	14
Philip Rivers	2015	SDG	701	29	13	21	19	16	2	2.2	14
Alex Smith	2009	SFO	394	18	12	16	10	6	6	2.2	4
Joey Harrington	2007	ATL	380	7	8	12	12	-1	0	2.2	-3
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2010	BUF	465	23	15	29	19	8	10	2.2	6
Tony Romo	2014	DAL	464	34	9	20	18	25	2	2.1	23
Blake Bortles	2018	JAX	434	13	11	18	14	2	4	2.1	0
Kirk Cousins	2014	WAS	212	10	9	13	11	1	2	2.1	-1
Case Keenum	2015	STL	129	4	1	7	5	3	2	2.0	1
Gardner Minshew	2020	JAX	354	16	5	16	10	11	6	2.0	9
Nick Foles	2016	KAN	59	3	0	4	2	3	2	2.0	1
Matt Ryan	2013	ATL	695	26	17	25	20	9	5	2.0	7
Jason Campbell	2010	OAK	362	13	8	20	12	5	8	1.9	3
Carson Wentz	2021	IND	548	27	7	22	18	20	4	1.9	18
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2018	TAM	260	17	12	20	17	5	3	1.9	3
Patrick Mahomes	2017	KAN	37	0	1	3	1	-1	2	1.9	-3
Tarvaris Jackson	2008	MIN	163	9	2	7	4	7	3	1.8	5
Drew Lock	2020	DEN	462	16	15	30	23	1	7	1.8	-1
J.P. Losman	2011	MIA	15	0	0	2	0	0	2	1.7	-2
Philip Rivers	2016	SDG	614	33	21	25	23	12	2	1.7	10
Kyle Boller	2007	BAL	299	9	10	16	16	-1	0	1.7	-3
Teddy Bridgewater	2019	NOR	208	9	2	7	5	7	2	1.7	5
Josh Johnson	2021	2TM	88	5	2	3	1	3	2	1.7	1
Matt Moore	2012	MIA	21	1	0	2	0	1	2	1.6	-1
Chase Daniel	2018	CHI	85	3	2	4	2	1	2	1.6	-1
Charlie Batch	2011	PIT	26	0	1	3	1	-1	2	1.6	-3
Matt Leinart	2006	ARI	398	11	12	14	17	-1	-3	1.5	-3
Ryan Finley	2020	CIN	41	1	2	2	0	-1	2	1.5	-3
Mason Rudolph	2020	PIT	44	2	1	3	1	1	2	1.5	-1
Daniel Jones	2020	NYG	493	11	10	24	17	1	7	1.4	0
Jimmy Clausen	2010	CAR	332	3	9	14	7	-6	7	1.4	-7
Vince Young	2009	TEN	268	10	7	15	11	3	4	1.4	2
Chad Pennington	2008	MIA	500	19	7	16	11	12	5	1.3	11
Shaun Hill	2009	SFO	173	5	2	6	3	3	3	1.3	2
Matt Schaub	2006	ATL	29	1	2	3	2	-1	1	1.3	-2
P.J. Walker	2020	CAR	60	1	5	4	2	-4	2	1.3	-5
Matthew Stafford	2010	DET	100	6	1	4	1	5	3	1.3	4
Joe Flacco	2018	BAL	395	12	6	15	12	6	3	1.3	5
Tony Romo	2012	DAL	684	28	19	40	27	9	13	1.3	8
Ben Roethlisberger	2008	PIT	515	17	15	23	18	2	5	1.2	1
Seneca Wallace	2010	CLE	107	4	2	5	2	2	3	1.2	1
Joe Flacco	2014	BAL	573	27	12	24	23	15	1	1.2	14
Kirk Cousins	2015	WAS	569	29	11	21	20	18	1	1.2	17
Vince Young	2010	TEN	169	10	3	15	11	7	4	1.2	6
Jason Campbell	2011	OAK	170	6	4	7	3	2	4	1.2	1
Andy Dalton	2014	CIN	502	19	17	23	22	2	1	1.2	1
Jay Cutler	2015	CHI	512	21	11	19	18	10	1	1.2	9
Bruce Gradkowski	2007	TAM	26	0	1	1	0	-1	1	1.2	-2
Damon Huard	2007	KAN	368	11	13	14	15	-2	-1	1.1	-3
Jake Locker	2013	TEN	199	8	4	9	7	4	2	1.1	3
Charlie Batch	2010	PIT	53	3	3	5	3	0	2	1.1	-1
Mark Brunell	2006	WAS	272	8	4	13	15	4	-2	1.1	3
Matt Flynn	2011	GNB	54	6	2	4	2	4	2	1.1	3
JaMarcus Russell	2008	OAK	399	13	8	17	13	5	4	1.1	4
Matt Schaub	2008	HOU	403	15	10	19	15	5	4	1.1	4
Kevin Kolb	2009	PHI	99	4	3	3	1	1	2	1.0	0
Ryan Mallett	2014	HOU	76	2	2	4	3	0	1	1.0	-1
Christian Ponder	2014	MIN	50	0	2	2	1	-2	1	1.0	-3
Luke McCown	2015	NOR	40	0	1	2	1	-1	1	1.0	-2
Dan Orlovsky	2015	DET	40	1	1	2	1	0	1	1.0	-1
Josh Freeman	2015	IND	29	1	1	1	0	0	1	1.0	-1
Ben Roethlisberger	2020	PIT	621	33	10	26	18	23	8	1.0	22
Colin Kaepernick	2013	SFO	455	21	8	22	19	13	3	1.0	12
Alex Tanney	2015	TEN	17	1	0	1	0	1	1	1.0	0
C.J. Beathard	2021	JAX	2	0	0	1	0	0	1	1.0	-1
Sean Mannion	2019	MIN	21	0	2	2	1	-2	1	1.0	-3
Troy Smith	2008	BAL	5	1	0	1	0	1	1	1.0	0
Brian Hoyer	2021	NWE	11	1	0	1	0	1	1	1.0	0
Tarvaris Jackson	2013	SEA	13	1	0	1	0	1	1	0.9	0
Kyle Allen	2021	WAS	21	1	0	2	1	1	1	0.9	0
Cody Kessler	2016	CLE	216	6	2	5	4	4	1	0.9	3
Cody Kessler	2017	CLE	29	0	1	2	1	-1	1	0.9	-2
Chase Daniel	2019	CHI	71	3	2	4	3	1	1	0.9	0
Matt Barkley	2018	BUF	26	2	0	3	2	2	1	0.9	1
Nick Mullens	2021	CLE	30	1	0	1	0	1	1	0.9	0
Michael Vick	2009	PHI	13	1	0	1	0	1	1	0.9	0
Kyle Allen	2018	CAR	31	2	0	1	0	2	1	0.9	1
Sean Mannion	2021	MIN	38	1	0	1	0	1	1	0.9	0
Matt Cassel	2009	KAN	535	16	16	23	17	0	6	0.9	-1
Joe Flacco	2009	BAL	535	21	12	17	11	9	6	0.9	8
Kellen Clemens	2013	STL	263	8	7	10	8	1	2	0.8	0
Matt Schaub	2010	HOU	606	24	12	26	15	12	11	0.8	11
Jon Kitna	2011	DAL	10	1	2	3	2	-1	1	0.8	-2
Dak Prescott	2016	DAL	484	23	4	14	13	19	1	0.8	18
Alex Smith	2016	KAN	517	15	8	18	17	7	1	0.8	6
David Garrard	2008	JAX	577	15	13	21	16	2	5	0.8	1
Mitchell Trubisky	2017	CHI	361	7	7	14	12	0	2	0.8	-1
Brodie Croyle	2008	KAN	30	0	0	1	0	0	1	0.8	-1
Kyle Orton	2013	DAL	51	2	2	2	1	0	1	0.8	-1
Taylor Heinicke	2020	WAS	20	1	0	2	1	1	1	0.8	0
Ben Roethlisberger	2011	PIT	553	21	14	36	26	7	10	0.8	6
Mark Brunell	2010	NYJ	14	2	1	2	1	1	1	0.8	0
Todd Collins	2009	WAS	25	0	0	2	1	0	1	0.8	-1
Matthew Stafford	2016	DET	631	24	10	23	22	14	1	0.7	13
Kurt Warner	2007	ARI	471	27	17	21	23	10	-2	0.7	9
Byron Leftwich	2008	PIT	39	2	0	1	0	2	1	0.7	1
Kyle Boller	2006	BAL	58	5	2	3	3	3	0	0.7	2
Tyrod Taylor	2020	LAC	32	0	0	1	0	0	1	0.6	-1
Joey Harrington	2006	MIA	403	12	15	11	15	-3	-4	0.6	-4
Brodie Croyle	2009	KAN	43	2	0	1	0	2	1	0.6	1
Deshaun Watson	2018	HOU	567	26	9	22	19	17	3	0.6	16
Kelly Holcomb	2007	MIN	95	2	1	4	4	1	0	0.6	0
Drew Lock	2021	DEN	120	2	2	5	4	0	1	0.5	-1
Rex Grossman	2008	CHI	64	2	2	2	1	0	1	0.5	-1
Alex Smith	2006	SFO	477	16	16	20	25	0	-5	0.4	0
A.J. Feeley	2006	PHI	39	3	0	1	1	3	0	0.4	3
Kurt Warner	2008	ARI	624	30	14	22	17	16	5	0.4	16
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2017	TAM	170	7	3	7	6	4	1	0.4	4
Dak Prescott	2020	DAL	232	9	4	12	9	5	3	0.4	5
Josh Johnson	2011	TAM	39	1	2	1	0	-1	1	0.3	-1
Brady Quinn	2008	CLE	90	2	2	4	3	0	1	0.3	0
Brooks Bollinger	2007	MIN	57	1	1	1	1	0	0	0.3	0
Michael Vick	2013	PHI	156	5	3	9	8	2	1	0.3	2
Stephen McGee	2011	DAL	41	1	0	1	0	1	1	0.3	1
David Garrard	2010	JAX	399	23	15	25	18	8	7	0.3	8
Eli Manning	2008	NYG	506	21	10	19	15	11	4	0.3	11
Brooks Bollinger	2006	MIN	24	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.3	-1
Dak Prescott	2017	DAL	522	22	13	19	17	9	2	0.2	9
Brian Hoyer	2017	2TM	227	4	4	9	8	0	1	0.2	0
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2019	MIA	542	20	13	18	17	7	1	0.2	7
Jake Locker	2012	TEN	339	10	11	19	13	-1	6	0.2	-1
Aaron Rodgers	2007	GNB	31	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.2	1
Matt Ryan	2018	ATL	660	35	7	24	21	28	3	0.2	28
Carson Wentz	2018	PHI	432	21	7	18	16	14	2	0.1	14
Brian Hoyer	2014	CLE	462	12	13	24	24	-1	0	0.1	-1
Derek Anderson	2007	CLE	541	29	19	31	34	10	-3	0.1	10
Joe Flacco	2010	BAL	529	25	10	28	19	15	9	0.1	15
Kirk Cousins	2012	WAS	51	4	3	5	4	1	1	0.1	1
Matt Cassel	2006	NWE	11	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.1	0
Aaron Rodgers	2017	GNB	260	16	6	11	10	10	1	0.1	10
Charlie Frye	2009	OAK	92	1	4	5	4	-3	1	0.1	-3
Craig Nall	2007	GNB	16	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.1	1
Brad Johnson	2007	DAL	12	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.1	0
Zach Mettenberger	2014	TEN	197	8	7	8	8	1	0	0.1	1
Kellen Clemens	2006	NYJ	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.1	0
Jared Lorenzen	2007	NYG	9	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.1	0
Matt McGloin	2013	OAK	217	8	8	15	14	0	1	0.0	0
Andrew Walter	2007	OAK	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Brady Quinn	2007	CLE	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Anthony Wright	2007	NYG	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Kirk Cousins	2017	WAS	581	27	13	23	21	14	2	0.0	14
Gus Frerotte	2006	STL	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Billy Volek	2006	SDG	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Vinny Testaverde	2006	NWE	3	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Anthony Wright	2006	CIN	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Derek Anderson	2014	CAR	101	5	0	2	2	5	0	0.0	5
Mark Sanchez	2015	PHI	100	4	4	4	4	0	0	0.0	0
Chad Henne	2014	JAX	94	3	1	4	4	2	0	0.0	2
Ken Dorsey	2006	CLE	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Hasselbeck	2014	IND	46	2	0	1	1	2	0	0.0	2
Kevin Kolb	2007	PHI	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Patrick Ramsey	2006	NYJ	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chase Daniel	2014	KAN	32	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Drew Stanton	2015	ARI	27	0	2	1	1	-2	0	0.0	-2
Jason Campbell	2014	CIN	20	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Tom Savage	2014	HOU	20	0	1	2	2	-1	0	0.0	-1
Matt Gutierrez	2007	NWE	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Logan Thomas	2014	ARI	11	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Brock Osweiler	2014	DEN	10	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Ryan Lindley	2015	IND	10	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Sean Renfree	2015	ATL	9	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.0	-1
Matt Simms	2014	NYJ	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Shaun Hill	2015	MIN	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Blaine Gabbert	2014	SFO	7	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Ryan Nassib	2014	NYG	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Sean Mannion	2015	STL	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Tarvaris Jackson	2015	SEA	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Kellen Clemens	2015	SDG	6	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Derek Anderson	2015	CAR	6	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Ryan Nassib	2015	NYG	5	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Kellen Clemens	2014	SDG	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
T.J. Yates	2014	ATL	4	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.0	-1
Jimmy Garoppolo	2015	NWE	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Jordan Palmer	2014	TEN	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chase Daniel	2015	KAN	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Scott Tolzien	2015	GNB	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
B.J. Daniels	2015	2TM	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Tarvaris Jackson	2014	SEA	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Barkley	2014	PHI	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Moore	2015	MIA	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Kellen Clemens	2016	SDG	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chase Daniel	2016	PHI	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Schaub	2016	ATL	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Alex Tanney	2019	NYG	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
David Fales	2016	CHI	6	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Ryan Mallett	2016	BAL	6	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.0	-1
Blake Bortles	2019	LAR	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Tyler Bray	2017	KAN	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Brett Hundley	2016	GNB	10	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.0	-1
Donovan McNabb	2007	PHI	517	19	7	16	19	12	-3	0.0	12
Colt McCoy	2013	SFO	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Luke McCown	2013	NOR	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Garrett Gilbert	2019	CLE	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Mike Glennon	2016	TAM	11	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Ryan Griffin	2019	TAM	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Tim Boyle	2019	GNB	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Teddy Bridgewater	2017	MIN	2	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.0	-1
Taylor Heinicke	2017	HOU	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Geno Smith	2016	NYJ	17	1	1	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Luke McCown	2008	TAM	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Dennis Dixon	2008	PIT	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Josh McCown	2019	PHI	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Marcus Mariota	2021	LVR	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Brett Rypien	2021	DEN	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Nate Sudfeld	2018	PHI	2	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
Brian Hoyer	2018	NWE	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Tyrod Taylor	2019	LAC	6	1	0	0	0	1	0	0.0	1
J.P. Losman	2009	OAK	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Gutierrez	2009	KAN	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Cooper Rush	2017	DAL	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Easton Stick	2020	LAC	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Trevor Siemian	2019	NYJ	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Sean Mannion	2018	LAR	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chad Henne	2018	KAN	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Cleo Lemon	2008	JAX	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Mike Glennon	2019	OAK	10	1	0	1	1	1	0	0.0	1
Shaun Hill	2016	MIN	36	0	0	1	1	0	0	0.0	0
Brian Hoyer	2011	NWE	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Billy Volek	2010	SDG	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chase Daniel	2012	NOR	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Josh Johnson	2012	CLE	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
A.J. McCarron	2018	OAK	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Jacoby Brissett	2018	IND	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Garrett Gilbert	2018	CAR	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Brett Hundley	2019	ARI	13	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Charlie Batch	2009	PIT	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chris Simms	2008	TEN	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Brock Berlin	2008	STL	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
A.J. McCarron	2020	HOU	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Cassel	2016	TEN	56	2	2	1	1	0	0	0.0	0
Joe Callahan	2017	GNB	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Moore	2013	MIA	6	0	2	1	1	-2	0	0.0	-2
Kellen Clemens	2017	LAC	8	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.0	-1
Derek Anderson	2017	CAR	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Marques Tuiasosopo	2008	OAK	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Patrick Ramsey	2008	DEN	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Matt Schaub	2018	ATL	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Tom Brandstater	2011	STL	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Kellen Clemens	2010	NYJ	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chad Pennington	2010	MIA	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Logan Woodside	2020	TEN	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Trent Edwards	2012	PHI	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Kellen Clemens	2008	NYJ	5	0	1	0	0	-1	0	0.0	-1
Matt Flynn	2008	GNB	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Drew Henson	2008	DET	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Brian St. Pierre	2009	ARI	4	1	1	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Chris Streveler	2021	ARI	11	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Blaine Gabbert	2021	TAM	12	0	0	1	1	0	0	0.0	0
Luke McCown	2009	JAX	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	0.0	0
Byron Leftwich	2009	TAM	109	4	3	4	3	1	1	0.0	1
Mark Brunell	2011	NYJ	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Shaun Hill	2011	DET	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Tyrod Taylor	2011	BAL	3	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
A.J. McCarron	2017	CIN	15	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Kevin O'Connell	2008	NWE	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Kellen Clemens	2012	STL	3	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Joshua Dobbs	2018	PIT	12	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Joshua Dobbs	2020	PIT	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Tyler Bray	2020	CHI	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Tyler Huntley	2020	BAL	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Pat White	2009	MIA	6	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Quinn Gray	2008	KAN	8	1	0	0	0	1	0	-0.1	1
A.J. McCarron	2019	HOU	42	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Chase Daniel	2010	NOR	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Caleb Hanie	2009	CHI	7	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Geno Smith	2020	SEA	6	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
David Carr	2012	NYG	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Ryan Mallett	2012	NWE	4	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Graham Harrell	2012	GNB	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Brock Osweiler	2012	DEN	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Derek Anderson	2012	CAR	4	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Robert Griffin	2016	CLE	169	2	3	3	3	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Tarvaris Jackson	2010	MIN	64	3	4	3	2	-1	1	-0.1	-1
Matt Cassel	2018	DET	18	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Nathan Peterman	2020	LVR	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Brock Osweiler	2013	DEN	18	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Jay Cutler	2012	CHI	472	19	14	31	23	5	8	-0.1	5
Colin Kaepernick	2011	SFO	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Chase Daniel	2011	NOR	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Kyle Boller	2010	OAK	5	0	1	1	1	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Jordan Palmer	2010	CIN	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Alex Smith	2020	WAS	274	6	8	10	7	-2	3	-0.1	-2
Rusty Smith	2012	TEN	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Tyler Thigpen	2012	BUF	5	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Rex Grossman	2009	HOU	9	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Troy Smith	2009	BAL	9	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Chad Henne	2008	MIA	12	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Nate Sudfeld	2017	PHI	26	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Kerry Collins	2008	TEN	423	12	7	13	10	5	3	-0.1	5
Mike Glennon	2018	ARI	22	1	0	0	0	1	0	-0.1	1
Chris Redman	2010	ATL	6	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Jacoby Brissett	2020	IND	10	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Case Keenum	2020	CLE	10	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Dan Orlovsky	2012	TAM	7	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Matt Flynn	2009	GNB	13	0	1	0	0	-1	0	-0.1	-1
Geno Smith	2017	NYG	39	1	0	1	1	1	0	-0.1	1
Tyler Palko	2010	KAN	8	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
J.T. O'Sullivan	2009	CIN	14	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.1	0
Sean Mannion	2017	LAR	40	0	0	2	2	0	0	-0.1	0
Alex Smith	2012	SFO	242	13	5	8	4	8	4	-0.1	8
Matt Moore	2019	KAN	99	4	0	3	3	4	0	-0.1	4
Byron Leftwich	2010	PIT	9	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.2	0
Caleb Hanie	2010	CHI	9	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.2	0
Matt Flynn	2012	SEA	9	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.2	0
Sam Bradford	2017	MIN	47	3	0	4	4	3	0	-0.2	3
E.J. Manuel	2017	OAK	47	1	1	1	1	0	0	-0.2	0
Cleo Lemon	2006	MIA	73	2	1	4	5	1	-1	-0.2	1
Joe Flacco	2021	NYJ	44	3	0	1	1	3	0	-0.2	3
Kyle Orton	2012	DAL	10	1	0	0	0	1	0	-0.2	1
Matt Cassel	2013	MIN	270	11	9	12	11	2	1	-0.2	2
Bruce Gradkowski	2012	CIN	11	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.2	0
Blaine Gabbert	2020	TAM	17	2	0	0	0	2	0	-0.2	2
Tarvaris Jackson	2009	MIN	21	1	0	0	0	1	0	-0.2	1
Matt Leinart	2011	HOU	13	1	0	1	1	1	0	-0.2	1
Tony Pike	2010	CAR	13	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.2	0
Jim Sorgi	2008	IND	30	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.2	0
Mason Rudolph	2021	PIT	58	1	1	2	2	0	0	-0.2	0
Shaun Hill	2012	DET	13	2	0	1	1	2	0	-0.2	2
Matt Flynn	2010	GNB	73	3	2	5	4	1	1	-0.2	1
Matt Leinart	2008	ARI	31	1	1	0	0	0	0	-0.2	0
Seneca Wallace	2006	SEA	155	8	7	6	8	1	-2	-0.2	1
Seneca Wallace	2009	SEA	129	3	2	3	2	1	1	-0.2	1
Matt Barkley	2020	BUF	22	1	1	2	2	0	0	-0.2	0
Gardner Minshew	2021	PHI	65	4	1	2	2	3	0	-0.2	3
Kirk Cousins	2020	MIN	555	35	13	24	18	22	6	-0.2	22
Brian Hoyer	2010	NWE	15	1	1	1	1	0	0	-0.3	0
Tyler Thigpen	2008	KAN	446	18	12	20	17	6	3	-0.3	6
Brian Hoyer	2009	NWE	29	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.3	0
Mike Kafka	2011	PHI	17	0	2	2	2	-2	0	-0.3	-2
Kellen Clemens	2009	NYJ	30	0	0	1	1	0	0	-0.3	0
Josh Johnson	2010	TAM	18	0	0	0	0	0	0	-0.3	0
Billy Volek	2009	SDG	32	1	1	1	1	0	0	-0.3	0
Marcus Mariota	2020	LVR	28	1	1	2	2	0	0	-0.3	0
Bruce Gradkowski	2011	CIN	19	1	1	0	0	0	0	-0.3	0
Philip Rivers	2020	IND	562	24	11	27	21	13	6	-0.3	13
David Carr	2009	NYG	35	1	0	0	0	1	0	-0.3	1
Colt McCoy	2012	CLE	21	1	0	0	0	1	0	-0.4	1
Rex Grossman	2010	WAS	142	7	4	11	9	3	2	-0.4	3
Richard Bartel	2011	ARI	23	1	1	0	0	0	0	-0.4	0
Brian Griese	2008	TAM	193	5	7	8	7	-2	1	-0.4	-2
Tony Romo	2008	DAL	470	26	14	28	25	12	3	-0.4	12
Brian Brohm	2010	BUF	26	0	3	0	0	-3	0	-0.4	-3
Chad Henne	2020	KAN	40	2	0	0	0	2	0	-0.5	2
Garrett Gilbert	2020	DAL	40	1	1	2	2	0	0	-0.5	0
Matt Moore	2017	MIA	139	4	5	6	6	-1	0	-0.5	-1
Dak Prescott	2018	DAL	582	22	8	20	18	14	2	-0.5	14
Richard Bartel	2010	ARI	30	0	1	1	1	-1	0	-0.5	0
Terrelle Pryor	2012	OAK	30	2	1	3	3	1	0	-0.5	2
Rex Grossman	2007	CHI	250	4	7	12	14	-3	-2	-0.6	-2
Lamar Jackson	2020	BAL	405	26	9	21	17	17	4	-0.6	18
Sage Rosenfels	2007	HOU	246	15	12	12	14	3	-2	-0.6	4
Trent Dilfer	2007	SFO	246	7	12	11	13	-5	-2	-0.6	-4
Matt Leinart	2012	OAK	34	0	1	1	1	-1	0	-0.6	0
Derek Carr	2018	OAK	604	17	12	26	24	5	2	-0.6	6
Joe Flacco	2020	NYJ	141	6	3	9	8	3	1	-0.6	4
Kyle Orton	2008	CHI	492	18	12	19	16	6	3	-0.6	7
Kevin Kolb	2012	ARI	210	8	3	10	7	5	3	-0.6	6
Lamar Jackson	2021	BAL	420	16	13	19	18	3	1	-0.6	4
Jimmy Garoppolo	2017	SFO	186	7	5	4	4	2	0	-0.6	3
Byron Leftwich	2007	ATL	64	1	2	0	1	-1	-1	-0.6	0
Brad Johnson	2006	MIN	468	9	15	13	19	-6	-6	-0.7	-5
Jamie Martin	2006	NOR	29	1	1	3	4	0	-1	-0.7	1
Kellen Clemens	2011	STL	100	2	1	4	3	1	1	-0.7	2
Andy Dalton	2013	CIN	615	33	20	27	25	13	2	-0.7	14
Quinn Gray	2006	JAX	23	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-0.7	1
Jim Sorgi	2007	IND	38	1	0	0	1	1	-1	-0.8	2
A.J. Feeley	2011	STL	107	1	2	4	3	-1	1	-0.8	0
Charlie Batch	2007	PIT	36	2	3	1	2	-1	-1	-0.8	0
Aaron Rodgers	2006	GNB	18	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-0.8	1
Daunte Culpepper	2007	OAK	207	5	5	11	13	0	-2	-0.8	1
Bruce Gradkowski	2010	OAK	167	5	7	8	6	-2	2	-0.8	-1
Brock Berlin	2007	STL	28	0	1	1	2	-1	-1	-0.8	0
Tim Rattay	2007	ARI	27	3	3	1	2	0	-1	-0.8	1
Marques Tuiasosopo	2006	OAK	13	1	2	0	1	-1	-1	-0.9	0
Joe Flacco	2015	BAL	429	14	12	21	22	2	-1	-0.9	3
Nick Foles	2018	PHI	204	7	4	7	7	3	0	-0.9	4
Brett Basanez	2006	CAR	11	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-0.9	0
Seneca Wallace	2011	CLE	113	2	2	5	4	0	1	-0.9	1
Brodie Croyle	2006	KAN	8	0	2	0	1	-2	-1	-0.9	-1
Charlie Frye	2007	2TM	15	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-0.9	0
Colin Kaepernick	2015	SFO	272	6	5	10	11	1	-1	-0.9	2
Shaun Hill	2014	STL	247	8	7	10	11	1	-1	-0.9	2
Kyle Orton	2010	DEN	532	20	9	27	19	11	8	-0.9	12
Billy Volek	2007	SDG	12	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-0.9	0
Byron Leftwich	2012	PIT	56	0	1	2	2	-1	0	-1.0	0
Matt Cassel	2007	NWE	7	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Tyler Thigpen	2007	KAN	7	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Kellen Moore	2015	DAL	109	4	6	2	3	-2	-1	-1.0	-1
Case Keenum	2014	2TM	80	2	2	3	4	0	-1	-1.0	1
Trent Edwards	2009	BUF	206	6	7	8	7	-1	1	-1.0	0
Matt Cassel	2010	KAN	476	27	7	22	15	20	7	-1.0	21
Geno Smith	2015	NYJ	45	2	1	1	2	1	-1	-1.0	2
Brandon Weeden	2014	DAL	42	3	2	1	2	1	-1	-1.0	2
Johnny Manziel	2014	CLE	38	0	2	1	2	-2	-1	-1.0	-1
Connor Shaw	2014	CLE	32	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Matt McGloin	2014	OAK	20	1	2	1	2	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Matt Flynn	2014	GNB	18	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Colt McCoy	2015	WAS	12	1	0	0	1	1	-1	-1.0	2
Matt Moore	2014	MIA	4	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.0	1
Tony Romo	2016	DAL	4	1	0	0	1	1	-1	-1.0	2
Sean Mannion	2016	LAR	6	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Philip Rivers	2017	LAC	593	28	10	24	23	18	1	-1.0	19
Feleipe Franks	2021	ATL	1	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Matt McGloin	2016	OAK	15	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.0	1
Chad Henne	2017	JAX	2	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.0	1
Jarrett Stidham	2019	NWE	5	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Mark Sanchez	2016	DAL	21	0	2	1	2	-2	-1	-1.0	-1
Charlie Whitehurst	2016	CLE	26	1	1	0	1	0	-1	-1.0	1
Kellen Mond	2021	MIN	3	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.0	1
Kevin Hogan	2016	CLE	28	0	2	1	2	-2	-1	-1.0	-1
Jake Rudock	2017	DET	5	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
John Wolford	2021	LAR	5	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Jacob Eason	2021	IND	5	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Tyrod Taylor	2013	BAL	5	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Matt Hasselbeck	2012	TEN	235	7	5	12	9	2	3	-1.0	3
Robert Griffin	2018	BAL	6	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.0	1
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2021	WAS	7	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.0	1
Mitchell Trubisky	2021	BUF	8	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.0	0
Tom Savage	2016	HOU	78	0	0	2	3	0	-1	-1.0	1
Landry Jones	2016	PIT	90	4	2	5	6	2	-1	-1.0	3
Josh Rosen	2021	ATL	11	0	2	0	1	-2	-1	-1.0	-1
Levi Brown	2010	BUF	3	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.1	0
Matt Hasselbeck	2013	IND	12	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.1	0
Ryan Mallett	2017	BAL	16	2	0	0	1	2	-1	-1.1	3
Kyle Allen	2020	WAS	94	4	1	3	3	3	0	-1.1	4
Chad Henne	2021	KAN	16	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
Josh McCown	2009	CAR	7	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
Tyler Thigpen	2009	2TM	8	1	2	1	2	-1	-1	-1.1	0
Tom Brady	2008	NWE	11	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
Jordan Palmer	2008	CIN	14	0	2	0	1	-2	-1	-1.1	-1
Ian Book	2021	NOR	28	0	2	0	1	-2	-1	-1.1	-1
Teddy Bridgewater	2018	NOR	25	1	1	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
Luke McCown	2007	TAM	154	5	3	5	7	2	-2	-1.1	3
Trace McSorley	2020	BAL	10	1	0	0	1	1	-1	-1.1	2
Mike Glennon	2020	JAX	188	7	5	11	10	2	1	-1.1	3
Seneca Wallace	2013	GNB	28	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.1	0
Garrett Gilbert	2021	WAS	33	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
Tyler Thigpen	2011	BUF	8	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.1	0
Brandon Allen	2019	DEN	93	3	2	2	3	1	-1	-1.1	2
Jay Cutler	2007	DEN	494	20	14	21	25	6	-4	-1.1	7
Brandon Allen	2021	CIN	38	2	0	0	1	2	-1	-1.1	3
Brooks Bollinger	2008	DAL	20	1	1	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
Jameis Winston	2020	NOR	13	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
David Fales	2017	MIA	44	1	1	0	1	0	-1	-1.1	1
Nate Sudfeld	2020	PHI	14	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.2	0
Drew Stanton	2008	DET	23	1	0	0	1	1	-1	-1.2	2
Chase Daniel	2013	KAN	40	1	1	1	2	0	-1	-1.2	1
Bruce Gradkowski	2008	CLE	25	0	3	0	1	-3	-1	-1.2	-2
Nick Foles	2019	JAX	125	3	2	6	7	1	-1	-1.2	2
Jake Locker	2011	TEN	71	4	0	3	3	4	0	-1.2	5
T.J. Yates	2012	HOU	11	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.2	0
Charlie Frye	2008	SEA	26	2	2	1	2	0	-1	-1.2	1
Robert Griffin	2020	BAL	17	0	2	0	1	-2	-1	-1.2	-1
Chris Simms	2009	DEN	22	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.2	0
David Carr	2010	SFO	14	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.2	0
Robert Griffin	2012	WAS	423	20	5	16	10	15	6	-1.2	16
Kevin Kolb	2008	PHI	34	0	4	1	2	-4	-1	-1.2	-3
Colt McCoy	2018	WAS	60	3	3	3	4	0	-1	-1.3	1
John Skelton	2010	ARI	135	2	2	6	5	0	1	-1.3	1
C.J. Beathard	2020	SFO	113	6	0	4	4	6	0	-1.3	7
Shaun Hill	2008	SFO	311	13	8	13	12	5	1	-1.3	6
David Blough	2019	DET	188	4	6	7	8	-2	-1	-1.3	-1
Trey Lance	2021	SFO	75	5	2	3	4	3	-1	-1.3	4
Jay Cutler	2006	DEN	150	9	5	5	8	4	-3	-1.3	5
Brandon Weeden	2013	CLE	294	9	9	14	14	0	0	-1.3	1
Mark Brunell	2009	NOR	30	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.3	0
Brian Brohm	2009	BUF	31	0	2	0	1	-2	-1	-1.3	-1
Luke McCown	2010	JAX	19	0	0	0	1	0	-1	-1.3	1
Matt Moore	2007	CAR	117	3	5	5	7	-2	-2	-1.3	-1
Chad Pennington	2007	NYJ	286	10	9	13	16	1	-3	-1.3	2
David Garrard	2009	JAX	558	15	10	26	22	5	4	-1.4	6
Case Keenum	2019	WAS	262	11	5	11	12	6	-1	-1.4	7
Brodie Croyle	2010	KAN	23	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.4	0
Andrew Walter	2008	OAK	54	0	3	0	1	-3	-1	-1.4	-2
Bryce Petty	2017	NYJ	120	1	3	5	6	-2	-1	-1.4	-1
Jimmy Garoppolo	2018	SFO	102	5	3	4	5	2	-1	-1.4	3
Brett Rypien	2020	DEN	41	2	4	4	5	-2	-1	-1.5	-1
Chris Redman	2011	ATL	28	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.5	0
Jon Kitna	2006	DET	659	21	22	24	33	-1	-9	-1.5	0
Marc Bulger	2008	STL	478	11	13	18	16	-2	2	-1.5	-1
Alex Smith	2018	WAS	350	10	5	9	9	5	0	-1.5	6
Jake Delhomme	2011	HOU	30	1	0	0	1	1	-1	-1.5	3
Shaun Hill	2007	SFO	85	5	1	2	4	4	-2	-1.5	6
Marc Bulger	2009	STL	261	5	6	10	9	-1	1	-1.5	1
Aaron Brooks	2006	OAK	218	3	8	7	11	-5	-4	-1.5	-3
Chase Daniel	2020	DET	46	1	2	2	3	-1	-1	-1.5	1
Brian St. Pierre	2010	CAR	31	1	2	1	2	-1	-1	-1.5	1
Troy Smith	2007	BAL	80	2	0	2	4	2	-2	-1.5	4
Tyrod Taylor	2012	BAL	32	0	1	0	1	-1	-1	-1.5	1
Todd Bouman	2010	JAX	35	2	2	3	4	0	-1	-1.6	2
Patrick Mahomes	2021	KAN	686	37	13	23	22	24	1	-1.6	26
Tyrod Taylor	2021	HOU	163	5	5	4	5	0	-1	-1.6	2
Brady Quinn	2009	CLE	275	8	7	7	6	1	1	-1.6	3
Matt Hasselbeck	2008	SEA	228	5	10	8	8	-5	0	-1.7	-3
Rusty Smith	2010	TEN	41	0	4	3	4	-4	-1	-1.7	-2
Jimmy Garoppolo	2020	SFO	151	7	5	4	4	2	0	-1.7	4
Kirk Cousins	2013	WAS	160	4	7	6	7	-3	-1	-1.7	-1
Greg McElroy	2012	NYJ	42	1	1	1	2	0	-1	-1.7	2
Gardner Minshew	2019	JAX	503	21	6	18	19	15	-1	-1.7	17
Charlie Whitehurst	2010	SEA	104	2	3	3	3	-1	0	-1.7	1
Baker Mayfield	2021	CLE	461	17	13	20	20	4	0	-1.8	6
Alex Smith	2007	SFO	210	2	4	6	9	-2	-3	-1.8	0
Colt McCoy	2020	NYG	71	1	1	1	2	0	-1	-1.8	2
Brett Favre	2007	GNB	550	28	15	27	32	13	-5	-1.8	15
Mitchell Trubisky	2019	CHI	554	17	10	20	21	7	-1	-1.8	9
Tom Savage	2017	HOU	244	5	6	13	14	-1	-1	-1.8	1
Jeff Driskel	2018	CIN	193	6	2	7	8	4	-1	-1.8	6
J.T. O'Sullivan	2007	DET	29	1	2	1	3	-1	-2	-1.8	1
Alex Smith	2015	KAN	515	20	7	13	15	13	-2	-1.8	15
J.T. O'Sullivan	2008	SFO	252	8	11	17	17	-3	0	-1.8	-1
Chris Weinke	2007	SFO	27	1	0	0	2	1	-2	-1.8	3
Jeff Driskel	2020	DEN	75	3	2	2	3	1	-1	-1.8	3
Teddy Bridgewater	2015	MIN	491	14	9	17	19	5	-2	-1.8	7
Philip Rivers	2012	SDG	576	26	15	31	23	11	8	-1.9	13
J.P. Losman	2007	BUF	189	4	6	7	10	-2	-3	-1.9	0
Kerry Collins	2006	TEN	94	1	6	3	6	-5	-3	-1.9	-3
Jacoby Brissett	2021	MIA	244	5	4	9	10	1	-1	-1.9	3
Matt Cassel	2015	2TM	218	5	7	5	7	-2	-2	-1.9	0
Colt McCoy	2014	WAS	145	4	3	4	6	1	-2	-2.0	3
E.J. Manuel	2014	BUF	137	5	3	5	7	2	-2	-2.0	4
Dan Orlovsky	2008	DET	269	8	8	11	11	0	0	-2.0	2
Matt Schaub	2015	BAL	83	3	4	2	4	-1	-2	-2.0	1
Brian Hoyer	2012	ARI	57	1	2	1	2	-1	-1	-2.0	1
Landry Jones	2015	PIT	57	3	4	3	5	-1	-2	-2.0	1
Tarvaris Jackson	2006	MIN	89	2	4	3	6	-2	-3	-2.0	0
Matt McGloin	2015	OAK	34	2	1	0	2	1	-2	-2.0	3
Jimmy Garoppolo	2014	NWE	32	1	0	0	2	1	-2	-2.0	3
Matt Schaub	2014	OAK	13	0	2	0	2	-2	-2	-2.0	0
Cardale Jones	2016	BUF	12	0	1	0	2	-1	-2	-2.0	1
Trevone Boykin	2016	SEA	19	1	1	0	2	0	-2	-2.0	2
E.J. Manuel	2016	BUF	29	0	0	0	2	0	-2	-2.0	2
Drew Stanton	2016	ARI	49	2	3	1	3	-1	-2	-2.0	1
Kyle Lauletta	2018	NYG	5	0	1	0	2	-1	-2	-2.0	1
Joe Webb	2017	BUF	7	0	1	0	2	-1	-2	-2.0	1
Matt Moore	2016	MIA	88	8	3	2	4	5	-2	-2.0	7
Vince Young	2011	PHI	122	4	9	9	9	-5	0	-2.0	-3
Colt McCoy	2019	WAS	33	0	1	1	3	-1	-2	-2.0	1
Robert Griffin	2019	BAL	43	1	2	0	2	-1	-2	-2.1	1
Curtis Painter	2013	NYG	17	0	2	0	2	-2	-2	-2.1	0
Chris Redman	2007	ATL	158	10	5	4	7	5	-3	-2.1	7
Ben Roethlisberger	2019	PIT	64	0	1	1	3	-1	-2	-2.1	1
Drew Stanton	2010	DET	125	4	3	6	6	1	0	-2.1	3
Landry Jones	2017	PIT	31	1	1	0	2	0	-2	-2.1	2
T.J. Yates	2013	HOU	24	0	2	0	2	-2	-2	-2.1	0
Colt McCoy	2010	CLE	245	6	9	11	9	-3	2	-2.1	-1
David Blough	2020	DET	11	0	1	0	2	-1	-2	-2.1	1
David Carr	2007	CAR	149	3	5	3	6	-2	-3	-2.1	0
Case Keenum	2016	LAR	345	9	11	11	13	-2	-2	-2.1	0
Nick Foles	2021	CHI	39	1	0	0	2	1	-2	-2.1	3
Matt Simms	2013	NYJ	35	1	1	0	2	0	-2	-2.2	2
Matt Cassel	2017	TEN	50	1	2	2	4	-1	-2	-2.2	1
Cooper Rush	2021	DAL	50	3	1	2	4	2	-2	-2.2	4
Case Keenum	2013	HOU	272	9	6	14	15	3	-1	-2.2	5
Chris Redman	2009	ATL	127	4	3	3	4	1	-1	-2.2	3
Eli Manning	2019	NYG	152	6	5	7	9	1	-2	-2.2	3
Dennis Dixon	2009	PIT	26	1	1	0	2	0	-2	-2.3	2
Vince Young	2008	TEN	39	1	2	0	2	-1	-2	-2.3	1
Jason Campbell	2009	WAS	550	20	15	20	17	5	3	-2.3	7
Brian Hoyer	2020	NWE	26	0	1	1	3	-1	-2	-2.3	1
Case Keenum	2021	CLE	77	3	1	0	2	2	-2	-2.3	4
Curtis Painter	2009	IND	31	0	2	0	2	-2	-2	-2.3	0
Jake Delhomme	2009	CAR	344	8	18	15	14	-10	1	-2.3	-8
Matt Leinart	2007	ARI	116	2	4	1	4	-2	-3	-2.3	0
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2009	BUF	248	9	10	9	9	-1	0	-2.4	1
Scott Tolzien	2013	GNB	93	1	5	6	8	-4	-2	-2.4	-2
Tyrod Taylor	2018	CLE	98	2	2	2	4	0	-2	-2.4	2
Joe Flacco	2019	DEN	288	6	5	8	10	1	-2	-2.4	3
Brian Hoyer	2013	CLE	102	5	3	3	5	2	-2	-2.4	4
Kyle Orton	2007	CHI	82	3	2	3	6	1	-3	-2.5	4
Jarrett Stidham	2020	NWE	48	2	3	0	2	-1	-2	-2.5	2
Jason Campbell	2006	WAS	214	10	6	5	10	4	-5	-2.6	7
Trent Green	2008	STL	78	0	6	2	4	-6	-2	-2.6	-3
Thaddeus Lewis	2012	CLE	35	1	1	0	2	0	-2	-2.6	3
Brian Griese	2006	CHI	35	1	2	2	5	-1	-3	-2.6	2
Dennis Dixon	2010	PIT	37	0	1	1	3	-1	-2	-2.6	2
Josh Freeman	2013	2TM	155	2	4	7	9	-2	-2	-2.7	1
Ken Dorsey	2008	CLE	96	0	7	3	5	-7	-2	-2.7	-4
Patrick Ramsey	2007	DEN	51	1	1	0	3	0	-3	-2.7	3
Carson Palmer	2009	CIN	492	21	13	18	16	8	2	-2.7	11
Chad Henne	2012	JAX	336	11	11	15	12	0	3	-2.8	3
Jacoby Brissett	2017	IND	521	13	7	15	16	6	-1	-2.8	9
Matt Leinart	2009	ARI	79	0	3	2	4	-3	-2	-2.8	0
Chad Pennington	2009	MIA	80	1	2	0	2	-1	-2	-2.8	2
Jeff Garcia	2006	PHI	194	10	2	8	13	8	-5	-2.8	11
Stephen McGee	2010	DAL	47	2	0	2	4	2	-2	-2.8	5
C.J. Beathard	2018	SFO	187	8	7	3	5	1	-2	-2.8	4
Ryan Tannehill	2015	MIA	631	24	12	24	27	12	-3	-2.8	15
Seneca Wallace	2007	SEA	31	2	1	0	3	1	-3	-2.8	4
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2011	BUF	591	24	23	33	26	1	7	-2.9	4
Brock Osweiler	2015	DEN	298	10	6	7	10	4	-3	-2.9	7
Matt Hasselbeck	2015	IND	272	9	5	6	9	4	-3	-2.9	7
Gus Frerotte	2007	STL	178	7	12	10	14	-5	-4	-3.0	-2
Josh Freeman	2009	TAM	310	10	18	16	16	-8	0	-3.0	-5
Jimmy Clausen	2014	CHI	51	2	1	0	3	1	-3	-3.0	4
Charlie Whitehurst	2015	2TM	37	0	1	0	3	-1	-3	-3.0	2
Luke McCown	2011	JAX	60	0	4	4	6	-4	-2	-3.0	-1
Connor Cook	2016	OAK	23	1	1	0	3	0	-3	-3.0	3
Scott Tolzien	2016	IND	40	1	2	2	5	-1	-3	-3.0	2
Geno Smith	2018	LAC	5	0	0	0	3	0	-3	-3.0	3
Derek Anderson	2016	CAR	53	2	5	1	4	-3	-3	-3.0	0
Matt Barkley	2019	BUF	53	0	3	2	5	-3	-3	-3.1	0
Matt Schaub	2019	ATL	69	3	1	1	4	2	-3	-3.1	5
Kerry Collins	2009	TEN	222	6	8	7	8	-2	-1	-3.1	1
Blaine Gabbert	2012	JAX	300	9	6	11	9	3	2	-3.1	6
Kurt Warner	2009	ARI	537	26	14	18	16	12	2	-3.2	15
Mark Sanchez	2018	WAS	42	0	3	1	4	-3	-3	-3.2	0
Paxton Lynch	2017	DEN	54	2	3	1	4	-1	-3	-3.2	2
Chris Streveler	2020	ARI	18	1	1	0	3	0	-3	-3.2	3
Sam Bradford	2013	STL	277	14	4	9	11	10	-2	-3.2	13
Drew Lock	2019	DEN	161	7	3	5	8	4	-3	-3.2	7
Taylor Heinicke	2018	CAR	59	1	3	1	4	-2	-3	-3.3	1
Cam Newton	2013	CAR	516	24	13	21	22	11	-1	-3.3	14
Shaun Hill	2010	DET	433	16	12	13	9	4	4	-3.3	7
Jeff Tuel	2013	BUF	61	1	3	2	5	-2	-3	-3.3	1
Marcus Mariota	2019	TEN	185	7	2	5	8	5	-3	-3.3	8
Kevin Hogan	2017	CLE	81	4	5	4	7	-1	-3	-3.3	2
P.J. Walker	2021	CAR	73	1	3	0	3	-2	-3	-3.3	1
Trevor Siemian	2017	DEN	382	12	14	15	17	-2	-2	-3.3	1
Josh Johnson	2009	TAM	136	4	8	7	9	-4	-2	-3.3	-1
Nick Foles	2017	PHI	106	5	2	2	5	3	-3	-3.4	6
T.J. Yates	2017	HOU	110	4	3	5	8	1	-3	-3.4	4
Gus Frerotte	2008	MIN	330	12	15	11	12	-3	-1	-3.4	0
Blaine Gabbert	2013	JAX	98	1	7	4	7	-6	-3	-3.4	-3
Andrew Luck	2012	IND	668	23	18	48	40	5	8	-3.4	8
Cam Newton	2020	NWE	399	8	10	11	10	-2	1	-3.5	1
Kyle Boller	2011	OAK	31	0	3	1	4	-3	-3	-3.5	1
Cam Newton	2021	CAR	136	4	5	4	7	-1	-3	-3.5	3
Sam Bradford	2011	STL	393	6	6	15	12	0	3	-3.6	4
Marcus Mariota	2018	TEN	373	11	8	13	15	3	-2	-3.6	7
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2013	TEN	371	14	12	18	20	2	-2	-3.6	6
Joe Webb	2010	MIN	97	0	3	4	6	-3	-2	-3.6	1
Brad Johnson	2008	DAL	86	2	5	1	4	-3	-3	-3.6	1
Jay Cutler	2009	CHI	590	27	26	26	24	1	2	-3.7	5
Sam Darnold	2019	NYJ	474	19	13	20	23	6	-3	-3.7	10
Kerry Collins	2011	IND	103	2	1	1	3	1	-2	-3.7	5
Kevin Kolb	2011	ARI	283	9	8	18	17	1	1	-3.7	5
Teddy Bridgewater	2021	DEN	457	18	7	13	15	11	-2	-3.7	15
Eli Manning	2006	NYG	547	24	18	21	31	6	-10	-3.8	10
Matt Schaub	2012	HOU	571	22	12	25	19	10	6	-3.8	14
Matthew Stafford	2015	DET	636	32	13	22	26	19	-4	-3.8	23
Byron Leftwich	2006	JAX	192	7	5	2	8	2	-6	-3.8	6
Jalen Hurts	2020	PHI	161	6	4	7	9	2	-2	-3.8	6
C.J. Beathard	2017	SFO	243	4	6	8	11	-2	-3	-3.8	2
Matt Cassel	2011	KAN	291	10	9	15	14	1	1	-3.9	5
Trent Edwards	2010	2TM	112	2	5	2	4	-3	-2	-3.9	1
Nick Foles	2012	PHI	285	6	5	16	15	1	1	-3.9	5
Drew Bledsoe	2006	DAL	185	7	8	7	13	-1	-6	-3.9	3
Ryan Mallett	2015	2TM	250	5	6	8	12	-1	-4	-3.9	3
Brandon Weeden	2015	2TM	150	5	2	4	8	3	-4	-4.0	7
Jimmy Clausen	2015	2TM	132	2	4	0	4	-2	-4	-4.0	2
Tony Romo	2015	DAL	127	5	7	2	6	-2	-4	-4.0	2
Ryan Lindley	2014	2TM	99	2	4	5	9	-2	-4	-4.0	2
Carson Palmer	2017	ARI	288	9	7	15	18	2	-3	-4.0	6
Matt Ryan	2019	ATL	664	26	14	25	28	12	-3	-4.0	16
Jason Campbell	2012	CHI	57	2	2	2	5	0	-3	-4.0	4
Matt Flynn	2013	3TM	224	8	5	5	8	3	-3	-4.0	7
Andy Dalton	2011	CIN	540	20	13	30	25	7	5	-4.0	11
David Garrard	2006	JAX	261	10	9	5	12	1	-7	-4.0	5
Andy Dalton	2020	DAL	357	14	8	11	11	6	0	-4.0	10
Jacoby Brissett	2016	NWE	61	0	0	1	5	0	-4	-4.0	4
Paxton Lynch	2016	DEN	92	2	1	2	6	1	-4	-4.0	5
Bryce Petty	2016	NYJ	146	3	7	5	9	-4	-4	-4.1	0
Cleo Lemon	2007	MIA	334	6	6	11	17	0	-6	-4.1	4
Charlie Whitehurst	2011	SEA	64	1	1	2	5	0	-3	-4.1	4
Scott Tolzien	2017	IND	22	0	2	0	4	-2	-4	-4.1	2
Joe Webb	2011	MIN	66	3	2	3	6	1	-3	-4.1	5
Ben Roethlisberger	2006	PIT	515	18	23	19	29	-5	-10	-4.1	-1
Chad Pennington	2006	NYJ	515	17	16	16	26	1	-10	-4.1	5
Cam Newton	2019	CAR	95	0	1	0	4	-1	-4	-4.1	3
Alex Smith	2010	SFO	367	14	10	13	11	4	2	-4.2	8
Nathan Peterman	2017	BUF	50	2	5	0	4	-3	-4	-4.2	1
Jeff Driskel	2019	DET	116	4	4	3	7	0	-4	-4.2	4
Deshone Kizer	2018	GNB	46	0	2	1	5	-2	-4	-4.2	2
Ryan Tannehill	2021	TEN	578	21	14	20	22	7	-2	-4.2	11
Daunte Culpepper	2006	MIA	155	2	3	3	9	-1	-6	-4.2	3
Charlie Batch	2012	PIT	73	1	4	3	6	-3	-3	-4.2	1
Jake Fromm	2021	NYG	66	1	3	0	4	-2	-4	-4.3	2
Devlin Hodges	2019	PIT	175	5	8	7	11	-3	-4	-4.3	1
John Beck	2007	MIA	117	1	3	1	6	-2	-5	-4.3	2
Andrew Walter	2006	OAK	322	3	13	9	17	-10	-8	-4.3	-6
Nathan Peterman	2018	BUF	88	1	7	1	5	-6	-4	-4.4	-2
A.J. Feeley	2007	PHI	106	5	8	4	9	-3	-5	-4.4	1
Kellen Clemens	2007	NYJ	277	5	10	7	13	-5	-6	-4.4	-1
Dan Orlovsky	2011	IND	207	6	4	11	12	2	-1	-4.5	6
Jason Campbell	2007	WAS	438	12	11	19	26	1	-7	-4.5	5
Drew Stanton	2017	ARI	166	6	5	6	10	1	-4	-4.6	6
Marc Bulger	2007	STL	415	11	15	16	23	-4	-7	-4.6	1
Cody Kessler	2018	JAX	153	2	2	3	7	0	-4	-4.7	5
Brandon Allen	2020	CIN	149	5	4	6	9	1	-3	-4.7	6
Jacoby Brissett	2019	IND	474	18	6	11	15	12	-4	-4.7	17
Carson Palmer	2011	OAK	345	13	16	23	22	-3	1	-4.8	2
Cam Newton	2017	CAR	527	22	16	17	20	6	-3	-4.8	11
Lamar Jackson	2018	BAL	186	6	3	6	10	3	-4	-4.8	8
Matt Ryan	2015	ATL	644	21	16	15	20	5	-5	-4.8	10
Josh McCown	2007	OAK	204	10	11	8	14	-1	-6	-4.8	4
Kyle Boller	2009	STL	193	3	6	3	6	-3	-3	-4.9	2
Derek Anderson	2009	CLE	193	3	10	7	10	-7	-3	-4.9	-2
Geno Smith	2014	NYJ	395	13	13	14	19	0	-5	-4.9	5
Joe Burrow	2020	CIN	436	13	5	15	15	8	0	-4.9	13
Matt Hasselbeck	2010	SEA	473	12	17	23	20	-5	3	-4.9	0
Daunte Culpepper	2008	DET	129	4	6	5	9	-2	-4	-4.9	3
Joe Flacco	2017	BAL	576	18	13	16	19	5	-3	-4.9	10
Mitchell Trubisky	2018	CHI	458	24	12	19	22	12	-3	-5.0	17
Matt Hasselbeck	2011	TEN	537	18	14	28	24	4	4	-5.0	9
Austin Davis	2015	CLE	105	1	3	1	6	-2	-5	-5.0	3
Bruce Gradkowski	2006	TAM	353	9	9	11	20	0	-9	-5.0	5
Andy Dalton	2021	CHI	254	8	9	5	9	-1	-4	-5.0	4
E.J. Manuel	2015	BUF	90	3	3	3	8	0	-5	-5.0	5
Jason Campbell	2008	WAS	544	13	6	9	10	7	-1	-5.0	12
Matt Cassel	2014	MIN	77	3	4	0	5	-1	-5	-5.0	4
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2008	CIN	410	8	9	14	16	-1	-2	-5.0	4
Sam Bradford	2012	STL	586	21	13	25	20	8	5	-5.0	13
Jay Cutler	2016	CHI	154	4	5	6	11	-1	-5	-5.1	4
Josh McCown	2016	CLE	183	6	6	6	11	0	-5	-5.1	5
Matt Cassel	2008	NWE	563	21	11	15	16	10	-1	-5.1	15
Carson Palmer	2012	OAK	591	22	14	26	21	8	5	-5.1	13
Luke Falk	2019	NYJ	89	0	3	0	5	-3	-5	-5.1	2
Trent Green	2007	MIA	148	5	7	5	11	-2	-6	-5.1	3
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2020	MIA	281	13	8	12	14	5	-2	-5.2	10
Christian Ponder	2013	MIN	266	7	9	13	17	-2	-4	-5.2	3
Jake Plummer	2006	DEN	335	11	13	13	22	-2	-9	-5.2	3
Josh Rosen	2019	MIA	125	1	5	4	9	-4	-5	-5.2	1
Tarvaris Jackson	2011	SEA	492	14	13	20	17	1	3	-5.2	6
Cam Newton	2016	CAR	546	19	14	27	32	5	-5	-5.2	10
Jordan Love	2021	GB	65	2	3	1	6	-1	-5	-5.2	4
Derek Anderson	2018	BUF	75	0	4	2	7	-4	-5	-5.3	1
Joe Flacco	2008	BAL	460	14	12	16	18	2	-2	-5.4	7
Colt McCoy	2021	ARI	105	3	1	1	6	2	-5	-5.4	7
Josh Johnson	2018	WAS	100	3	4	1	6	-1	-5	-5.4	4
Todd Collins	2010	CHI	29	0	5	0	5	-5	-5	-5.5	0
T.J. Yates	2011	HOU	149	3	3	4	7	0	-3	-5.5	5
Mike Glennon	2017	CHI	148	4	5	3	8	-1	-5	-5.5	4
Josh McCown	2018	NYJ	117	1	4	1	6	-3	-5	-5.5	3
Taysom Hill	2020	NOR	135	4	2	3	7	2	-4	-5.5	8
Matt Ryan	2009	ATL	470	22	14	16	17	8	-1	-5.5	14
Donovan McNabb	2010	WAS	509	14	15	21	18	-1	3	-5.5	5
Drew Stanton	2009	DET	56	0	6	0	5	-6	-5	-5.5	0
Ben DiNucci	2020	DAL	50	0	0	1	6	0	-5	-5.6	6
JaMarcus Russell	2007	OAK	72	2	4	1	7	-2	-6	-5.6	4
Brodie Croyle	2007	KAN	241	6	6	7	14	0	-7	-5.6	6
Davis Mills	2021	HOU	425	16	10	16	20	6	-4	-5.6	12
Chris Simms	2006	TAM	110	1	7	3	10	-6	-7	-5.7	0
Tyler Huntley	2021	BAL	206	3	4	3	8	-1	-5	-5.8	5
Chris Weinke	2006	CAR	106	2	4	2	9	-2	-7	-5.8	4
Ryan Tannehill	2014	MIA	636	27	12	21	27	15	-6	-5.8	21
Jameis Winston	2015	TAM	562	22	15	27	33	7	-6	-5.8	13
Andy Dalton	2019	CIN	565	16	14	18	23	2	-5	-5.8	8
Brock Osweiler	2018	MIA	195	6	4	4	9	2	-5	-5.8	8
Josh McCown	2014	TAM	363	11	14	16	22	-3	-6	-5.9	3
Nick Foles	2015	STL	351	7	10	10	16	-3	-6	-5.9	3
Peyton Manning	2015	DEN	347	9	17	15	21	-8	-6	-5.9	-2
Nick Foles	2014	PHI	320	13	10	14	20	3	-6	-5.9	9
Josh McCown	2015	CLE	315	12	4	10	16	8	-6	-5.9	14
Philip Rivers	2019	LAC	625	23	20	27	32	3	-5	-5.9	9
Drew Stanton	2014	ARI	251	7	5	10	16	2	-6	-5.9	8
Robert Griffin	2014	WAS	247	4	6	9	15	-2	-6	-5.9	4
Michael Vick	2015	PIT	76	2	1	1	7	1	-6	-6.0	7
Jon Kitna	2008	DET	135	5	5	1	6	0	-5	-6.0	6
Caleb Hanie	2011	CHI	121	3	9	9	13	-6	-4	-6.0	0
Josh McCown	2011	CHI	62	2	4	1	6	-2	-5	-6.0	4
Blaine Gabbert	2016	SFO	171	5	6	2	8	-1	-6	-6.1	5
Will Grier	2019	CAR	58	0	4	0	6	-4	-6	-6.1	2
Quinn Gray	2007	JAX	154	10	5	4	11	5	-7	-6.1	11
Derek Anderson	2008	CLE	297	9	8	6	10	1	-4	-6.2	7
Nick Mullens	2018	SFO	291	13	10	5	10	3	-5	-6.2	9
Jake Luton	2020	JAX	117	2	6	4	9	-4	-5	-6.3	2
Tim Boyle	2021	DET	94	3	6	1	7	-3	-6	-6.4	3
Sam Bradford	2018	ARI	86	2	4	1	7	-2	-6	-6.4	4
Trent Edwards	2007	BUF	281	7	8	6	14	-1	-8	-6.4	5
Trevor Lawrence	2021	JAX	634	12	17	22	26	-5	-4	-6.4	1
Blaine Gabbert	2018	TEN	106	4	4	3	9	0	-6	-6.5	6
Daniel Jones	2021	NYG	383	10	7	7	12	3	-5	-6.5	9
Trent Green	2006	KAN	222	7	9	5	14	-2	-9	-6.5	4
Josh Allen	2018	BUF	348	10	12	17	22	-2	-5	-6.5	4
Mike White	2021	NYJ	136	5	8	3	9	-3	-6	-6.5	4
Taysom Hill	2021	NOR	143	4	5	2	8	-1	-6	-6.5	6
Eli Manning	2013	NYG	590	18	27	29	33	-9	-4	-6.6	-2
Jake Delhomme	2010	CLE	155	2	7	5	9	-5	-4	-6.6	2
Jameis Winston	2017	TAM	475	19	11	23	28	8	-5	-6.6	15
Vince Young	2006	TEN	382	12	13	19	30	-1	-11	-6.6	6
Daunte Culpepper	2009	DET	171	3	6	2	7	-3	-5	-6.6	4
JaMarcus Russell	2009	OAK	279	3	11	8	12	-8	-4	-6.7	-1
Brady Quinn	2012	KAN	218	2	8	5	8	-6	-3	-6.7	1
Steve McNair	2007	BAL	216	2	4	2	10	-2	-8	-6.7	5
Jimmy Garoppolo	2019	SFO	512	27	13	13	19	14	-6	-6.8	21
Josh Rosen	2018	ARI	438	11	14	19	24	-3	-5	-6.9	4
Brian Hoyer	2015	HOU	394	19	7	7	14	12	-7	-6.9	19
Mark Sanchez	2014	PHI	332	14	11	9	16	3	-7	-6.9	10
Sam Darnold	2018	NYJ	444	17	15	16	21	2	-5	-6.9	9
Kurt Warner	2006	ARI	182	6	5	7	16	1	-9	-6.9	8
Dwayne Haskins	2020	WAS	261	5	7	6	10	-2	-4	-6.9	5
Jake Locker	2014	TEN	160	5	7	3	10	-2	-7	-6.9	5
Vinny Testaverde	2007	CAR	181	5	6	6	14	-1	-8	-7.0	6
Carson Palmer	2008	CIN	140	3	4	0	6	-1	-6	-7.0	6
Eli Manning	2017	NYG	602	19	13	19	24	6	-5	-7.0	13
Michael Vick	2006	ATL	433	20	13	15	27	7	-12	-7.1	14
Matt Barkley	2016	CHI	222	8	14	12	19	-6	-7	-7.1	1
Ryan Lindley	2012	ARI	183	0	7	6	10	-7	-4	-7.1	0
Robert Griffin	2013	WAS	494	16	12	11	16	4	-5	-7.2	11
Trevor Siemian	2016	DEN	517	18	10	18	25	8	-7	-7.2	15
Keith Null	2009	STL	132	3	9	0	6	-6	-6	-7.3	1
Sage Rosenfels	2008	HOU	183	6	10	5	11	-4	-6	-7.3	3
Brett Favre	2010	MIN	380	11	19	15	16	-8	-1	-7.4	-1
Tyler Palko	2011	KAN	145	2	7	4	9	-5	-5	-7.4	2
John Beck	2011	WAS	148	2	4	3	8	-2	-5	-7.5	5
Steve McNair	2006	BAL	482	16	12	13	26	4	-13	-7.5	11
Brock Osweiler	2017	DEN	183	5	5	3	10	0	-7	-7.6	8
Case Keenum	2018	DEN	620	18	15	20	25	3	-5	-7.7	11
Sam Darnold	2021	CAR	441	9	13	15	21	-4	-6	-7.7	4
Chad Henne	2010	MIA	520	15	19	20	19	-4	1	-7.7	4
Eli Manning	2015	NYG	645	35	14	22	30	21	-8	-7.8	29
Austin Davis	2014	STL	313	12	9	6	14	3	-8	-7.9	11
Mark Sanchez	2010	NYJ	534	17	13	25	24	4	1	-8.0	12
Jared Goff	2021	DET	529	19	8	12	18	11	-6	-8.0	19
Charlie Frye	2006	CLE	436	10	17	9	22	-7	-13	-8.0	1
Brett Hundley	2017	GNB	345	9	12	8	15	-3	-7	-8.2	5
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2016	NYJ	422	12	17	14	22	-5	-8	-8.2	3
Jameis Winston	2016	TAM	602	28	18	18	26	10	-8	-8.2	18
Carson Palmer	2010	CIN	612	26	20	29	27	6	2	-8.3	14
Rex Grossman	2006	CHI	501	23	20	21	35	3	-14	-8.3	11
Curtis Painter	2011	IND	259	6	9	12	16	-3	-4	-8.3	5
Terrelle Pryor	2013	OAK	303	7	11	10	17	-4	-7	-8.3	4
Mason Rudolph	2019	PIT	298	13	9	6	14	4	-8	-8.4	12
Sam Bradford	2010	STL	624	18	15	24	22	3	2	-8.5	11
Kyle Orton	2009	DEN	570	21	12	10	13	9	-3	-8.5	17
Drew Brees	2020	NOR	403	24	6	15	19	18	-4	-8.5	27
Blaine Gabbert	2017	ARI	194	6	6	7	15	0	-8	-8.7	9
Matt Schaub	2013	HOU	379	10	14	14	21	-4	-7	-8.7	5
Eli Manning	2018	NYG	623	21	11	25	31	10	-6	-8.7	19
Ryan Tannehill	2020	TEN	505	33	7	19	22	26	-3	-8.7	35
John Skelton	2012	ARI	216	2	9	5	10	-7	-5	-8.7	2
Derek Carr	2017	OAK	535	22	13	17	24	9	-7	-8.8	18
Teddy Bridgewater	2020	CAR	523	15	11	17	20	4	-3	-8.9	13
Derek Anderson	2010	ARI	352	7	10	13	16	-3	-3	-8.9	6
Matt Hasselbeck	2009	SEA	520	17	17	14	18	0	-4	-9.0	9
Matt Cassel	2012	KAN	296	6	12	7	11	-6	-4	-9.1	3
Jared Goff	2016	LAR	231	5	7	3	12	-2	-9	-9.1	7
Colin Kaepernick	2016	SFO	367	16	4	6	15	12	-9	-9.2	21
Carson Palmer	2016	ARI	637	26	14	21	30	12	-9	-9.3	21
Blake Bortles	2016	JAX	659	23	16	17	26	7	-9	-9.3	16
Kyle Orton	2011	2TM	262	9	9	10	15	0	-5	-9.4	9
Kevin Kolb	2010	PHI	204	7	7	8	14	0	-6	-9.4	9
Jason Campbell	2013	CLE	333	11	8	5	13	3	-8	-9.5	12
Josh McCown	2017	NYJ	436	18	9	15	23	9	-8	-9.5	18
Carson Wentz	2020	PHI	487	16	15	20	24	1	-4	-9.5	10
Tua Tagovailoa	2020	MIA	310	11	5	7	13	6	-6	-9.5	15
J.P. Losman	2006	BUF	476	19	14	19	34	5	-15	-9.6	15
Derek Anderson	2006	CLE	125	5	8	1	12	-3	-11	-9.6	7
Matt Moore	2010	CAR	156	5	10	5	12	-5	-7	-9.6	5
Zach Wilson	2021	NYJ	427	9	11	10	18	-2	-8	-9.6	8
Vince Young	2007	TEN	407	9	17	15	27	-8	-12	-9.6	2
Carson Palmer	2013	ARI	613	24	22	33	40	2	-7	-9.7	12
Mark Sanchez	2009	NYJ	390	12	20	17	23	-8	-6	-9.8	2
J.P. Losman	2008	BUF	119	2	5	1	10	-3	-9	-9.9	7
Jameis Winston	2019	TAM	673	33	30	31	40	3	-9	-10.0	13
Rex Grossman	2011	WAS	483	16	20	32	34	-4	-2	-10.1	6
Jay Cutler	2010	CHI	484	23	16	29	31	7	-2	-10.1	17
Ryan Finley	2019	CIN	98	2	2	0	10	0	-10	-10.1	10
Tarvaris Jackson	2007	MIN	313	9	12	6	18	-3	-12	-10.2	7
Matt Barkley	2013	PHI	52	0	4	0	10	-4	-10	-10.2	6
Carson Wentz	2016	PHI	640	16	14	17	27	2	-10	-10.3	12
Michael Vick	2012	PHI	379	12	10	14	18	2	-4	-10.5	12
Max Hall	2010	ARI	92	1	6	1	10	-5	-9	-10.5	6
Josh Allen	2019	BUF	499	20	9	13	23	11	-10	-10.7	22
Jameis Winston	2018	TAM	405	19	14	13	22	5	-9	-10.7	16
Blake Bortles	2015	JAX	657	35	18	27	38	17	-11	-10.8	28
Eli Manning	2014	NYG	629	30	14	17	28	16	-11	-10.8	27
Christian Ponder	2012	MIN	515	18	12	23	25	6	-2	-10.8	17
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2015	NYJ	581	31	15	21	32	16	-11	-10.8	27
Zach Mettenberger	2015	TEN	179	4	7	0	11	-3	-11	-10.9	8
Michael Vick	2014	NYJ	140	3	2	2	13	1	-11	-11.0	12
Mike Glennon	2013	TAM	456	19	9	18	27	10	-9	-11.0	21
Taylor Heinicke	2021	WAS	532	20	15	18	27	5	-9	-11.0	16
Joe Flacco	2016	BAL	705	20	15	13	24	5	-11	-11.3	16
Christian Ponder	2011	MIN	321	13	13	15	21	0	-6	-11.4	11
Jon Kitna	2007	DET	612	18	20	17	32	-2	-15	-11.5	9
Jared Goff	2020	LAR	575	20	13	13	18	7	-5	-11.5	18
Mark Sanchez	2011	NYJ	582	26	18	30	32	8	-2	-11.7	20
Daniel Jones	2019	NYG	497	24	12	20	31	12	-11	-11.7	24
Matthew Stafford	2009	DET	401	13	20	13	21	-7	-8	-11.9	5
Marcus Mariota	2015	TEN	408	19	10	9	21	9	-12	-11.9	21
Johnny Manziel	2015	CLE	242	7	5	4	16	2	-12	-11.9	14
Geno Smith	2013	NYJ	486	12	21	23	33	-9	-10	-12.1	3
Eli Manning	2016	NYG	619	26	16	21	33	10	-12	-12.3	22
E.J. Manuel	2013	BUF	334	11	9	8	19	2	-11	-12.5	14
Sam Darnold	2020	NYJ	399	9	11	9	17	-2	-8	-12.5	10
DeShone Kizer	2017	CLE	514	11	22	20	31	-11	-11	-12.7	2
Derek Carr	2014	OAK	623	21	12	13	26	9	-13	-12.8	22
Jay Cutler	2014	CHI	599	28	18	16	29	10	-13	-12.8	23
Blake Bortles	2014	JAX	530	11	17	12	25	-6	-13	-12.8	7
Andrew Luck	2015	IND	308	15	12	12	25	3	-13	-12.9	16
Brock Osweiler	2016	HOU	537	15	16	15	28	-1	-13	-13.2	12
Mark Sanchez	2012	NYJ	487	13	18	25	30	-5	-5	-13.3	8
Ben Roethlisberger	2021	PIT	643	22	10	21	32	12	-11	-13.5	25
Mitchell Trubisky	2020	CHI	315	16	8	10	20	8	-10	-13.5	22
Tua Tagovailoa	2021	MIA	408	16	10	10	22	6	-12	-13.6	20
Josh Freeman	2011	TAM	580	16	22	22	26	-6	-4	-13.7	8
David Carr	2006	HOU	483	11	12	4	24	-1	-20	-14.5	13
Jay Cutler	2017	MIA	449	19	14	7	20	5	-13	-14.5	20
Kyle Allen	2019	CAR	535	17	16	20	34	1	-14	-14.8	16
Jimmy Garoppolo	2021	SFO	470	20	12	10	23	8	-13	-14.8	23
Nick Mullens	2020	SFO	345	12	12	10	21	0	-11	-14.9	15
John Skelton	2011	ARI	298	11	14	12	22	-3	-10	-15.0	12
Cam Newton	2018	CAR	500	24	13	13	26	11	-13	-15.1	26
Blaine Gabbert	2011	JAX	453	12	11	13	21	1	-8	-15.6	17
Colt McCoy	2011	CLE	495	14	11	20	28	3	-8	-16.3	19
Ryan Tannehill	2018	MIA	309	17	9	8	23	8	-15	-16.3	24
Chad Henne	2013	JAX	541	13	14	10	24	-1	-14	-16.4	15
Mike Glennon	2021	NYG	176	4	10	2	18	-6	-16	-16.7	11
Brett Favre	2008	NYJ	552	22	22	17	30	0	-13	-17.0	17
Ryan Fitzpatrick	2012	BUF	535	24	16	19	29	8	-10	-19.2	27
Brandon Weeden	2012	CLE	545	14	17	17	38	-3	-21	-30.3	27

The very top of the board is populated by the same seasons we think of as being great by traditional stats (except Wilson 2019), but it gets much less predictable after that. I’ll spend the rest of this post highlighting seasons that caught my eye for whatever reason.

Tom Brady’s 2006 season scores higher in adjusted BTT-TWP difference than his 2017 or 2010 MVP seasons! Brady was unlucky to throw so few TD passes in 2006 and it was by far the hardest year for PFF stats in general. Meanwhile his 2010 featured exceptionally good fortune, as most extremely low INT% seasons do, and it occurred during the period where even mediocre quarterbacks were racking up BTT like crazy.

The reversal of fortune seen by Eli Manning from mid to late career was pretty insane. From 2009-12 the younger Manning averaged +11 in TD-INT difference. That average jumped to +16 from 2014-16, making it look like, at least superficially, Eli was still in his prime. But the PFF stats tell a completely different tale. From 2009-12 he averaged +20 in BTT-TWP but that cratered to a -10 average from 2014-16. He was extremely unlucky in his best years and extremely lucky in his decline years; Manning’s adjusted luck was -36 from 2009-12 and +77 from 2014-16! This is perhaps the most pointed example of how grossly TD/INT stats can warp our perceptions of a player.

Speaking of fortune reversals, Matt Ryan experienced whiplash from 2017 to 2018. In the former year he appeared to regress steeply from his MVP season with a 20/12 boxscore split. However, that was dragged down by a preposterous number of deflected interceptions, giving Ryan a healthy 21/6 PFF split in 2017. The Falcons QB looked to have a renaissance in 2018 with 35 TD and 7 INT but his PFF splits were merely 24/21. His adjusted luck swung from -5 one season to +28 the next which completely obscured the true trajectory of his performance.

A pair of unwanted quarterbacks this offseason have had their career narratives distorted by a chasm in plain old luck. Jimmy Garoppolo, while taking some heat for being a game manager or system QB, has gotten his fair share of praise for efficient play and leading his 49ers to a couple of deep playoff runs. Well, his career PFF splits are 39 BTT and 58 TWP. On the other hand, Baker Mayfield has become one of the most criticized players in the league while posting 120 BTT and 79 TWP. The difference? Jimmy G is
+57 in career luck while Baker is just +6. In 2012, Matthew Stafford totaled just 20 TD and 17 INT on a record 756 dropbacks. At first glance that would appear to be a classic game manager type season, but PFF stats reveal that it was exactly the opposite. Stafford compiled 48 BTT and 32 TWP while famously seeing Calvin Johnson get tackled on the one yard line six different times; that’s how you throw so few TD passes while slinging it all over the field. Stafford had 43 more notable plays according to BTT/TWP
than TD/INT, the largest discrepancy in the sample.

David Carr led the league in completion percentage in 2006 and placed 15th in passer rating. Pundits lamented that he could be a great QB if only his offensive line weren’t so porous. But those lying boxscore stats obscured just how pathetic Carr played in 2006. He had only 4 BTT and 24 TWP! Even after adjusting for the difficult passing environment that season, Carr was an absolute disaster and
mercifully never got to be a team’s primary starter again.

In 2013, Nick Foles memorably tossed 27 TD and only 2 INT. Surprise surprise, PFF numbers show that he wasn’t nearly that good, tallying 20 BTT and 7 TWP for an adjusted difference of only +11.5. Other than his out of nowhere run in the 2017 playoffs, Foles never came close to replicating his 2013 season.

Speaking of unsustainably low INT rates, Damon Huard threw 11 TD and a single INT in 2006. According to PFF he had 19 BTT and 12 TWP, meaning that he got away with over 90% of his mistakes that season! Predictably, Huard never came close to matching his fluky 2006 campaign.

Legendary journeyman Josh McCown managed to have two ridiculous TD/INT seasons. In 2013 he tallied 13/1 and in 2015 he posted 12/4 splits. Meanwhile, his PFF splits for those seasons were 12/5 (not bad) and 10/16 (LOL) respectively.

Remember when Jeff Garcia stepped in to rescue the Eagles’ 2006 season after Donovan McNabb got hurt? He threw 10 TD and 2 INT and received ample praise for his efforts as quality backup. His PFF stats show that sometimes it’s better to be lucky than good, as Garcia tallied 8 BTT and 13 TWP. The previous four examples betray a truth about quarterback stats: Don’t trust extremely low INT rates! If we look back at the olden days before charting data existed, it’s highly likely that seasons such as Steve Deberg’s 1990 or Milt Plum’s 1960 were not nearly as good as their absence of interceptions made them appear. In fact, Aaron Rodgers’ 2011 and Tom Brady’s 2016 are the only two seasons of extreme TD/INT that are actually backed up by BTT/TWP to the same degree. ^[1]Thank you once again to Pro Football Focus for letting me use their data publicly.

I’ll end this by noting the AP1 QB each year back to 2006 as well as their BTT/TWP, adjusted difference,
and season rank:

2021 – Aaron Rodgers; 36/12, +22, 3rd
2020 – Aaron Rodgers; 43/12, +25, 2nd
2019 – Lamar Jackson; 20/9, +10, 6th
2018 – Patrick Mahomes; 48/22, +23, 1st
2017 – Tom Brady; 40/15, +23, 1st
2016 – Matt Ryan; 29/16, +13, 8th
2015 – Cam Newton; 34/16, +16, 4th
2014 – Aaron Rodgers; 36/15, +21, 1st
2013 – Peyton Manning; 45/14, +28, 1st
2012 – Peyton Manning; 49/19, +20, 2nd
2011 – Aaron Rodgers; 50/6, +35, 1st
2010 – Tom Brady; 22/7, +6, 9th
2009 – Peyton Manning; 33/14, +13, 2nd
2008 – Peyton Manning; 30/10, +16, 2nd
2007 – Tom Brady; 38/9, +33, 1st
2006 – Drew Brees; 31/18, +20, 3rd

References[+]

References
↑1	Thank you once again to Pro Football Focus for letting me use their data publicly.

Tagged as: Adam Steele, Guest Posts, luck

{ 1 comment }