≡ Menu

Donald, Suh, and Great DTs Playing Together

The Rams defensive line is kind of nuts

It’s officially: as hinted at over the weekend, former Dolphin and Lions Ndamukong Suh has joined the Los Angeles Rams and will be playing alongside Aaron Donald.  Along with Michael Brockers, who has alternated between nose tackle and defensive end in the Rams 3-4 defense (after playing as a DT in the team’s 4-3 defense), the Rams now have the league’s most terrifying three-person defensive line.

On paper this is a tremendous signing, but there is some question over where Suh will line up and whether playing in a 3-4 defense alongside Donald really maximizes his value.  Which made me wonder: how often has a team had two former (or future) All-Pro defensive tackles? (Note: (the Eagles now have Haloti Ngata and Fletcher Cox, but Cox has “only” been a second-team All-Pro by the AP, although he was a first-team All-Pro in 2017 by the Sporting News and the Pro Football Writers Association).

It turns out, more often than you might think, although often it’s in a reserve role.  In fact, eight teams had three such players!

The 1996 Raiders started Russell Maryland and Chester McGlockton (1995 All-Pro) at defensive tackle, and had a 32-year-old Jerry Ball (1991 AP) and 22-year-old La’Roi Glover (2000 AP) on the bench! The 1992 Seahawks had Cortez Kennedy (1992-1994 AP) and Joe Nash (1984 AP) as starters on the inside, and an end-of-career Keith Millard (1988-1989 AP) on the bench for two games.

The other six: the 1984 49ers (Gary Johnson, Michael Carter, Louie Kelcher), 1981 Bears (Steve McMichael, Alan Page, Dan Hampton), 1974 Chiefs (Curley Culp, Buck Buchanan, Tom Keating), 1968 Chiefs (Buck Buchanan, Ernie Ladd, Curley Culp), and the 1964 and 1965 Bills (Tom Sestak, Jim Dunaway, Tom Keating).

The last time that a team had two former All-Pros on the same roster? Well, it happened twice in 2011 with Albert Haynesworth.  He began the season in New England, where he lined up next to Vince Wilfork. He was cut in mid-season and joins the Bucs, where he lined up next to Gerald McCoy. At that point in time, McCoy was not yet an All-Pro, but he would be two years later.

If we limit this to teams that had two players who had been or would be first-team Associated Press All-Pros at DT who also started at least eight games in that season, then this hasn’t happened in a decade. In 2008, Haloti Ngata and Trevor Pryce were on the Ravens, while Vince Wilfork and Richard Seymour were on the Patriots.

Among the most terrifying combinations in terms of both players actually being productive at the same time? Dan Hampton and Steve McMichael on the 1985-1986 Bears, Jerome Brown and Reggie White on the 1990 and 1991 Eagles, Louie Kelcher and Gary Johnson on the 1980 Chargers.

The table below lists all combinations where two former or future first-team All-Pro DTs according to the Associated Press were teammates and each started at least eight games. This includes a very similar Rams duo 50 years ago:

YearTeamPlayeravStarts
2008ravHaloti Ngata1616
2008ravTrevor Pryce816
2008nweVince Wilfork916
2008nweRichard Seymour815
2007nweVince Wilfork1316
2007nweRichard Seymour48
2006ravTrevor Pryce1016
2006ravHaloti Ngata816
2006nweRichard Seymour1515
2006nweVince Wilfork813
2005raiTed Washington616
2005raiWarren Sapp510
2005nweRichard Seymour1212
2005nweVince Wilfork716
2004raiWarren Sapp616
2004raiTed Washington516
2003nweRichard Seymour1614
2003nweTed Washington610
2002sfoBryant Young816
2002sfoDana Stubblefield615
2002denTrevor Pryce1016
2002denChester McGlockton715
2001sfoBryant Young1316
2001sfoDana Stubblefield716
2001denTrevor Pryce1116
2001denChester McGlockton716
1999minJohn Randle916
1999minJerry Ball510
1998minJohn Randle1516
1998minJerry Ball716
1997sfoDana Stubblefield1716
1997sfoBryant Young612
1997raiChester McGlockton916
1997raiDarrell Russell410
1996sfoBryant Young1916
1996sfoDana Stubblefield815
1995sfoDana Stubblefield1216
1995sfoBryant Young612
1995seaCortez Kennedy1116
1995seaJoe Nash511
1995raiChester McGlockton1516
1995raiJerry Ball714
1994sfoDana Stubblefield1014
1994sfoBryant Young816
1994seaCortez Kennedy1616
1994seaJoe Nash715
1994raiChester McGlockton1316
1994raiJerry Ball714
1994gnbReggie White1415
1994gnbSteve McMichael714
1993sfoDana Stubblefield714
1993sfoTed Washington612
1993seaCortez Kennedy1616
1993seaJoe Nash716
1992seaCortez Kennedy1916
1992seaJoe Nash816
1991phiReggie White1816
1991phiJerome Brown1511
1990phiJerome Brown1615
1990phiReggie White1616
1989phiReggie White1816
1989phiJerome Brown916
1988phiReggie White1816
1988phiJerome Brown715
1988chiDan Hampton1616
1988chiSteve McMichael1016
1987phiReggie White1512
1987phiJerome Brown58
1987chiSteve McMichael1412
1987chiDan Hampton48
1986chiDan Hampton1816
1986chiSteve McMichael1816
1985chiSteve McMichael1716
1985chiDan Hampton1415
1984chiDan Hampton1915
1984chiSteve McMichael916
1983chiSteve McMichael710
1983chiDan Hampton611
1981sdgGary Johnson1116
1981sdgLouie Kelcher814
1981chiAlan Page916
1981chiDan Hampton816
1980sdgGary Johnson1416
1980sdgLouie Kelcher1114
1980chiDan Hampton1116
1980chiAlan Page1016
1979chiDan Hampton716
1979chiAlan Page716
1978sdgLouie Kelcher1215
1978sdgGary Johnson714
1977sdgLouie Kelcher1012
1977sdgGary Johnson714
1976sdgGary Johnson614
1976sdgLouie Kelcher614
1976ramLarry Brooks1014
1976ramMerlin Olsen814
1975sdgLouie Kelcher513
1975sdgGary Johnson38
1975ramMerlin Olsen1214
1975ramLarry Brooks68
1974ramMerlin Olsen1014
1974ramLarry Brooks713
1974kanBuck Buchanan59
1974kanTom Keating512
1973ramMerlin Olsen1214
1973ramLarry Brooks814
1973kanBuck Buchanan914
1973kanCurley Culp912
1972kanCurley Culp814
1972kanBuck Buchanan714
1971kanBuck Buchanan1014
1971kanCurley Culp914
1970kanBuck Buchanan814
1970kanCurley Culp714
1968ramMerlin Olsen1414
1968ramRoger Brown914
{ 0 comments }