A few years ago, I looked at the career leaders in rushing yards over 50 yards in a game. I like doing this because it helps remove less material games and places more of an emphasis on dominance. A player with 16 games of 70 rushing yards has 1,120 rushing yards but only 320 rushing yards over 50 yards per game. On the other hand, a player with 8 games of 25 rushing yards and 8 games of 95 rushing yards maybe was a backup for half the season; he would have only 960 rushing yards but 360 rushing yards over 50 yards per game.
One player who excels in this metric is Ezekiel Elliott, who obviously missed six games due to suspension and therefore ranked only 10th in rushing yards. But Elliott hit 80 or more yards in 9 of 10 games — in fact, he’s rushed for at least 80 yards in a remarkable 23 of 25 career games (and also did it in his sole playoff game) — which means he fares very well in this formulation. In fact, he ranks 4th by this metric, and was the only rusher in 2016 to have over half of his rushing yards come after already rushing for 50 yards in a game.
On the other side of things, you have players like Lamar Miller and Frank Gore. Miller ranked 16th in rushing yards with a respectable 888-yard season, but his season high was just 75 yards. He was a consistent player — in 11 of 16 games he rushed for between 50 and 65 yards — but in no way was he a dominant one. Gore had 961 rushing yards, good enough for 12th place, but he ranked only 23rd in rushing yards over 50. Gore had two big games in December to boost his numbers: but in the first 12 games of the season, Gore finished with between 34 and 62 rushing yards in 11 games. A very consistent runner, yes, but a dominant runner? No.
The full results below:
Two players who had mediocre rushing numbers but better dominance metrics were Adrian Peterson and Kenyon Drake. Peterson ranked 39th in rushing yards but 21st in rushing yards over 50, just ahead of Gore. Peterson had a 159-yard game, a 134-yard game, and a 79-yard game with Arizona, but didn’t do much else. That’s a sign that there might still be something left in Peterson’s (soon-to-be) 33-year-old body, although the rest of his season was a disaster. As for Drake, he only started 6 games, but he actually led the NFL in rushing yards in December. So while Drake ranked “only” 29th in rushing yards, he was 19th in rushing yards over 50. That’s probably a better way to measure how dominant he was in 2017.