≡ Menu

Marginal Air Yards: 2019 Update by Adam Steele

Adam Steele is back for another guest post. You can view all of Adam’s posts here. As always, we thank him for contributing.


It’s been a few years since I updated my Marginal Air Yards metric, so that’s what today’s post will do. I decided to make this a purely style based statistic rather than trying to combine style with efficiency. As such, here is the updated formula:

mAir = (completed air yards / completions – league average) * completions

Said simply, Marginal Air Yards represents the total depth of a passer’s completions compared to league average. A quarterback who averages 7.0 AirY/C on 300 completions in a league that averages 6.5 AirY/C will be credited with +150 mAir (i.e., 0.5 x 150).

Historical air yardage data goes back to 1992, but I’ve chosen to estimate the numbers for years prior by splitting gross passing yards into 60% air yards and 40% YAC. This should sound like a big assumption — because it absolutely is — but it’s one I’m comfortable making for two reasons. One, since I’m only trying to measure playing style and not performance, if the numbers are not perfectly accurate but are directionally correct, that’s still useful information. And two, throughout most of NFL history, offenses generally moved the ball by throwing deep, and any YAC gained was considered a bonus. Therefore, I’m confident that the variance in YAC between quarterbacks was smaller in past eras than it is today.

Here is the Marginal Air Yards data for 2018:

QuarterbackYearTeamCompAirYrdAir/CmpMrgAir
Jameis Winston2018TAM24420598.44608
Ryan Fitzpatrick2018TAM16414728.98497
Russell Wilson2018SEA28020047.16339
Jared Goff2018LAR36425026.87338
Deshaun Watson2018HOU34523846.91333
Matt Ryan2018ATL42227826.59273
Baker Mayfield2018CLE31020326.55189
Sam Darnold2018NYJ23915956.67174
Patrick Mahomes2018KAN38324406.37163
Josh Allen2018BUF16911196.62114
Philip Rivers2018LAC34721746.27111
Lamar Jackson2018BAL996926.99103
Mitchell Trubisky2018CHI28918036.2485
Aaron Rodgers2018GNB37222956.1783
Matt Barkley2018BUF1515310.2064
Joe Flacco2018BAL23214416.2162
Andy Dalton2018CIN22613976.1853
Kyle Allen2018CAR201728.6053
Derek Anderson2018BUF422886.8638
Tyrod Taylor2018CLE422846.7634
Jimmy Garoppolo2018SFO533476.5532
Tom Brady2018NWE37522616.0331
Chase Daniel2018CHI533446.4929
Colt McCoy2018WAS342196.4417
DeShone Kizer2018GNB201276.358
Nick Mullens2018SFO17610545.998
Andrew Luck2018IND43025645.967
Chad Henne2018KAN2147.002
A.J. McCarron2018OAK177.001
Mike Glennon2018ARI15895.930
Garrett Gilbert2018CAR2105.00-2
Josh Rosen2018ARI21712885.94-2
Nate Sudfeld2018PHI1-1-1.00-7
Brian Hoyer2018NWE1-3-3.00-9
Geno Smith2018LAC1-3-3.00-9
Jacoby Brissett2018IND210.50-11
Matt Cassel2018DET7304.29-12
Joshua Dobbs2018PIT6244.00-12
Carson Wentz2018PHI27916445.89-15
Sean Mannion2018LAR2-4-2.00-16
Robert Griffin2018BAL2-5-2.50-17
Matt Schaub2018ATL5122.40-18
Teddy Bridgewater2018NOR14644.57-19
Drew Brees2018NOR36421425.88-22
Blaine Gabbert2018TEN613265.34-37
Taylor Heinicke2018CAR351714.89-37
Josh Johnson2018WAS522715.21-38
Alex Smith2018WAS20511795.75-40
Mark Sanchez2018WAS19492.58-64
C.J. Beathard2018SFO1025225.12-84
Sam Bradford2018ARI502064.12-91
Marcus Mariota2018TEN22812545.50-102
Eli Manning2018NYG38021425.64-117
Brock Osweiler2018MIA1135454.82-127
Josh McCown2018NYJ602293.82-128
Case Keenum2018DEN36520415.59-129
Dak Prescott2018DAL35619855.58-132
Ryan Tannehill2018MIA1769035.13-143
Cody Kessler2018JAX853604.24-145
Nathan Peterman2018BUF441132.57-149
Nick Foles2018PHI1416884.88-150
Jeff Driskel2018CIN1054544.32-170
Derek Carr2018OAK38120465.37-219
Kirk Cousins2018MIN42522925.39-235
Cam Newton2018CAR32016575.18-246
Blake Bortles2018JAX24311914.90-254
Ben Roethlisberger2018PIT45222985.08-390
Matthew Stafford2018DET36717394.74-443

How ‘bout them Buccaneers? The duo of Jameis Winston and Ryan Fitzpatrick tallied 1,105 mAir, the highest single season figure for any team in history. Tampa Bay turned the ball over a ton and had no chance of making the playoffs, but they sure were fun to watch! Winston and Fitzpatrick zigged when the rest of the NFL zagged, as their bombs away style existed in sharp contrast to a league that threw the second shortest average completion in NFL history (only 2014 had shallower completions).

At the opposite end of the spectrum, Matthew Stafford once again wasted his rocket arm by throwing the shortest completions of any full time starter in the league. Despite his reputation as a gunslinger, Stafford has morphed into a checkdown machine in recent years.

Which quarterback posted the best Marginal Air Yards season in history? Here are the top 200 historical seasons, with all seasons prior to 1992 being very rough estimates:

QuarterbackYearTeamCompAirYrdAir/CmpLgAvgMrgAir
Carson Palmer2015ARI34228978.476.17787
Daunte Culpepper2000MIN29726218.826.56674
Jeff Hostetler1993RAI23622509.536.79649
Steve McNair2003TEN25021988.796.35610
Jameis Winston2018TAM24420598.445.95608
Peyton Manning2006IND36228897.986.31603
Jameis Winston2015TAM31225288.106.17603
Steve McNair2001TEN26423038.726.49591
Mark Brunell1996JAX35328858.176.54576
Jameis Winston2016TAM34527037.836.23552
Cam Newton2015CAR29623708.016.17544
Jameis Winston2017TAM28222257.896.05520
Drew Bledsoe1998NWE26323799.057.09514
Chris Chandler1998ATL19018589.787.09511
Jeff George1999MIN19117889.366.70508
Andrew Luck2012IND33926447.806.30508
Ben Roethlisberger2015PIT31924697.746.17501
Ryan Fitzpatrick2018TAM16414728.985.95497
Jake Delhomme2008CAR24620198.216.19496
Peyton Manning2004IND33628328.436.95496
Peyton Manning2000IND35728357.946.56495
Lynn Dickey1983GNB2892674.89.267.55494
Cam Newton2016CAR27021598.006.23476
Brian Hoyer2014CLE24218987.845.91468
Eli Manning2012NYG32124877.756.30464
Tony Romo2006DAL22018508.416.31461
Blake Bortles2015JAX35526507.466.17460
Carson Palmer2006CIN32425037.736.31457
Eli Manning2011NYG35927587.686.42455
Trent Green2000STL14514009.666.56449
Jon Kitna1999SEA27022578.366.70448
Scott Mitchell1995DET34627107.836.56441
Boomer Esiason1988CIN2232143.29.617.63441
Carson Wentz2017PHI26520387.696.05436
Randall Cunningham1998MIN25922598.727.09423
Jake Delhomme2004CAR31025778.316.95422
Kerry Collins2005OAK30223997.946.55420
Derek Anderson2007CLE29822957.706.31416
Gus Frerotte1995WAS19917208.646.56415
Joe Namath1972NYJ1621689.610.437.87414
Steve Grogan1979NWE2061971.69.577.59408
Kirk Cousins2016WAS40629397.246.23408
George Blanda1961HOU187199810.688.52405
Tyrod Taylor2015BUF24218987.846.17405
Andrew Luck2016IND34625567.396.23399
Jim Kelly1992BUF26923228.637.15398
Matt Ryan2008ATL26520367.686.19395
Norm Van Brocklin1954RAM1391582.211.388.55394
Elvis Grbac2000KAN32625257.756.56388
John Elway1998DEN21018758.937.09386
Johnny Unitas1964BAL1581694.410.728.32381
Tony Romo2007DAL33524927.446.31380
Jay Schroeder1986WAS2762465.48.937.56380
Chris Chandler1999ATL17415458.886.70379
Peyton Manning2014DEN39527116.865.91377
Terry Bradshaw1980PIT2182003.49.197.46376
Craig Erickson1994TAM22518578.256.59375
Scott Mitchell1996DET25320308.026.54375
Marcus Mariota2016TEN27620957.596.23374
Peyton Manning2007IND33724977.416.31372
Jeff George1997OAK29023698.176.92362
Tom Brady2004NWE28823638.206.95361
Eli Manning2013NYG31722717.166.03359
Josh Freeman2012TAM30622867.476.30358
Craig Erickson1993TAM23319368.316.79355
Ben Roethlisberger2009PIT33723767.056.01349
Jake Plummer1997ARI15714349.136.92348
Mark Rypien1991WAS2492138.48.597.20346
Josh McCown2014TAM18414337.795.91346
Jay Schroeder1990RAI1821709.49.397.50345
Jack Kemp1964BUF119137111.528.63344
Tony Banks1996STL19215978.326.54341
Billy Joe Tolliver1999NOR13912719.146.70340
Russell Wilson2018SEA28020047.165.95339
Jared Goff2018LAR36425026.875.95338
Joe Ferguson1979BUF2382143.29.017.59337
Eric Hipple1981DET1401414.810.117.71335
Kurt Warner2007ARI28121077.506.31335
Ben Roethlisberger2007PIT26419997.576.31334
Colin Kaepernick2013SFO24317997.406.03334
Michael Vick2002ATL23118007.796.35333
Deshaun Watson2018HOU34523846.915.95333
Mark Brunell2001JAX28922057.636.49331
Eli Manning2009NYG31722367.056.01330
Matt Hasselbeck2005SEA29422567.676.55329
Kurt Warner2001STL37527607.366.49328
Tommy Maddox2002PIT23418137.756.35327
Dan Marino1992MIA33026878.147.15326
Ed Brown1963PIT1681789.210.658.72324
Steve Grogan1978NWE1811694.49.367.58323
Jeff Hostetler1994RAI26320527.806.59320
Mark Brunell2000JAX31123587.586.56319
Steve Beuerlein1993PHO25820688.026.79317
Carson Palmer2016ARI36425867.106.23317
Scott Mitchell1994DET11910999.246.59315
Brian Hoyer2015HOU22416977.586.17315
Carson Palmer2011OAK19915907.996.42313
Eli Manning2005NYG29422407.626.55313
Boomer Esiason1986CIN2732375.48.707.56312
Ben Roethlisberger2010PIT24017717.386.09310
Peyton Manning2005IND30523097.576.55310
Dan Marino1984MIA3623050.48.437.57310
Mark Sanchez2012NYJ24618577.556.30307
Russell Wilson2017SEA33923546.946.05304
Matt Hasselbeck2006SEA21016297.766.31303
Doug Williams1981TAM2382137.88.987.71303
Kurt Warner2000STL23518437.846.56302
Tom Brady2017NWE38526286.836.05300
Philip Rivers2009SDG31722066.966.01300
Norm Snead1963WAS1751825.810.438.72299
Ben Roethlisberger2004PIT19616628.486.95299
Ben Roethlisberger2005PIT16814008.336.55299
Richard Todd1979NYJ17115969.337.59298
Frank Reich1996NYJ17514428.246.54297
Browning Nagle1992NYJ19216698.697.15295
Kyle Orton2010DEN29320777.096.09294
Eli Manning2010NYG33923576.956.09294
Stan Humphries1995SDG28221407.596.56291
Craig Morton1970DAL1021091.410.707.87289
Bert Jones1976BAL2071862.49.007.60289
Craig Morton1969DAL1621571.49.707.93287
Terry Bradshaw1977PIT1621513.89.347.59285
Jim Kelly1996BUF22217367.826.54284
Warren Moon1987HOU1841683.69.157.61283
Michael Vick2006ATL20415717.706.31283
Derek Anderson2010ARI16913107.756.09281
Aaron Rodgers2011GNB34324807.236.42279
John Hadl1968SDG2082083.810.028.68279
Chris Miller1991ATL2201861.88.467.20278
Mike Glennon2014TAM1179698.285.91278
Tom Brady2007NWE39827877.006.31278
Tom Flores1963OAK1131260.611.168.71276
Aaron Rodgers2008GNB34123867.006.19275
Matt Ryan2018ATL42227826.595.95273
Mark Brunell1999JAX25920057.746.70269
Terry Bradshaw1979PIT2592234.48.637.59269
Jay Cutler2008DEN38426456.896.19268
Greg Landry1971DET1361342.29.877.90267
Don Meredith1966DAL17716839.518.01266
Earl Morrall1968BAL1821745.49.598.13266
Joe Namath1968NYJ1871888.210.108.68265
Matt Robinson1978NYJ1241201.29.697.58262
Bobby Layne19582TM145150610.398.58262
Doug Flutie2000BUF13211278.546.56262
Phil Simms1984NYG2862426.48.487.57261
Steve McNair2002TEN30121727.226.35260
Drew Stanton2014ARI13210407.885.91260
Jon Kitna2007DET35524967.036.31258
Geno Smith2013NYJ24717477.076.03258
Marcus Mariota2017TEN28119566.966.05257
Cam Newton2012CAR28020217.226.30256
Tim Tebow2011DEN12610648.446.42256
Jim Everett1989RAM30425868.517.67255
Russell Wilson2013SEA25718047.026.03254
Vinny Testaverde1996BAL32523807.326.54254
Drew Bledsoe2005DAL30022207.406.55254
Aaron Brooks2002NOR28320517.256.35254
Drew Bledsoe1994NWE40028887.226.59254
Jake Plummer2004DEN30323607.796.95253
Aaron Brooks2004NOR30924017.776.95253
Deshaun Watson2017HOU12610148.056.05252
Tom Flores1966OAK1511582.810.488.82251
Otto Graham1953CLE1671633.29.788.28250
Andrew Luck2014IND38024956.575.91250
Drew Brees2012NOR42229096.896.30250
Vinny Testaverde1988TAM22219448.767.63249
Jim Hart1967STL1921804.89.408.11249
Matt Moore2011MIA21015967.606.42249
Joe Ferguson1981BUF2522191.28.707.71248
Mark Sanchez2009NYJ19614267.286.01247
Jay Cutler2013CHI22415977.136.03246
Warren Moon1993HOU30323027.606.79246
Bubby Brister1988PIT1751580.49.037.63244
Matt Barkley2016CHI12910488.126.23244
Russell Wilson2016SEA35324446.926.23243
Kerry Collins2010TEN16012177.616.09243
Matt Ryan2016ATL37325676.886.23242
Jay Schroeder1988RAI1131103.49.767.63241
Marc Bulger2003STL33623757.076.35240
Colin Kaepernick2012SFO13610978.076.30240
Cam Newton2014CAR26217886.825.91240
Joe Namath1967NYJ2582404.29.328.40238
Philip Rivers2008SDG31221696.956.19237
Carson Palmer2013ARI36224206.696.03237
Marc Bulger2005STL19214957.796.55237
Michael Vick2011PHI25318597.356.42236
Tony Romo2014DAL30420316.685.91235
Rodney Peete1992DET12311149.067.15234
Rodney Peete2002CAR22316507.406.35234
Johnny Lujack1949CHI1621594.89.848.40233
Sonny Jurgensen1962PHI1961956.69.988.79233
Brett Favre1997GNB30423367.686.92233
Jay Schroeder1989RAI9193010.227.67232
Johnny Unitas1960BAL1901859.49.798.57232
Dan Fouts1980SDG34828298.137.46232
Carson Palmer2017ARI16312177.476.05232
Trent Green2001KAN29621517.276.49231
David Garrard2007JAX20815427.416.31231
Vince Young2010TEN937958.556.09229
Eli Manning2008NYG28920186.986.19229

Carson Palmer and Bruce Arians were a deep throwing match made in heaven, and Palmer’s 2015 MVP caliber season stands as the gold standard of gunslinging (compared to league average, at least). As Chase has written, Arians will be coaching Jameis Winston next season on what promises to be an aerial extravaganza Tampa Bay squad. In fact, all four of Winston’s NFL seasons rank in the top 10 mAir campaigns of all time, so I wouldn’t be surprised if he sets a new record in 2019.

The Randy Moss effect is clearly at work on this list, as three different Vikings quarterbacks appear in the top 35 during Moss’ first three years in the league (not to mention coaxing a long ball explosion out of Kerry Collins in 2005). Brady ’07 also makes the list, although it’s lower down than you might expect.

It’s worth noting that Joe Namath’s 1972 season makes the top 40 despite completing far fewer passes than most of the quarterbacks ahead of him. Namath is certainly in the conversation for best deep passer of all time. Chase’s pinned tweet touches on how different the modern game is from the ’72 Jets.

And now the 200 lowest Marginal Air Yards seasons of all time:

QuarterbackYearTeamCompAirYrdAir/CmpLgAvgMrgAir
David Carr2006HOU30211983.976.31-709
Christian Ponder2012MIN30012224.076.30-669
Sam Bradford2016MIN39518414.666.23-621
Matthew Stafford2015DET39818604.676.17-596
Brett Favre1993GNB31815684.936.79-590
Tom Brady2002NWE37317824.786.35-587
Sam Bradford2010STL35415704.446.09-585
Philip Rivers2015SDG43721134.846.17-583
Jay Cutler2014CHI37016384.435.91-548
Fran Tarkenton1978MIN3452080.86.037.58-533
Joe Flacco2016BAL43621935.036.23-525
Jason Campbell2009WAS32714574.466.01-510
Mark Rypien1993WAS1666233.756.79-503
Joey Harrington2003DET30914674.756.35-496
Brett Favre1992GNB30216665.527.15-495
Brett Favre1994GNB36319065.256.59-485
Donovan McNabb2000PHI33016865.116.56-477
Joe Flacco2017BAL35216544.706.05-474
Drew Bledsoe2000NWE31215745.046.56-471
Alex Smith2014KAN30313234.375.91-467
Alex Smith2016KAN32815814.826.23-464
Drew Brees2007NOR44023115.256.31-463
Philip Rivers2012SDG33816674.936.30-463
Chad Henne2013JAX30513784.526.03-461
Matt Hasselbeck2009SEA29313044.456.01-458
Sam Bradford2015PHI34616774.856.17-458
Jon Kitna2000SEA25912474.816.56-451
Matt Cassel2008NWE32715774.826.19-447
Matthew Stafford2018DET36717394.745.95-443
Steve DeBerg1979SFO3472191.26.317.59-443
Brett Favre2008NYJ34316934.946.19-431
Ryan Fitzpatrick2011BUF35318365.206.42-429
Joey Harrington2004DET27414775.396.95-428
Ryan Fitzpatrick2012BUF30615144.956.30-414
Josh Freeman2011TAM34618065.226.42-414
Shaun Hill2010DET25711524.486.09-412
Carson Wentz2016PHI37919515.156.23-412
Frank Tripucka1961DEN16710146.078.52-409
Blake Bortles2014JAX28012464.455.91-409
Matt Ryan2013ATL43922395.106.03-408
Brett Favre2006GNB34317645.146.31-402
Shane Matthews1999CHI1677234.336.70-396
Jason Campbell2008WAS31515594.956.19-391
Ben Roethlisberger2018PIT45222985.085.95-390
Teddy Bridgewater2015MIN29214154.856.17-387
Drew Brees2017NOR38619495.056.05-385
Boomer Esiason1992CIN1446464.497.15-384
Alex Smith2013KAN30814784.806.03-379
Alex Smith2015KAN30715154.936.17-379
Bobby Hoying1998PHI1144323.797.09-376
Drew Brees2003SDG2059274.526.35-376
Brad Johnson2006MIN27013314.936.31-374
Bruce Gradkowski2006TAM1777504.246.31-368
David Klingler1993CIN1909264.876.79-363
Bobby Hebert1996ATL29415655.326.54-358
Brandon Weeden2012CLE29715145.106.30-358
Steve Young1995SFO29916035.366.56-358
Jeff George1991IND29217465.987.20-356
Drew Brees2002SDG32016785.246.35-354
Eli Manning2016NYG37719965.296.23-354
Tommy Kramer1979MIN3152038.26.477.59-353
Brett Hundley2017GNB1928134.236.05-348
Derek Carr2014OAK34817094.915.91-347
Billy Wade1964CHI1821166.46.418.32-347
Peyton Manning1998IND32619656.037.09-346
Aaron Rodgers2015GNB34717965.186.17-345
Tom Brady2001NWE26413695.196.49-343
Joe Flacco2015BAL26613034.906.17-338
Joe Montana1994KAN29916355.476.59-334
Brett Favre2005GNB37221055.666.55-333
Matt Hasselbeck2011TEN31917185.396.42-329
Boomer Esiason1993NYJ28816265.656.79-328
Kelly Holcomb2005BUF1556884.446.55-328
Rich Gannon2002OAK41823285.576.35-327
Joe Ferguson1983BUF28117976.407.55-324
Boomer Esiason1994NYJ25513565.326.59-323
Matthew Stafford2016DET38820995.416.23-320
Charlie Frye2006CLE25212735.056.31-318
Blaine Gabbert2011JAX21010334.926.42-314
Nick Foles2015STL1908584.526.17-314
Tom Flores1961OAK1901305.66.878.52-313
Robert Griffin2014WAS1475563.785.91-313
Jeff Garcia2002SFO32817715.406.35-312
Ryan Fitzpatrick2008CIN22110574.786.19-311
Sonny Jurgensen1969WAS2741861.26.797.93-311
Bobby Thomason1951GNB125783.66.278.75-310
Frank Tripucka1962DEN2401750.27.298.57-307
Roman Gabriel1974PHI1931120.25.807.38-305
Joey Harrington2007ATL21510554.916.31-301
Tony Banks1998STL24114095.857.09-300
Eric Hipple1986DET1921151.46.007.56-300
Jon Kitna2010DAL2099744.666.09-298
Brian Griese2001DEN27514865.406.49-298
Eli Manning2017NYG35218315.206.05-297
Kyle Boller2004BAL25814985.816.95-296
Billy Wade1963CHI1921380.67.198.72-294
Daunte Culpepper2004MIN37923416.186.95-294
David Carr2005HOU25613845.416.55-294
Jim Miller2001CHI22811875.216.49-292
Greg Landry1979BAL2701759.26.527.59-290
Frank Tripucka19522TM91485.45.338.52-290
George Blanda1964HOU2621972.27.538.63-289
Blake Bortles2016JAX36820075.456.23-287
Chris Weinke2001CAR29316145.516.49-286
Mark Brunell2006WAS1627384.566.31-285
Kyle Orton2009DEN33617375.176.01-284
Fran Tarkenton1975MIN2731796.46.587.62-283
Kyle Boller2009STL983073.136.01-282
Doug Pederson2000CLE1174864.156.56-281
Bubby Brister1995NYJ933303.556.56-280
Frankie Albert1950SFO1551060.26.848.64-279
Mickey Slaughter1964DEN975585.758.63-279
Koy Detmer1998PHI974104.237.09-278
Len Dawson1972KAN17511016.297.87-277
Steve Walsh1994CHI20810955.266.59-275
Dan Pastorini1973HOU154889.25.777.55-273
Kyle Orton2014BUF28714234.965.91-273
Steve McNair2007BAL1335684.276.31-271
Dave Krieg1996CHI22612105.356.54-268
Brad Johnson2001TAM34019385.706.49-267
Boomer Esiason1995NYJ22111825.356.56-267
Case Keenum2017MIN32516985.226.05-267
Ken Stabler1980HOU2931921.26.567.46-266
Vinny Testaverde2001NYJ26014215.476.49-265
Steve Bono1996KAN23512735.426.54-264
Neil Lomax1986STL2401549.86.467.56-264
Kelly Holcomb2003CLE1939644.996.35-262
Jim McMahon1993MIN20010955.486.79-262
Ken O'Brien1988NYJ2361540.26.537.63-261
Y.A. Tittle1950BAL1611130.47.028.64-261
Mike Livingston1978KAN159943.85.947.58-261
Steve Young1997SFO24114075.846.92-260
Andrew Luck2013IND34318085.276.03-260
Joe Montana1981SFO31121396.887.71-259
Blake Bortles2018JAX24311914.905.95-254
Norm Van Brocklin1958PHI1981445.47.308.58-254
Steve McNair2005TEN29216625.696.55-252
Joe Ferguson1984BUF1911194.66.257.57-251
Terry Bradshaw1971PIT2031355.46.687.90-249
Dan Darragh1968BUF92550.25.988.68-248
Jack Concannon1970CHI19412786.597.87-248
Andy Dalton2014CIN30915795.115.91-247
Fran Tarkenton1971NYG2261540.26.827.90-246
Cam Newton2018CAR32016575.185.95-246
Carson Palmer2012OAK34519305.596.30-244
Rick Mirer1993SEA27416155.896.79-244
Bobby Hebert1988NOR2801893.66.767.63-244
Norm Snead1968PHI1529936.538.13-243
Jimmy Clausen2010CAR1577134.546.09-243
Y.A. Tittle1957SFO1761294.27.358.72-241
Richard Todd1983NYJ3082086.86.787.55-238
Joe Montana1980SFO17610776.127.46-237
Ryan Tannehill2014MIA39220805.315.91-236
Kordell Stewart1999PIT1608365.236.70-236
Joey Harrington2002DET21511305.266.35-235
Jack Kemp1969BUF1701188.66.998.38-235
Kirk Cousins2018MIN42522925.395.95-235
Donovan McNabb2001PHI28516145.666.49-235
Brad Johnson2005MIN1849735.296.55-233
David Klingler1994CIN1316304.816.59-233
Nick Foles2012PHI1617864.886.30-229
John Brodie1965SFO2421867.27.728.66-229
Bill Munson1965RAM1441020.67.098.66-226
Sonny Jurgensen1965WAS1901420.27.478.66-225
Bobby Layne1949NYY1551077.66.958.40-225
Jim Kelly1987BUF2501678.86.727.61-224
Jeff Garcia2001SFO31618275.786.49-223
Brian Griese2004TAM23313986.006.95-222
Len Dawson1963KAN1901433.47.548.71-221
Brett Favre2007GNB35620245.696.31-221
Joe Theismann1985WAS1671064.46.377.69-220
Jack Concannon1969CHI87469.85.407.93-220
Rich Gannon1998KAN20612416.027.09-220
Derek Carr2018OAK38120465.375.95-219
Rich Gannon1991MIN2111299.66.167.20-219
Gary Huff1975CHI114649.85.707.62-218
Steve Fuller1979KAN146890.46.107.59-218
Alex Smith2006SFO25714055.476.31-218
Jeff Blake2000NOR1849905.386.56-216
Randall Cunningham1992PHI23314516.237.15-216
John Brodie1960SFO103666.66.478.57-216
Jake Delhomme2006CAR26314455.496.31-216
Shane Matthews2000CHI1024554.466.56-214
Roman Gabriel1966RAM21715247.028.01-213
Tom Brady2006NWE31918015.656.31-213
Joe Namath1976NYJ1146545.747.60-213
Richard Todd1981NYJ2791938.66.957.71-212
Milt Plum1965DET14310267.178.66-212
Brad Johnson2000WAS22812835.636.56-212
Danny Kanell1998NYG1609245.787.09-210
Steve Spurrier1976TAM156976.86.267.60-209
Greg Landry1977DET135815.46.047.59-209
Sam Bradford2013STL1597504.726.03-209
Kordell Stewart1998PIT25215786.267.09-209
Dave Krieg1989SEA2861985.46.947.67-208
Elvis Grbac1995SFO1276254.926.56-208
Chuck Long1987DET2321558.86.727.61-207
Jack Trudeau1986IND20413356.547.56-207
Rich Gannon2001OAK36121355.916.49-206
Andy Dalton2012CIN32918675.676.30-206

This list is populated by the quarterbacks you’d expect (David Carr, Sam Bradford, Joey Harrington, Alex Smith), but there are also some surprises. A number of HOF caliber QBs had at least one season of super short passing, including Tom Brady, Philip Rivers, Drew Brees, Fran Tarkenton, and several appearances from Brett Favre. Similar to Stafford defying his gunslinger reputation in today’s NFL, Favre embodied the west coast offense early in his career by offsetting his highlight reel plays with a bevy of completions at or behind the line of scrimmage. Oh, and three different Fitzpatrick seasons make this list, showing how different his playing style used to be.

What stands out to you?

{ 1 comment }